Skip to main content

The Xbox One is a PC in console’s clothing. Here’s why it matters

Is the Xbox One pretty much a PC
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Microsoft has spoken at length about the many features of its new all-in-one entertainment console. Besides gaming, the system will also support control of cable television, streaming apps, and can hook up with a home network to read media files. The Xbox One will also include an upgraded version of Kinect that improves hands-free control and (mostly) removes the need for multiple remotes.

All of this is important, even revolutionary, but there’s more going on under the hood. A closer look reveals that even the label “all-in-one entertainment” doesn’t cover the broad potential the Xbox One presents. This is not a console as we’ve previously known it; instead, it’s a PC in console clothes. 

The heart of a PC

Underneath the Xbox One’s exterior is a range of components derived from a standard PC architecture. As described in our deep-dive of the console, the One includes eight x86 cores tied together with DDR3 RAM and paired with an integrated Radeon-class GPU. The system also includes USB ports, an optical drive, and all the other extras you’d normally expect to receive from a mid-range desktop computer.

Xbox One ComponentsThat’s not to say the One is exactly the same as a PC, as a few notable differences have been confirmed. Most important is the super-fast 32MB ESRAM chip designed to offset the limited bandwidth of DDR3, and custom silicon designed to ship information around the system and help the console’s many functions communicate. 

Even so, the One is very similar to a PC, and it’s deviations are minor speed-bumps compared to the hurdle of porting current-gen console software to an x86 computer. Developers will now be tweaking code designed for x86 rather than porting code from one instruction set architecture (PowerPC, the basis for the Xbox 360 and PlayStation 3) to another.

The mind of a PC

Sony’s PlayStation 4 has an architecture that’s even more closely related to a desktop PC because it uses far less custom silicon to enable system functions. Yet, in spite of this, the PS4 will never have the capabilities of a PC. Why? Because it doesn’t ship with Windows, and, in the eyes of many consumers, that’s the computer operating system.

You only need a sliver of imagination to envision users replacing many traditional PC roles with the combination of a console and tablet.

However, the Xbox One does ship with Windows. While it’s doesn’t run Windows 8 exactly, it does use the same kernel and the same interface design language, which means it can in theory run the same applications without much effort by developers. A preview of this appeared during the 2013 Build conference when Microsoft showed real-time debugging of an Xbox One via Visual Studio on stage.

While the hints dropped at Build were small, the consequences could be huge. Could an app for the new console guide you through how to make a stew, geo-locate your friends, or remind you to go buy some milk? Does this potentially serve as an avenue for indie developers to self-publish their titles? And will developers be able to monetize as they do elsewhere, effectively creating an app store for your television? Porting Windows apps into the One’s environment would help developers make money and let consumers use the One for more than just entertainment.

Why PC compatibility matters

The battle for dominance among next-gen consoles hasn’t even begun, but with the Wii U still struggling, only Sony offers serious competition. There are certainly enough gamers in the world to sustain two consoles, so the One looks set to sell well even if it occasionally bursts into a ball of confetti.

Xbox One Living Room In other words, Microsoft is poised to send millions of PCs directly to consumers. They run x86 hardware, they run a Windows kernel, and it’s all but confirmed that they’ll be able to run Windows 8 apps (with a few tweaks, most likely). In addition to this, they’ll have access to all the media features that PCs are known for, plus they can be used to watch cable TV – something computers never made easy.

The One could be an extension of Windows into a new territory (the living room) that’s traditionally been unfriendly to Microsoft and has weakened the company’s ability to appeal to consumers. Extending the Windows 8 app environment to the living room could help developers sell software and help Microsoft unify the user experience. This could even help push users towards the company’s unpopular smartphones and tablets.

And the potential doesn’t stop there. Smartglass, the Xbox remote control app, could allow the One to operate as if it were a PC with a keyboard and mouse attached. You only need a sliver of imagination to envision users replacing many traditional PC roles with this combination of console and tablet. The two would complement each other perfectly – the console providing the horsepower, the tablet providing a friendly interface and remote control. Users could edit photos and movies, create presentations, or open spreadsheets right in the living room.

Will Microsoft innovate or fight itself?

This is where the story gets tricky, because Microsoft is a large, complicated company. None of the potential functions we’ve outlined are outlandish, and there’s no technical reason why they shouldn’t be possible. But what if the Windows division steps in to cripple the One’s capability, seeing it as a threat to Windows sales? Past in-fighting killed Courier, delayed ClearType, and destroyed early expeditions into eBooks, so such a move would be far from unprecedented. 

Tim Cook, CEO of Apple, declared at the beginning of this year that his company’s “core philosophy is to never fear cannibalization. If we don’t do it, someone else will.” Microsoft should listen to its competitor and make sure that divisional jealously doesn’t hamper what might be. The One grants a rare chance to move before other tech giants are ready to respond. But, if this chance is squandered, others (including Apple) could quickly outflank Redmond. Again.  

Editors' Recommendations

Matthew S. Smith
Matthew S. Smith is the former Lead Editor, Reviews at Digital Trends. He previously guided the Products Team, which dives…
Scores of people are downgrading back to Windows 10
The screen of the Galaxy Book4 Ultra.

Microsoft continues to struggle with the adoption of Windows 11 among its users. Recent data from Statcounter reveals a notable decline in the operating system’s market share, specifically compared with Windows 10.

After reaching an all-time high of 28.16% in February 2024, Windows 11 has experienced a drop, falling below the 26% mark.

Read more
The ASUS ROG Ally handheld gaming PC has a nice discount today
Starfield running on the Asus ROG Ally.

If you love the power of gaming PCs and the portability of the Nintendo Switch, you should think about getting a handheld gaming PC like the Asus ROG Ally. If you're interested, it's currently on sale from Walmart with an $87 discount that pulls its price down to $400 from $487. It's a pretty popular device so we expect this offer to attract a lot of attention, which means it's probably not going to last long. If you want to get this handheld gaming PC for this cheap, you should proceed with the transaction immediately.

Why you should buy the Asus ROG Ally handheld gaming PC
It's the version of the Asus ROG Ally with the AMD Ryzen Z1 Extreme that's listed in our roundup of the best handheld gaming PCs, but the Asus ROG Ally Z1 is still a worthwhile purchase because it gives you a gaming PC that you can bring with you wherever you go. Unlike a gaming laptop that's still pretty bulky with its large screen and keyboard, the Asus ROG Ally takes on the form of a portable gaming console like the Nintendo Switch, but with Windows 11 pre-installed as a familiar operating system to navigate and launch the best PC games.

Read more
The HP Victus gaming PC with RTX 3060 has a $550 discount
The HP Victus 15L gaming PC in white.

Gamers don't need to spend more than $1,000 if they want to buy a new gaming PC because there are affordable options like the HP Victus 15L gaming desktop. From its original price of $1,400, you can get it for just $850 as HP has applied a $550 discount on this machine. However, you shouldn't delay your purchase because there's no assurance that the gaming PC will still be 39% off tomorrow. If you want to make sure that you get it for less than $1,000, you're going to have to complete the transaction for it within the day.

Why you should buy the HP Victus 15L gaming desktop
You shouldn't expect the HP Victus 15L gaming desktop to match the performance of the top-of-the-line models of the best gaming PCs, but it's surprisingly powerful for its cost. Inside it are the 13th-generation Intel Core i7 processor and the Nvidia GeForce RTX 3060 graphics card, with 16GB of RAM that our guide on how much RAM do you need says is the best place to start for gaming. It's enough to play today's best PC games without any issues, and it may even be capable of running the upcoming PC games of the next few years if you're willing to dial down the settings for the more demanding titles.

Read more