Skip to main content

Oracle wants a new trial after accusing Google of ‘lying,’ now funding an anti-Google group

google canada free speech case gavel flickr
Joe Gratz/Flickr
Oracle, it’s safe to say, is a bit perturbed about the $9 billion judgment against Google it was not awarded earlier this year. Larry Ellison’s software empire, you may recall, is embroiled in an ongoing legal battle with the search giant over the originality of the latter’s Android operating system, and things, you might say, just got real. On Wednesday, Oracle’s legal team accused Google of “withholding” information regarding the availability of Android apps on platforms other than smartphones. And most recently, it’s been revealed that Oracle has been funding “The Google Transparency Project,” which is in short, an anti-Google group.

Updated on 8-21-2016 by Lulu Chang: Oracle funding an anti-Google non-profit 

The non-profit alleges it exposes “various villainies carried out by the search giant,” Fortune reports. And Ken Glueck, Senior Vice President of Oracle, is not backing away from their part in the Project. “Oracle is absolutely a contributor (one of many) to the Transparency Project. This is important information for the public to know. It is 100 percent public records and accurate,” he said.

As for the ongoing legal battle, counsel for Oracle requested a new, third hearing regarding the issue at hand: whether or not Google, in building Android, copied bits and pieces of the Java Standard Edition source code that Oracle acquired from Sun Microsystems in 2010. The reason? Lawyers for the company contend that Google knowingly, concertedly concealed a pertinent fact during the last trial which, they argue, swayed its outcome: that Android apps were coming to Google’s Chromebook-branded laptops and desktops.

It was an open secret, really. Google launched ARC, or App Runtime for Chrome, which allowed developers to convert off-the-shelf Android apps to versions compatible with Chrome OS, last year in beta. And during the companies’ last courtroom encounter, Google’s lawyers volunteered ARC’s documentation and development history. But what Google failed to mention, Oracle said, was that it was developing a system alongside ARC that would accomplish much the same — translating Android apps into a form that Chrome OS can understand — more efficiently.

It was unveiled at the company’s developer I/O developer conference in May. Google announced that the Play Store — the apps marketplace available on Android devices — would hit Chromebooks running Chrome OS version 37 and higher “later in the year.” And it told reporters in attendance that a new compatibility layer made the integration possible.

“We have redone this completely differently,” Zelidrag Hornung, engineering director of Chrome and Android, told Ars Technica. “There are no connecting points between [ARC] and [the new system] from an implementation perspective.”

That’s what has Oracle’s feathers ruffled. Lawyers for the company content that Google’s expert witnesses “lied” when they told the jury that Android ran strictly on smartphones, tablets, and other portable devices — and not the desktop machines traditionally associated with Java Standard Edition.

“They were perpetuating a fraud on the jury,” Oracle attorney Annette Hurst told presiding Judge William Alsup. “This was a shock to the industry and to us.”

As Vice’s Motherboard points out, though, Chrome OS is far from the only platform to which Android has expanded since Oracle’s battle with the search giant began four years ago. 2014 saw the debut of both Android TV, Google’s operating system for set-top boxes, and Android Wear, a slimmed-down OS designed to run on smartwatches, wristbands, and other forms of wearables.

That fact didn’t escape mention at this week’s hearing, either. Google attorney Christa Anderson, responding to a question by Judge Alsup about Oracle’s legal standing, said that the company was entitled to sue over every and all forms of Android — including Android TV, Android Wear, and Android apps on Chrome OS. And she left open the possibility that Android Nougat, the newest version of Android, could be included in a new suit, too. That would be particularly problematic for Google: Nougat supports Java version 8 by using, presumably, the same code over which Oracle sued Google in the first place.

But Oracle isn’t the only one throwing a hissy fit. Google’s legal team has filed for “a finding of civil contempt and sanctions against Oracle,” and $3.9 million in court costs. A hearing over those complaints begins on September 22.

Editors' Recommendations

Kyle Wiggers
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Kyle Wiggers is a writer, Web designer, and podcaster with an acute interest in all things tech. When not reviewing gadgets…
Google enforces its 30% tax for app makers who want to sell on the Play Store
Google Pixel 4a Front

Google is cracking down on app makers who have been evading Android’s app store tax. The company has updated its policy to enforce the 30% cut it requires developers to pay if they want to sell and distribute their apps on the Google Play Store.

This isn’t a new development. But over the years, many companies like Spotify, due to Google’s lax guidelines, have managed to circumvent this tax by offering their own payment systems.

Read more
Google is shutting down your Chromebook apps, but here’s why you shouldn’t worry
pixelbook go hands on features price photos video release date google hero

The focus of Chromebooks has always been the Chrome web browser. Apps were always an afterthought, and ever since Google introduced the Android Play Store to Chrome OS, users have had three different ways to experience apps on their Chromebooks.

First, there are Chrome Apps, which are specially packaged and run inside the Chrome web browser. These are the ones Google is shutting down, with a final shutdown date set for 2022.

Read more
Google teases Thunderbolt 3 support for Chromebooks in new code commit
thunderbolt 3 could be coming to chromebooks

Chromebooks could soon support a feature that has long been present on competing Windows 10 laptops and MacBooks. According to a very specific new commit from the Chromium Repositories, Google might be working to add support for Thunderbolt 3 to ChromeOS, and perhaps newer Chromebook devices.

If this commit holds up, heading into the future, Chromebook users might be able to enjoy a list of abilities and benefits long familiar to others with Macbooks or Windows laptops. That includes support for a wider range of external monitors, as well as docking stations, and faster data transfer rates when copying files to and from Chromebooks.

Read more