Skip to main content

The Sandman and Peacemaker were 2022’s best comic book adaptations

The comic book medium and superhero genre have undoubtedly maintained their places in the highest tiers of pop culture thanks to their efforts in film and television, and there certainly have been plenty of great shows competing for audience subscription dollars in the TV streaming space. Disney and Marvel Studios’ MCU has taken the genre to new heights in live-action TV — for better and worse — by pumping Disney+ with several original shows in the last couple of years.

However, even though Marvel had the occasional standout production, it was arguably Netflix and HBO Max that had the best comic book adaptations of the year with The Sandman and Peacemaker, respectively. While wildly different in tone and subject matter, both shows shared the same refreshing dose of creative ingenuity that made them wildly entertaining.

The Sandman: successfully adapting the “unadaptable”

The titular Endless surrounded by his supporting cast in The Sandman.

In the world of comics, Neil Gaiman is a respected name. He’s provided some of the best work in the medium and has lent his talents to various well-known characters such as the Fantastic Four. The Sandman is commonly regarded as his magnum opus, but he’s also written Batman, which shows his versatility in both original works and longstanding IPs.

When it comes to The Sandman, many have long thought of this comic book master class of a story to be challenging, if not impossible, to adapt to another medium. Much of this series is defined by abstract and surreal visuals on top of the nuanced storytelling and character arcs.

Gaiman had been working on getting an adaptation off the ground for many years now, depite the massive weight of expectation behind the source material.

And while it’s an undoubtedly big name in the “streaming wars,” Netflix hasn’t exactly inspired confidence that quality and faithfulness would be a guarantee for something as layered as The Sandman, but — mercifully — that’s what the final product ended up delivering. Of course, it likely helps that Gaiman himself ensured his property would be treated with respect.

Dream with Lucienne in The Sandman.

The Sandman has succeeded in what was once seen as impossible, putting to screen a world that’s as visually imaginative as the comic book series that inspired it. Even if a few episodes toward the end of the first season somewhat tapered off compared to the bigger story arcs that came before it, there was an enticing sense of wonder in seeing Dream travel to different locales and meet with characters in an anthology-style narrative structure.

That episodic formula did well to show pockets of this corner of the DC world in ways that were in service to those isolated stories, while still feeding into grander themes and the character journey of Dream himself. The Sandman is a poignant story of learning to adapt to the times, as well as being willing to embrace growth within oneself.

Among the main cast, the performances were outstanding, with Tom Sturridge being a highlight in adapting such an ethereal and larger-than-life figure, while also rooting the protagonist’s budding sense of humanity. You can also tell how much fun the creative team behind the scenes had with taking spins on these characters, as other members of the Endless like Kirby Howell-Baptiste’s Death and villains like Gwendoline Christie’s Lucifer provided some of the show’s most engaging episodes thanks to their respective charms.

It’s been a roller coaster waiting to see if Netflix would give the show the season 2 renewal it deserves or would prematurely ace this one too, but it’s great to see that the show will go on with this passion project.

Peacemaker: the show no one knew they wanted

Peacemaker promo featuring John Cena as the titular antihero.

The soon-to-be DCU under co-CEOs James Gunn and Peter Safran is currently going under heavy renovations, especially with the recent news of Henry Cavill being dropped as Superman, but Gunn has already proven — across Marvel and DC — to have a reverence for the source material and a knack for character work.

Following the critically panned 2016 Suicide Squad movie, Gunn was brought on board to helm a loose sequel that keeps the same general continuity while serving as a fresh starting point for newcomers. The movie was well-received and was essentially what Gunn achieved with his Guardians of the Galaxymovies in the MCU: a comedic action adventure about a group of unlikely protagonists and misfits.

It was all it needed to be, but the most surprising aspect of The Suicide Squad was how it spawned a spinoff TV series starring John Cena’s seemingly deplorable antihero Peacemaker. The show’s first eight-episode season garnered critical acclaim, showing the unexpected “dramedy” acting prowess of Cena as an actor.

Peacemaker promo featuring the show's main cast.

Peacemaker, and perhaps the TV format in general, debatably to have gotten the best out of Gunn, as the raunchy humor and heartfelt character dynamics were all there, but felt even bolder in terms of social commentary than his successful theatrical ventures. Cena’s protagonist is presented early on as a hypocritical menace, but the show brilliantly spins out into a story of meaningful introspection.

