Skip to main content

Famed photographer Highsmith sues Getty over alleged copyright infringement

Getty responds to $1B copyright infringement lawsuit by photog Highsmith

photographer sues getty 1 billion dollars version 1469682608 carol highsmith corvette
Carol M. Highsmith/Library of Congress
Photographer Carol Highsmith is known for her Americana-themed images, which she has captured in all 50 states, the District of Columbia, and Puerto Rico. Since 1988, she has been providing the images, free of charge, to the public through the Library of Congress. Unknown to her until recently, stock photo agency Getty Images had been selling her photos to paying clients while allegedly claiming exclusive copyright over them.

But now Getty says that Highsmith gave up her rights to file suit over any copyright when she donated the images to the public domain. On September 6, Getty asked the courts to dismiss the case, filed earlier this summer, because they claim that Highsmith can’t own the copyright to a public domain image. According to the stock photo agency, selling images that have a public domain license isn’t illegal — after all, book publishers sell copies of public domain classics like Shakespeare, the court documents argue.

Highsmith filed a lawsuit against the agency on July 25, alleging “gross misuse” of her photographs, according to PDNPulse. The suit asks for $1 billion in damages, an uncommonly high amount for a copyright case, but Highsmith cites a precedent in the case of Morel v. Getty, in which a photographer was awarded $1.2 million based on the misuse of a small number of photos. Highsmith alleges that Getty violated her copyright on more than 18,000 images.

While Highsmith provided the images to the Library of Congress for free, she apparently never released the copyright. She asked that the Library of Congress inform users of her images that she is the author, and that users give credit for each image used.

“The defendants have apparently misappropriated Ms. Highsmith’s generous gift to the American people,” the claim states. “[They] are not only unlawfully charging licensing fees … but are falsely and fraudulently holding themselves out as the exclusive copyright owner.”

Getty believes Highsmith’s complaint is “based on a number of misconceptions,” according to a statement the company made on July 28. “The content in question has been part of the public domain for many years. It is standard practice for image libraries to distribute and provide access to public domain content, and it is important to note that distributing and providing access to public domain content is different to asserting copyright ownership of it.”

Somewhat ironically, Highsmith claims she only found out about Getty’s use of her images when she received a letter from License Compliance Services (LCS) on behalf of Alamy, a stock agency affiliated with Getty. The letter charged her with copyright violation for using one of her own photos online. According to Highsmith’s complaint, LCS has apparently sent similar letters to other users of her images who found them through the Library of Congress collection. She called the practice “brazen and extortionate.”

The truth may not be quite so dramatic, however. Getty clarified in its statement that “as soon as the plaintiff contacted LCS, LCS acted swiftly to cease its pursuit with respect to the image provided by Alamy and notified Alamy it would not pursue this content,” suggesting Highsmith’s complaint may be the result of a misunderstanding.

Updated on 09-12-2016 by Hillary Grigonis: Added information from Getty’s request to dismiss the case.

Updated 07-29-2016 by Daven Mathies: Added information from Getty’s statement and to clarify the roles of LCS and Alamy.

Editors' Recommendations

Daven Mathies
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Daven is a contributing writer to the photography section. He has been with Digital Trends since 2016 and has been writing…
Best Camera Deals: Save on Canon, Panasonic, Nikon, and GoPro
fujifilm x t4 review set 2 dm 1

Whether you're looking for the best digital cameras or the best travel cameras, there are a ton of options out there, sometimes too many options, especially for those who aren't familiar with the photography world. Luckily, we've done a lot of legwork for you and collected a range of great camera deals across the spectrum, so even if you want something more sports-oriented, like a GoPro, there are a couple of deals for those too. So, let's jump right into it.
Today's Best Camera Deals
One of our favorite deals is the Canon EOS Rebel T7 going for $400, as it's one of the better DSLR cameras on the market, and it has a reasonably budget-friendly price on it, making it a great starter camera. Of course, if you've been in the game for a while and are looking for a powerful upgrade, the Sony Alpha 7R IV is one of the best full-frame cameras on the market, and while it still costs a hefty $3,200, that's still $300 off the usual $3,500 price tag. That said, if you're looking for something more portable and action-oriented, you can't go wrong with the GoPro HERO11 Black Mini, although if you're a professional content creator, the GoPro HERO9 Black 5K is probably the one to go for instead.

Do I Need a DSLR or a Mirrorless Camera?
Like most things, this really depends on what you're trying to do. Mirrorless cameras have fewer internal moving parts, which generally means they can capture images quicker, so if you're taking pictures of action-packed stuff like sports or animals in the wilderness, a mirrorless camera is a great option. On the other hand, DSLR cameras are great for low-light conditions and are great for anything from portraits to landscapes. DSLRs are also cheaper and have much better battery life, as well as having a decade or two worth of lenses to choose from.

Read more
How to blur a background in photos
A person photographed with iPhone 11's portrait mode.

Introducing a background blur to your photos can draw attention to a specific subject, such as an individual in a portrait or an item in a still life, while also adding a professional flair to your image. This beautiful background blur, also known as bokeh, can be achieved even after shooting your photo, thanks to advances in editing software. This guide will walk you through the process on iOS, Android, Windows, and macOS.

Read more
How to download Instagram photos (5 easy ways)
Instagram app running on the Samsung Galaxy Z Flip 5.

Instagram is amazing, and many of us use it as a record of our lives — uploading the best bits of our trips, adventures, and notable moments. But sometimes you can lose the original files of those moments, leaving the Instagram copy as the only available one . While you may be happy to leave it up there, it's a lot more convenient to have another version of it downloaded onto your phone or computer. While downloading directly from Instagram can be tricky, there are ways around it. Here are a few easy ways to download Instagram photos.

Read more