Skip to main content

Opinion: Why I quit Spotify and ran back into the arms of Pandora

spotify-pandora
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Guest contibuter Mark Beare is the president and founder of ReviverSoft, which helps people optimize and maintain their computers through its award-winning software and blog. He’s an avid audio junkie by hobby, and a long-time Digital Trends fan.

As someone who spends a lot of time on a computer, loves many different types of music, and enjoys discovering new music, I (along with many people) was excited when Spotify launched in the US in July. Unfortunately, the streaming music service I had been clamoring for didn’t work out quite as I had imagined. After a brief love affair with Spotify, things fizzled out quickly, and now I’m back in the arms of Pandora. Here’s what happened.

The honeymoon period

At first, Spotify’s service was really impressive. Very rarely would I not be able to find a song I was looking for, and I never had to worry about my music collection when moving from computer to computer. No matter which computer I was on, or even which mobile device, all my music was right there and organized how I liked it.

After initially signing up for the service, it was a lot of fun to put play lists together of songs that I liked. I have been a Pandora user for some time, so I based a lot of my playlists off of what I already liked on Pandora. I would make a good playlist, thrash it to death till I was sick of all the songs, and then go to work on a new playlist. I paid for the premium service ($9.99 a month), so I also listened to my playlists in the car using offline playlists.

One thing that did annoy me was that I could not use the songs on my iPod shuffle, which is what I use when I work out. This is where I really want fresh music for use offline.

A labor of love

While I initially really liked making playlists in Spotify, after a couple weeks it became more of a chore than a pleasure. I exhausted the “What’s New” and “Top Lists” playlists, then I found myself starting to have to put in a considerable amount of time to find music for new playlists. This wasn’t fun anymore. What used to be something that I did while working became something I had to do instead of working.

Pandora, I miss you

Within a couple of weeks, I found myself longing for the “set it and forget it” ease of Pandora. All I had to do was pick one song that I liked, and then let Pandora do the rest. Also, Pandora recently added genre stations, which means you can pick a type of music you like or even just listen to today’s hits. This style of music selection fits in much better with my work than Spotify’s.

The love affair is over

After initially enjoying Spotify, and paying for the premium service, I cancelled the service within the first month to go back to Pandora. While Spotify would be revolutionary for some people, it really does not fit in with the way I like to listen to music during my work day. I honestly think that the only reason Spotify became so popular in Europe was simply because Pandora is not available there. People rave about Pandora in the US. They love it and find it to be an amazing service. I have not heard people refer to Spotify with this type of passion; people are just impressed with the selection. I think that it will not take too long before people start to realize that to use Spotify long term takes a time commitment that may be OK for some people, but not all. The same thing can be said for Turn Table.

For me, I am back to listening to Pandora for eight hours a day, and not once since switching back have I missed a single thing about Spotify.

Also check out our comparison: Spotify vs. Pandora vs. Grooveshark.

Editors' Recommendations

Mark Beare
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Mark Beare is the Vice President of Engineering at Digital Trends. He grew up on a farm in Australia where his father was the…
Spotify is looking to add a virtual concert feature
Woman using phone while listening to headphones

Spotify is reportedly testing out a virtual events feature that will connect you to concert livestreams directly within the app. 

Based on screenshots shared by security researcher Jane Manchun Wong on Tuesday, the new feature would list virtual events in a specific location and links to tune in. 

Read more
Five years on, Jay-Z’s Tidal is still fighting to make waves
Tidal Owners: Jay-Z, Beyoncé, Kanye West, Nicki Minaj, Daft Punk

Imagine a cool, zeitgeist-capturing brand with a streaming music service co-owned by one of the biggest names in hip-hop history, which attracts the support of major celebrities, while rapidly ascending to the promised land of multibillion-dollar valuations.

Is this the story of streaming music service Tidal? No. It's the story of Beats, actually: The Dr. Dre co-founded company, which sold to Apple in 2014 with a $3 billion price tag every bit as cool as the headphones it made, seen around the necks of stars like LeBron James and Michael Phelps.

Read more
Google needs to get back to basics with Android. Why? Take a look at iOS 14
Android 10 Assistant Navigation

For the last few weeks, I’ve been bouncing between an iPhone and an Android phone to explore what their new software updates have to offer. Similar to how it goes every year, the experience largely involves me poking around in all the latest features Google and Apple have baked into Android 11 and iOS 14 -- except this year brought one conspicuous and pivotal difference.

This time, the whole process left me yearning. As a longtime Android user, this time I was more partial to (and tempted by) iOS than ever before. I’m not picking sides, nor have I ever done that in the past. However, iOS 14 hammered home what I've been suspecting for years now: Google’s relentless quest to build a “smarter” mobile operating system has riddled the Android experience with gaping, glaring holes.

Read more