Honeywell RTH9585WF1004 Smart Color Thermostat review

Smart, bright, and simple, Honeywell’s Color Thermostat is a great basic model

The Honeywell Smart Color Thermostat brightens up your room while saving you some cash at the same time.
The Honeywell Smart Color Thermostat brightens up your room while saving you some cash at the same time.
The Honeywell Smart Color Thermostat brightens up your room while saving you some cash at the same time.

Highs

  • Vibrantly colored and customizable touch screen display
  • Large, easy-to-read display screen
  • Relatively easy install
  • Compatibility with multiple voice-control platforms

Lows

  • No geofencing
  • Limited features

The typical American home spends half of their energy costs on their heating and cooling, which can add up to more than $900 each year. A smart thermostat can reduce this cost by learning your temperature preferences and using other energy-saving features.

Recently, we’ve seen an increase in the number of smart thermostats available to customers. Some look like regular old thermostats with old school calculator-like display screens and cost $100 or less, while others, like those offered by Nest and Ecobee, are higher priced and have more advanced features and designs.

We tested out the Honeywell RTH9585WF1004 Thermostat ($200) for a period of six months to evaluate its performance, ease of use, features, and ability to serve as a money-saving device. Here’s how it went.

What’s inside

When you open the box, you’ll find virtually everything you need to get the unit up and running. In addition to the thermostat, which measures 4.5 inches wide by 3.5 inches tall by 0.8 inches deep, you also get an ID card for the thermostat, a wall plate, screws and anchors, wire labels, and a user guide and quick start guide.

honeywell smart color thermostat rth9585wf1004 1
Erika Rawes/Digital Trends

While its features and app design are somewhat simplistic, the thermostat is a solid and reliable addition to your smart home that will save you money, and you don’t have to read a giant manual to understand how to operate the device.

Easy to Self-Install…if you have a C wire

Installation takes about 30 minutes to an hour, and the instructions are clearly laid out in the user guide. It’s designed for a do-it-yourself install, and if you can put in a basic light fixture, you can install this thermostat. The only tool you really need is a screwdriver, but you do need to have a C wire available.

As long as you have a C wire and label the wires correctly based on where they were on your old thermostat, install isn’t too difficult.

To install, switch off the power to your heating and cooling system, remove the old thermostat faceplate (but leave the wires connected), label the wires, remove the old wall plate and mount the new one, attach the wires to the new thermostat, attach the thermostat to the wall plate, and then restore the power to your heating and cooling system.

The wiring is the most difficult part of the installation process. But as long as you have a C wire and label the wires correctly based on where they were on your old thermostat (not based on their color), install isn’t too difficult.

After you get the thermostat installed and connected, you just connect it to your Wi-Fi network, go through the app setup, and connect it to your smart home network.

Colorful Touch Screen, Limited features

The screen is in full color, and there are several different themes to choose from. The screen color is rich and vibrant, and it gives the thermostat a more expensive and high-tech appearance.

The touch screen display is responsive, but don’t expect the responsiveness you’d get with a device like an iPhone. You may have to occasionally press a button twice to initiate a command, and sometimes you annoyingly have to touch the button “just right.” But overall, the backlit screen is functional and attractive, and the few extra button touches here and there take little away from the overall experience.

honeywell smart color thermostat rth9585wf1004 2
Erika Rawes/Digital Trends

The main screen displays the indoor temperature and indoor humidity level, the temperature and humidity level outside, the time, and the temperature at which your thermostat is set.

While the RTH9585WF1004 is an improvement over its predecessor, it lacks some of the advanced features you get with other smart thermostats.

If you go you tap the Weather option, you can see a more information about the day’s weather forecast. You can have the system remind you to replace your air filter or your humidifier pad, and it will alert you in the event of extreme high or low temperatures. You can check the status of your heating and cooling equipment or program a schedule directly into the thermostat touchscreen panel. Smart Response Learning also allows the thermostat to learn your heating and cooling cycle times.

While the RTH9585WF1004 is an improvement over its predecessor (the RTH9580WF), it lacks some of the advanced features you get with other smart thermostats. It doesn’t come with geofencing, for instance. It also doesn’t have Alexa’s voice built-in like the Ecobee4 does, nor does it have room sensors or advanced motion sensor capabilities that can detect movement in specific areas of the home.

Total Connect Comfort

The Honeywell Total Connect Comfort app (available for iOS or Android) lets you control your thermostat from your phone or tablet. It has a basic voice control feature, or you can use the on-screen controls in the app.

The Total Connect Comfort app also lets you do things like view the 5-day weather forecast, set up automatic air filter shipments, and create a schedule. The app will guide you through creating a schedule, or you can customize it day-by-day. It’s very simplistic, but it’s also easy to use because of its simplistic design.

Alexa, set temperature to 70 degrees

While it’s not an Alexa speaker, you can use the thermostat with Alexa to create routines. In fact, it’s compatible several with smart home platforms, including Alexa, Google Home, Smartthings, and IFTTT.

Once you set it up on your smart home network, which takes just a minute or two and involves simply connecting your app account to your Alexa account (or other smart home system’s account), you can voice-control your thermostat.

It’s compatible several with smart home platforms, including Alexa, Google Home, Smartthings, and IFTTT.

You can say things like, “Alexa, what is the thermostat set to?” “Alexa, decrease the temperature by 5 degrees,” or “Alexa, turn on the air conditioning.” You have little need to get up and adjust the thermostat because there are voice commands to cover virtually every situation.

Money savings?

