Skip to main content

Suits Start Over Apple iPhone 4 Antenna

Digital Trends

Kevin McCaffrey and Linda Wrinn of Maryland have had enough of the iPhone 4 experiencing significant signal loss if held in particular ways, and they’re not going to take it anymore: the two have filed a lawsuit against Apple accusing the company of deceptive trade practices, fraud, negligence, and breach of implied warranty. The suit also targets iPhone carrier AT&T. The plaintiffs want unspecified financial recompense for the issue, as well as an injunction preventing Apple from selling the iPhone 4 until the antenna issue is resolved.

The suit is just he latest chapter in the ongoing headache Apple is experiencing with iPhone 4 reception: if the phone is held in particular ways—with a hand or finger making contact with the phone’s lower left-hand corner and antenna—the phone can experience significant signal drop. For some users in some locations, the impact of the signal drop isn’t a problem, but for folks in areas with spotty mobile reception, it can make the difference between staying on a call and having the call dropped.

Apple didn’t help matters by suggesting iPhone 4 users buy a case or hold differently, and avoid contact with the lower left corner of the phone if they experience signal loss. Apple’s own promotional materials for the iPhone 4 show users handling the device in ways that would result signal loss.

The iPhone 4 is not the first mobile device to experience significant signal loss caused by users’ hands, but the media attention surrounding the phone’s release and spectacular sales have fueled the controversy and public perception of the problem’s magnitude. Other phone makers—like Nokia—have been using the issue to promote their own devices.

McCaffrey and Wrinn’s lawsuit may just be the first of many to come. Other industry reports have additional suits being filed against Apple over the antenna issue, including one demanding Apple offer impacted customers free cases or bumpers to prevent users’ hands from coming in contact with the iPhone 4’s antenna ports,

Editors' Recommendations

Geoff Duncan
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Geoff Duncan writes, programs, edits, plays music, and delights in making software misbehave. He's probably the only member…
iOS 18’s new iMessage features make me wish everyone I know had an iPhone
Screenshots of new iMessage features in iOS 18.

Without fail, one thing always happens during the iOS segment at Apple’s Worldwide Developer Conference (WWDC): I have a moment where I want more people I know to own an iPhone and use iMessage because it always looks a whole lot more fun than my usual message apps.

It’s not evidence of iMessage being generally superior, though; it’s about something else. And this was especially true at WWDC 2024.
There's something about iMessage

Read more
iOS 18 makes an 11-year-old iPhone feature exciting again
Someone holding an iPhone 14, showing the Lock Screen.

Following the Worldwide Developers Conference (WWDC 2024) keynote, developers are starting to dig into the first iOS 18 developer beta. Though this beta lacks Apple Intelligence and many of the other features demoed on Monday, it offers a surprising new take on an old iOS feature: the flashlight.

The built-in flashlight feature has been available on the iPhone since iOS 7, which was released in 2013. It hasn't changed much at all since then, which makes sense, given its basic function. Interestingly, it has received a significant update in iOS 18.

Read more
The 5 biggest things missing from WWDC 2024
A person holding the Apple iPhone 15 Plus and Apple iPhone 15 Pro Max.

Apple iPhone 15 Pro Max (left) and Apple iPhone 15 Plus Andy Boxall / Digital Trends

Apple kicked off WWDC 2024 with a bang by introducing big updates to iOS 18, iPadOS 18, watchOS 11, macOS 15, and visionOS 2. It even revealed Apple Intelligence, which is its on-device AI across multiple platforms that gives users a much improved Siri and other helpful AI tools. But for as much as Apple did announce, there were plenty of things the company didn't announce. Here are the five biggest missing announcements from WWDC 2024.
An iOS redesign

Read more