Skip to main content

His Dark Materials review: HBO’s must-see series is a dark, beautiful adaptation

His Dark Materials: Season 1 | Official Trailer | HBO

In the lead-up to the series finale of Game of Thrones, there was plenty of speculation about what the future might hold for HBO after one of the most popular shows of all time comes to an end. The network calmed subscribers’ fears with the recent, well-received Watchmen series, and now the upcoming His Dark Materials series add another stunning project to HBO’s post-Game of Thrones offerings.

Recommended Videos

Digital Trends was given an early look at the first four episodes of His Dark Materials, which comprise the first half of the show’s debut season. A second season has already been ordered for the show, which delivers a wonderfully compelling story filled with impressive visual effects and praiseworthy performances in its first four episodes.

Strong female characters

Based on Phillip Pullman’s fantasy saga of the same name, His Dark Materials is set in a world where every human has an animal companion that is a representation of their soul, called daemons. The story follows an orphaned young girl and her daemon who find themselves at the center of a dangerous conflict between science and magic when she (and her daemon, Pantalaimon) begin investigating the disappearance of one of her friends.

Their adventure takes them from the dusty halls of the Oxford college where she was raised to the farthest, frozen reaches of the world — and possibly beyond it.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

HBO recruited some high-profile names both behind the camera and in front of it to ensure its adaptation avoids the problems that befell the 2007 feature The Golden Compass, which was based on the first book in Pullman’s series. Oscar-winning director Tom Hooper (The King’s Speech) directs the first two episodes of the season, while Logan actress Dafne Keen portrays Lyra, the girl at the center of the story.

She’s joined in the cast by fellow X-Men franchise actor James McAvoy as the determined explorer Lord Asriel, Luther actress Ruth Wilson as the cold, calculating Magisterium agent Marisa Coulter, and Hamilton star Lin-Manuel Miranda as aeronaut-for-hire Lee Scoresby.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Keen makes it clear early on that her critically praised performance in Logan was no fluke as she carries the series through the first half of the season admirably, and delivers a captivating performance that — much as she did with Hugh Jackman and Patrick Stewart in Logan — draws your attention even as she shares scenes with McAvoy and Wilson, two extremely talented actors in their own rights. She manages to find the perfect balance of precocious awareness and childhood innocence, drawing you into this fantastic world of daemons and mysteries with curiosity and courage in equal measures.

And like her character in Logan, Keen’s Lyra is a cheer-worthy hero bigger than her years.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Playing supporting roles in the first four episodes, McAvoy and Wilson accomplish a lot with the screen time they’re given, with Wilson in particular building layer upon layer into her enigmatic character as the tale evolves.

As Coulter, Wilson flits between ruthless villain and caring mentor with disturbing ease, maintaining a level of uncertainty in her performance that makes every subtle movement, quiet comment, or facial gesture seem like an all-important clue to her true motives. Some of the early episodes’ most captivating moments are the scenes Wilson shares with Keen, as both actresses are fascinating to watch.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Although the part he plays is brief in the season’s first four episodes, Miranda provides a fun — if not entirely fleshed-out — addition to the cast as intrepid balloonist Scoresby. It will be interesting to see if he can disappear into the role as well as his fellow cast members, as the early episodes don’t spend much time on his character.

Daemons done right

An ever-present element of His Dark Materials that could have been a make-or-break aspect of the series is the portrayal of the characters’ daemons. Fortunately, HBO handles this part of the story expertly, and strikes just the right balance between keeping the audience aware of their presence and not letting them distract from the world-building that occurs in the first half of the season.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

The daemons are representative of their human companions’ true nature, and as such, change forms frequently during their formative, adolescent years, only to settle into a constant state upon reaching adulthood. Pantalaimon (voiced by Kit Connor) shifts between a ferret-like creature and a bird, cat, moth, or other forms, depending on Lyra’s mood and whims.

That the character is able to serve an active, complementary role alongside Keen’s performance without distracting from it is a testament to the impressive visual effects that bring the daemons to life, and solves one of the biggest obstacles faced by any adaptation of Pullman’s novels.