The Honeywell Smart Color Thermostat is Energy Star Certified. We installed the thermostat in the beginning of November. Since then, we’ve monitored our energy usage and compared energy consumption to the same months during the previous year.

From November 2017 to March 2018, the reports indicate we used an average of 1407.8 kWh per month. However, between November 2018 and March 2019, we used an average of 1197.8 kWh per month. This means there’s a decrease in kWh consumption of around 15 percent.

Warranty information

The Honeywell RTH9585WF1004 Smart Color Thermostat comes with a one-year limited warranty.

Our Take

The Honeywell Smart Color Thermostat does exactly what a smart thermostat is supposed to do. It’s energy efficient, it saves on heating and cooling costs, and it makes it easier to control your heating and cooling system with smart features like app and voice control. This unit does, however, lack some of the bells and whistles you’d get with other smart thermostats like geofencing and motion detection.

Is there a better alternative?

If you want a thermostat with more bells and whistles, you may like the 3rd gen Nest Learning Thermostat. It has several cool perks, including a “Farsight” feature that uses built-in sensors and lights up the thermostat when you’re in the room so you can easily read the display.

If you want a thermostat that doesn’t require a C wire, you might want to check out the Ecobee4. It comes with an adapter as a work around if you don’t have one. The Ecobee also has Alexa built right into the thermostat. You can read more in our full review of the Ecobee here.

How long will it last?

Although it’s somewhat simplistic in terms of the features it offers, it’s exceptionally user-friendly, and the hardware is durable. Plus, considering the first-generation Honeywell Smart Color Thermostat is still for sale in several stores and the RTH9585WF1004 is the second-generation version, this thermostat shouldn’t be going anywhere anytime soon.

Should you buy it?

Yes. If you want a simple and easy-to-read thermostat that gives you the ability to adjust your thermostat settings while you’re sitting on your couch or laying in bed, you’ll like the Honeywell RTH9585WF1004.

Smart Home

Ecobee leverages humor in a heated discussion with climate change skeptics

Ecobee cranked up the heat on climate change doubters. In observance of Earth Day, Ecobee and ad agency DCX released video of a social experiment that tested the effectiveness of humor in easing tension during discussions with skeptics.
Smart Home

Echo Plus (1st-gen) vs. Echo Plus (2nd-gen): How exactly do they compare?

Which Echo Plus should you buy? This guide compares the first-generation Echo Plus its latest successor, allowing you to get a better idea regarding the ins and outs of each device.
Smart Home

Philips Hue users can activate their favorite routines through Google Home

Philips Hue expanded its Google Home integration through the Gentle Sleep and Wake routine. Just give Google the proper instructions are your lights will brighten or dim over half an hour.
Trash

Our favorite smart thermostats let you stay warm without burning money

The right thermostat can do more than just adjust the temperature of your home, it can also learn about you and help you save money. Check out our picks for the best smart thermostats on the market right now.
Deals

Amazon and Best Buy halve the price of the Facebook Portal for Mother’s Day

Amazon and Best Buy both cut the price in half for the Facebook Portal smart display for Mother's Day. The Portal's smart camera will follow you as you move around the room during video calls. The Portal also has Amazon Alexa built in.
Smart Home

From the kitchen to the bedroom, here are the best Alexa tips and tricks

Amazon's voice assistant Alexa has plenty of neat skills. So many, in fact, it seems like new ones appear every day. We've rounded up the top Echo tips and tricks to help you get the most out of your virtual assistant.
Smart Home

Ring home security system now works as a hub for smart home devices

Ring is helping the issue of smart home fragmentation with its Works With Ring program. It lets thousands of smart home devices built on Z-Wave connect to Ring's Alarm Base Station.
Smart Home

There will be 200 million smart speakers by year’s end, analysts say

A new report by the research and analysis firm Canalys predicts that more than 200 million smart speakers will be engaged by users by the end of 2019, which is a growth of over 82% from last year.
Smart Home

Oh, Zuck, no! Facebook rumored to be creating a voice assistant to rival Alexa

Facebook hasn't been a big player in the smart speaker market, but that may be changing: The social media giant is reportedly working on a digital assistant to compete against Alexa and others.
Smart Home

SMEG debuts colorful dual-fuel Portofino 48-inch ranges for no-compromise cooks

When SMEG launches new kitchen appliances, you can count on retro-classic design, gorgeous high-end finishes, envy-inducing functional wizardry, and lofty prices. This week SMEG launched its Portofino Dual-Fuel 48-inch Pro-Style Range.
Deals

Walmart offers big price cuts on air fryers from La Gourmet and Farberware

Walmart made deep price cuts on air fryers from La Gourmet, Farberware, and others. Air frying is faster, healthier, and easier to clean than traditional deep frying. You also can use most air fryers for baking, roasting, and grilling.
Deals

Amazon drops a killer Instant Pot deal, with prices under $60

Instant Pots are the popular kitchen device known for making cooking easier and faster. Thinking of finally getting yourself one? Amazon dropped the price of the Instant Pot Duo Mini. Prepare delicious meals this Easter Sunday with this…
Smart Home

I have seen the future, and it’s full of salad-making robots

Think that robots bussing tables, tossing salads and baking bread is a futuristic concept? It's actually not as far away as you might think. Robots took center stage at a food robotics summit in San Francisco this week, where they showed…
Product Review

4K in home security is finally here, thanks to Arlo’s Ultra UHD smart cam

The 4K home security camera is finally here! Class-leading image clarity and a super-wide field of vision makes Arlo Ultra an early contender for the year’s best smart cam. While there are definite quirks to the device, the device…