The rest of his supporting cast and equally unlikely team members also stood out as Peacemaker told an effective and rewarding isolated story within the vast DC multiverse that didn’t concern itself with being a commercial for someone else’s show — while also not divorcing itself from the wider universe.

It’s the “superhero” show no one saw coming, and the show that no one knew that they wanted, and we’ll akk be looking forward to how season 2 follows up on the satisfying character arcs Peacemaker‘s debut season fleshed out.

Standing above the rest

A giant cat with glowing eyes sits in The Sandman.

Even outside of the superhero genre specifically, it’s easy to look at the past couple of years’ worth of big franchise IP TV shows and feel cynical. Several of the MCU Phase 4 series felt either padded out, cut too short, or simply unnecessary, and the same could be said for some of Lucasfilm’s corner of Disney+ with the mega-franchise that is Star Wars.

However, what The Sandman and Peacemaker mean in the medium, at least for comic book adaptations, is that there is still room for inventiveness in this genre on the small screen.

These two shows are wildly different in tone and concept, but they’re examples of how wonderfully strange these kinds of stories can be on their own merits.

You can stream The Sandman on Netflix, while Peacemaker is currently streaming on HBO Max.

Editors' Recommendations

Guillermo Kurten
Freelance Writer, Entertainment
A University of Houston graduate in Print Media Journalism, Guillermo has covered sports entertainment and practically all…
Batman’s live-action future should be on HBO, not on the big screen
Robert Pattinson as the Dark Knight in red promo art for The Batman.

Matt Reeves' recent Dark Knight venture is the third major live-action rendition of the character in the last 10 years, and while it seems like a lot to already be thinking about what comes after The Batman movies, Warner Bros. Discovery and DC could do well to look to TV for the next take's future.

That might be asking a lot, especially considering the company's chaotic merger laying waste to a slew of streaming projects and DC's reputation for its use of Batman -- and lack thereof -- in the live-action TV space. However, while The Batman is an exciting fresh start for a detective-focused, neo-noir Gotham City, a shakeup in the medium of choice could give the next long-term reboot a new and tantalizing creative angle through the HBO brand.
A change of pace from the theatrical format

Read more
Forget The Batman: Mask of the Phantasm is still the best Batman movie adaptation
Batman spreading his cape in the Mask of the Phantasm poster.

Matt Reeves' The Batman finally brought to the live-action theatrical space an iteration of DC Comics' beloved, brooding superhero that honed in on the crime-noir detective aspect of the character, but Mask of the Phantasm still reigns supreme as being the truest to the character.

It's the first time a live-action adaptation made his "World's Greatest Detective" epithet just as important as being the "Dark Knight," even if Robert Pattinson's grimy and grounded take is still learning what his symbol should mean. However, Mask of the Phantasm -- and the animated universe Paul Dini and Bruce Timm co-created that paved the way for it -- remains the deepest dive into what makes Batman tick while honoring his swathes of comic book mythos.
The Batman brand of "dark deco"

Read more
Is Netflix the right home for The Sandman?
The Sandman sitting in a chair in all black looking serious from The Sandman on Netflix.

The Sandman, Neil Gaiman's iconic and seminal exploration of dreams, fantasy, and the occult, is getting a lush adaptation on Netflix. Famously described by Norman Mailer as "a comic strip for intellectuals," The Sandman is among the finest pieces of storytelling and artistry we've seen in the comic book genre. It is famously challenging, thought-provoking, philosophical, and unwilling -- or perhaps unable -- to confine itself in any given category. Like its famously elusive protagonist, The Sandman flows, twists, and turns throughout a story that remains engaging, even if it is not always approachable.

Reviews for the show have been strong out of the gate; it currently sits at an impressive 86% on Rotten Tomatoes. Critics call it loyal to a fault to its source material, praising its production values, ambition, and willingness to bring Gaiman's vision to life. The Sandman's positive reception is a win in and of itself; like Alan Moore's Watchmen, Gaiman's graphic novel was often considered too unyielding for a traditional adaptation. The word "unfilmable" often accompanied its title, despite several attempts to bring it into live action.

Read more