Coulter’s daemon is handled just as well, with her monkey familiar pivoting between adorable innocence and cold efficiency just as suddenly as its human counterpart.

Familiar, but strange

From its geographic landmarks to certain technologies in common use, the world of His Dark Materials is as much a character in the narrative as the daemons and their human companions.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

HBO and the show’s creative team do a masterful job of balancing the world’s familiarity with its other-ness (which includes a kingdom of talking polar bears, for example). Just when you begin to feel comfortable in Lyra’s world, the series offers a reminder of just how extraordinary her version of “normal” is and how wide the scope of her journey is likely to be.

It’s no easy balance to maintain, but the series manages to do just that across the first four episodes with few — if any — moments that jar you out of her world or make it feel small. Although we only see a small portion of that world in the first half of the season, there’s the suggestion of so much more, and that Lyra’s journey through it is only just beginning.

HBO clearly hasn’t lost its affinity (or knack) for world-building on a grand scale, and His Dark Materials is yet another story that sweeps its audience along in all the right ways.

HBO’s His Dark Materials premieres November 4.

Rick Marshall
A veteran journalist with more than two decades of experience covering local and national news, arts and entertainment, and…
Game of Thrones prequel A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms pushed back to 2026
A knight holds his sword as he walks down the street.

One of the ideas behind running two different Game of Thrones prequels at once was to keep the franchise alive on HBO and Max during the long breaks between seasons. However, the next prequel series, A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms, will now be skipping 2025 altogether. And that may mean both House of the Dragon season 3 and A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms could come out in the same year.

Via Variety, HBO confirmed the delay when it screened a trailer for A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms during its upfront presentation. The trailer ended with a vague 2026 release window, but HBO CEO Casey Bloys suggested that it would be released in winter 2026. That would have it premiere on HBO and Max in either January or February 2026. HBO hasn't announced when House of the Dragon will return. But if season 3 doesn't premiere in 2026, then pushing it back to 2027 would mean a nearly three-year gap between seasons. House of the Dragon season 3 is currently in production.

Read more
Andor: Why the Disney+ show is a triumph of Star Wars’ flexibility
Diego Luna as Cassian Andor inside a ship in the Star Wars series Andor season 2.

Director Gareth Edwards’ Rogue One: A Star Wars Story easily became the best Star Wars movie of the Disney era. Even so, few could have predicted that writer Tony Gilroy would also turn Rogue One into a launchpad for Andor, one of Star Wars’s best live-action productions in general. With Andor season 2 finished and the story of Diego Luna’s tragic hero, Cassian, concluded, the series cemented itself as another example of the galaxy far, far away’s creative versatility.

There is no question that Andor’s approach to realism is decidedly different than much of the franchise’s more operatic sci-fi adventures. While the Disney+ Star Wars series’ adherence to grit and realism might not strike a chord with fans who appreciate the franchise’s more fantastical side, it’s still a triumph for its image as a whole. Whether realistic or mystical, Andor shows across two seasons how this franchise’s sandbox rewards different sci-fi subgenres without losing its identity or needing a big legacy name to sell it.

Read more
We’re never going to see a movie like Mad Max: Fury Road again
Nicholas Hoult and Tom Hardy in Mad Max: Fury Road.

The second people got their hands on it, Mad Max: Fury Road felt special. The movie, which came 30 years after the last installment in this franchise, felt like a miracle. Set almost entirely in the desert, its sheer scale and intensity were so marvelous that, even though it's a deeply weird movie, the 2016 Oscars simply couldn't resist nominating it for many awards.

10 years later, Fury Road's stature has only grown. Even though we got Furiosa, which I'd argue is every bit as good as Fury Road, Miller's first return to Mad Max since Beyond Thunderdome is undeniably the one with the bigger cultural imprint. It's a movie we're not likely to ever see again, not just because of its greatness, but because no one else will be dumb enough to try.

Read more