Skip to main content

The FBI wants to know your internet browsing history

james comey encryption war far from over apple vs fbi
Image used with permission by copyright holder
First it was the data in smartphones, and now it’s your browser history — the FBI wants it all. The Obama administration wants to allow the FBI to access a person’s internet browsing history and other data in spy and terrorism cases.

FBI Director James Comey is advocating for amending the Electronic Communications Privacy Act, ECPA, to force tech firms to provide this browsing data — current language allows these companies to refuse demands for data. But Comey wants to fix this and allow special agents to issue National Security Letters. NSLs do not require a judge’s approval, and the FBI could use them to demand “electronic communication transactional records,” or ECTRs. Holy acronyms, Batman.

But the data the FBI seeks doesn’t include the content of the sites you visit — just the protocol address and how much time you spend on a particular website. For example, if you visit Digital Trends’ website, authorities would only see digitaltrends.com and for how long you stayed on the site. They wouldn’t be able to tell if you clicked into specific parts of the site, according to the Washington Post.

Regardless, Silicon Valley, along with various privacy and civil rights organizations, aren’t taking this lightly. Dubbed the “ECTR Coalition,” companies such as Google, Yahoo, and Facebook have joined the likes of the Electronic Frontier Foundation, the American Civil Liberties Union, Human Rights Watch, Restore the Fourth, and more to highlight what the FBI is really trying to do: expand the surveillance powers of the government.

More than 300,000 NSLs have been issued in the past 10 years.

“This expansion of the NSL statute has been characterized by some government officials as merely fixing a ‘typo’ in the law,” the coalition writes in a letter. “In reality, however, it would dramatically expand the ability of the FBI to get sensitive information about users’ online activities without court oversight.”

The Senate Judiciary Committee is considering an amendment this week penned by Senator John Cornyn, R-Texas, to reform the ECPA. And the Senate Intelligence Committee voted on the Intelligence Authorization bill with the NSL amendment. These NSLs issued by the FBI would also come with a gag order, which means companies wouldn’t be able to disclose if they shared a user’s data.

More than 300,000 NSLs have been issued in the past 10 years, according to the Electronic Frontier Foundation.

“The new categories of information that could be collected using an NSL — and thus without any oversight from a judge — would paint an incredibly intimate picture of an individual’s life,” the coalition writes. “For example, ECTRs could include a person’s browsing history, email metadata, location information, and the exact date and time a person signs in or out of a particular online account.”

The coalition goes on to say this data could reveal a person’s political affiliation, medical conditions, religion, substance abuse history, sexual orientation, and even their movements throughout the day.

“Given the sensitive nature of the information that could be swept up under the proposed expansion, and the documented past abuses of the underlying NSL statute, we urge the Senate to remove this provision from the Intelligence Authorization bill and oppose efforts to include such language in the ECPA reform bill, which has never included the proposed NSL expansion,” the coalition writes.

You can read the full letter, with the list of signed companies and organizations, here.

Editors' Recommendations

Julian Chokkattu
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Julian is the mobile and wearables editor at Digital Trends, covering smartphones, fitness trackers, smartwatches, and more…
I’ve used an iPhone for 14 years. The Pixel Fold made me want to stop
Google Pixel Fold in Obsidian open on Pixar Pier portrait mode.

When Steve Jobs took the stage on January 9, 2007, to unveil the original iPhone, everyone was amazed at the little piece of technology he held in his hand. Then in June 2007, people could buy and get their hands on the very first iPhone — and the scope of the cell phone industry changed forever.

I personally didn't get the original iPhone on launch day, believe it or not. Instead, I received it as a birthday present in 2008 (my very first Apple product), but my clumsy self eventually dropped it on cement four months later, and the screen shattered. But instead of getting it fixed, I figured I might as well just get the iPhone 3G since it was just a few weeks away from release.

Read more
Have the Android 14 beta on your Pixel? You need to download this update now
Google Pixel 7a held in hand showing home screen

Google revealed a bunch of new goodies during its opening keynote for Google I/O 2023, showing off its latest advancements in AI with Bard, as well as the brand new Pixel Fold and Pixel Tablet. There was also a sneak peek at upcoming features in Android 14, including new lock screen clocks, shortcuts, and generative AI wallpapers.

If you have a Pixel phone, like the new Pixel 7a or the older Pixel 7 or Pixel 7 Pro, then -- surprise -- Google is rolling out the Android 14 Beta 2 starting right now.

Read more
Wear OS 4 is coming to your smartwatch this year — here’s what’s new
The main menu screens on the Pixel Watch and the Galaxy Watch 5.

Wear OS is getting a major update with Wear OS 4, and with it, Google's promising a big improvement to the overall smartwatch experience.

Announced today at Google I/O 2023, Wear OS 4 is adding a slew of new features on both a system level as well as an individual app level, meaning that smartwatch owners will be able to have a more streamlined and productive experience when using their devices.

Read more