Skip to main content

You’re supposed to watch TV shows, not try to write them. Remember?

Grey's Anatomy Death
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Falling for a TV show takes a leap of faith. Will the cast members you like most stick around? Will the writing hold up over time? Will the network keep ordering new seasons? There are many ways for a show to break your heart, and it’s totally outside your control. Or was, anyway.

For decades, TV fans were almost completed insulated from the people who make TV. If your favorite show faced cancellation, you could write a letter. Or send Tabasco sauce. But organized campaigns to save struggling shows required a fair amount of effort and a lot stamps. They didn’t happen often.

Technology has changed all that. Organizing a campaign to save your favorite show is now just a couple clicks – and a few seconds – away. For better and worse.

“Successful” efforts to save shows are so common, it makes me wonder just how in endangered these shows actually were. It’s hard to tell the difference between a real grassroots effort to save a show and one driven by marketers to boost ratings.

Take ABC’s Happy Endings, for example. When the show was moved to Friday nights in 2013 (not a good sign for a show aimed at young people who aren’t home on Friday nights), fans panicked. They started a legitimate campaign on social media to save the show. ABC then took the unusual step of actually acknowledging the fan campaign in commercials on the network itself.

The network aired promos that basically admitted the show was on the verge of cancellation and implored its fans to take action, to prevent that from happening. It was the equivalent of holding up an adorable rabbit and screaming: “Stop us from killing this bunny!”

It was a vexing move. It was also an unsuccessful one, as the show still got axed. I truly believe ABC was hoping to help the show by backing the fan campaign. A better way to help the show, though? Not cancelling it.

Happy Endings Cancellation
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Technology has made “save our show” campaigns a ubiquitous part of the modern TV experience. It’s a great development, but the empowering of viewers doesn’t stop there. Superfans are now using their newfound powers to not just save their favorite shows – but also to change them. This, in my ever-so-humble opinion, is not a great development.

Spoiler alert: The rest of this piece discusses a recent plot development on Grey’s Anatomy that you’ve probably heard out whether you’re a fan of the show or not.

Within 48 hours of Meredith Grey tearfully pulling the plug on her lover McDreamy last Thursday night, a fan had taken to to start a petition to un-pull that plug. As of this writing, the petition has nearly 90,000 “signatures.”

The Internet is fast, but TV production is slow.

Despite the hefty number of supporters, the petition has been met with a great deal of ridicule due to its over-the-top rhetoric, which I won’t rehash here. OK, I’ll rehash it a little. I was particularly struck by the petitioner’s need to point out how “FINE” — her word, her all-caps — Patrick Dempsey looked before his character died, and how his handsomeness made the character’s death even more emotionally devastating. What?

The Grey’s petition is not the first of its kind. In December, a Walking Dead fan turned to to bring back a deceased character on that show. (Heads up: Don’t click on the link if you’re not caught up on season 5.)

Both petitions seek to “undo” a fictitious character’s death, but that’s about all they have in common. The Walking Dead petition is short and respectful in tone. The Grey’s Anatomy petition is neither of those things. The Walking Dead petition closes with a heartfelt appeal to the actress whose character got killed off. The Grey’s petition closes with a veiled threat to Shonda Rhimes and a demand that Patrick Dempsey change his mind about leaving and return to the show.

The Walking Dead Bring Back Dead
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Guess which one the show’s writers and producers give more thought to?

In truth, neither petition is going to achieve its goal. The Internet is fast, but TV production is slow. It’s also incredibly complicated. The decision to kill off a popular character is not made lightly. Do TV producers ever mess up? Sure. TV is both commerce and art, and the two don’t always mesh very well. But you know what else does go well with art? Crowd-sourcing plot points.

The barrier between content creators and content consumers has never been thinner. But just because you can do something, that doesn’t mean you should. Because angry tweets tend to represent exactly 0.4 seconds worth of effort, they don’t really carry much weight. Social media might allow easier access to writers and actors, but that access is diluted. In a weird way, after all the progress we’ve made technologically, the best way to get an entertainer’s attention is still through old-fashioned snail mail. I’m being totally serious.

Technology has made “save our show” campaigns a ubiquitous part of the modern TV experience.

That doesn’t mean social media doesn’t have any influence. Of course it does. You just need to wield that tool wisely. Positivity carries much more weight than negativity. If there’s a character on a show that you feel deserves more screen time, champion them online. Quote them. GIF them. Give them the Tumblr treatment.

I’ve worked in a half-dozen different writers’ rooms and I can say, without a doubt, that there’s nothing more satisfying that writing for a character that you know fans really love – especially someone who isn’t a star of the show.

It’s also OK to vent. Venting can be very healthy. It can be fun. Being a TV viewer doesn’t mean you have to take every plot development in stride. But when that venting crosses over into outright hostility with personal insults and outlandish demands? Well … viewer discretion is seriously advised.

Eric Buchman
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Eric is a TV Writer whose credits include ABC’s Grey’s Anatomy and Lifetime’s Drop Dead Diva. When not working on a…
Hulu with Live TV: plans, price, channels, bundles and more
Hulu with Live TV.

If you’re looking to cut the cord with your cable provider, but want to hang onto linear programming, one of the best cable TV alternatives is Hulu With Live TV. Billed as a Multichannel Video Programming Distributor (MVPD), Hulu With Live TV provides many of the same features you’d find in a premium cable package, like DVR recording. You’ll also be able to access movies and shows that are available through the standard Hulu streaming service. Plus, you'll get Disney+ and ESPN+ on the house. 

There’s plenty to learn about Hulu With Live TV, and we’ve compiled all the most salient information into this helpful explainer. And do be sure to check back often: as Hulu With Live TV pricing and capabilities have been known to change in the blink of an eye.

Read more
The best anime on Netflix right now
Red-Haired Shanks and Luffy in key art for One Piece Film: Red.

Netflix is increasingly becoming a more compelling platform to watch the best anime. Alongside its usual live-action original content, the streamer's anime catalog is growing across film and TV. With such a diverse selection, seasoned and prospective fans are guaranteed to find something to pique their interest.

Still, Netflix's impressive selection of anime can make it tough to parse through. Thankfully, our anime guide streamlines the platform's offerings down to the highlights. This guide is also curated monthly to update fans on the best anime to watch on Netflix right now.
If you want more options, check out our other guides to the best anime on Hulu and the best anime available on Amazon Prime Video.

Read more
If you have to watch one Hulu show this April, stream this one
Darren Criss in American Crime Story.

When you're looking for something to watch on a streaming service like Hulu, the first step you probably take is to look for lists of the best shows available on Hulu. Sometimes, though, even those lists can be a bit too overwhelming. If you find yourself feeling decision fatigue at the thought of having to comb through a list of all the great shows available on Hulu, we'll happily pick one for you!

This April, you should be sure to check out American Crime Story: The Assassination of Gianni Versace, which is admittedly a very long title. The series, which chronicles the murder of the fames fashion designer, is a fascinating look inside the mind of a killer, and also very much a story about what it's like to be gay in America. Here are three reasons you should watch this show.
It's the rare show that feels like it understands a killer's mind
The Assassination of Gianni Versace: American Crime Story | Season 2: First Look | FX

Read more