Skip to main content

Samsung’s smartphone ban not likely to last

Samsung-Galaxy S II

There’s another wrinkle in the Samsung v. Apple battle that’s already provided us with a whole lot of entertaining controversy. There’s discussion afoot that Apple’s big legal victory – getting Galaxy phones banned through the European Union for copyright infringement – may be as toothless as a twenty-year-old cat.

Apple’s copyright lawsuit concerned a whole mess of things, namely physical design elements of the Galaxy phones as well as specific UI features, like the slide-to-unlock gesture. While Apple did indeed succeed in getting an injunction barring Samsung from selling Galaxy phones in the EU, most of Apple’s claims were actually thrown out in court. It seems that the court ruled Samsung only violated a single Apple patent, and avoiding infringement of that patent is only an Android update away.

Some of the most crucial aspects of the suit concerned Samsung’s physical design of the Galaxy lineup. While reworking infringing software would be a massive pain, it can at least be ported onto existed devices. But had Samsung’s phone design been ruled in violation of Apple’s patents, basically its entire stock of Galaxy phones would be immediately bricked. That’s a huge problem.

But according to OS News, corroborated by the Inquirer, the judge threw out everything design-related, citing numerous cases of prior art that predated the iPhone, including the Compaq TC1x00 and LG Prada. Additionally, the judge threw out claims over the Android’s GUI, citing the Nokia 7710 as prior art.

Apple’s claim over the swipe-to-unlock gesture was interesting because it seems like such an integral part of any smartphone. The judge said he expected the claim over that gesture would get tossed out in what’s called a ‘bottom procedure,’ which is a more in-depth case focusing more closely on a specific item. In this case, he referenced the Neonode N1m phone, which was released in 2005, as prior art.

The only patent the judge upheld, and the one thing allowing the injunction to go through, concerns the method of scrolling through photos in Android’s Gallery app. The judge did rule that Samsung’s Android 2.x devices infringe on Apple’s patent, but Android 3.0 does not. The injunction thus affects the Galaxy S, SII and Ace smartphones, but not the Galaxy Tab, which uses 3.0. The injunction won’t go into effect until mid-October. That gives Samsung plenty of time to push out an update to its smartphone lineup using a version of Android 3.0 that has changes to the Gallery, a move the company has already promised to do. So while it’s a technical win for Apple, Samsung should come out unscathed.

Editors' Recommendations

Derek Mead
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Usually $600, the Samsung Galaxy Tab S7 FE is $130 off at Best Buy
Samsung Galaxy Tab S7 feat image.

The Samsung Galaxy Tab S7 FE is currently on sale from Best Buy, with the model offering 128GB of storage and 6GB of RAM available for just $470 following the retailer's $130 discount on its sticker price of $600. This is one of the most attractive tablet deals in the market right now, but time is running out if you want to take advantage of it. The device's price goes back to normal at the end of the day, so you shouldn't waste time if you want to purchase it.

Why you should buy the Samsung Galaxy Tab S7 FE
The Samsung Galaxy Tab S7 FE, is a new version of the Samsung Galaxy Tab S7 Plus as it's equipped with the same 12.4-inch touchscreen with 2560 x 1600 pixel resolution, instead of the 11-inch touchscreen of the Samsung Galaxy Tab S7. The Samsung Galaxy Tab S7 FE, however, has a TFT screen, and not the Super AMOLED display with a 120Hz refresh rate that's found in the Samsung Galaxy Tab S7 Plus and Samsung Galaxy Tab S7. That's an acceptable trade-off for the tablet's lower price though, especially if you'll only be using the device for watching streaming content, playing games, and browsing the internet.

Read more
Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 5: everything we know and what we want to see
samsung galaxy z fold 5 release date price specs news leaked render front back

Samsung is the top dog for foldable phones, and in 2023, all eyes are on what the company will do with the Galaxy Z Fold 5. This will be Samsung's fifth attempt at a flagship folding smartphone, and this year, it'll be entering an unusually competitive market.

Google is launching the Pixel Fold in June, OnePlus is expected to release its first foldable phone this year, and there's mounting competition from the likes of Huawei and Honor. So, how will Samsung ensure it stands out from the crowd? Here's everything we currently know about the Galaxy Z Fold 5.
Samsung Galaxy Z Fold 5: design

Read more
The Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra looks like one of 2023’s most exciting tablets
Render of the Samsung Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra.

Android tablet fans, buckle up. We've finally gotten our first look at the Galaxy Tab S9 Ultra via a handful of leaked renders, and it looks like it might be a worthy successor to the Galaxy Tab S8 Ultra.

First shared in one of MySmartPrice's frequent collaborations with OnLeaks, the design of the Tab S9 Ultra is following in the footsteps of its predecessor with an absolutely massive screen.

Read more