Skip to main content

MacBook Pro owners file class action lawsuit over keyboard issues

MacBook Pro Touch Bar
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Thousands of MacBook Pro owners have started a petition to encourage Apple to recall their MacBook Pros following continued difficulties with the laptop’s keyboard. Declaring all MacBook Pro keyboards since late 2016 defective due to a failure in the butterfly mechanism supporting each key, the petition demands that Apple recall the laptops — and replace the keyboards with something new “that just works.”

Recommended Videos

Some of those users have gone beyond tweets and online petitions. CNET reports that a group of customers have filed a class action lawsuit against Apple. The lawsuit, which was filed in Northern California’s U.S. District Court, alleges that Apple failed to warn consumers about the flaws in its butterfly keyboards.

In the never-ending race to make the slimmest and lightest laptops, Apple, alongside other manufacturers, has been trimming the fat on its notebooks for years. One way Apple did so in recent generations of the MacBook Pro was to redesign the keyboard with a new “butterfly” switch of its own making. Despite a few iterations, failure rates have skyrocketed and MacBook Pro users claim that all of them are at risk of breaking or becoming stuck due to their innate fragility.

Like most of Apple’s laptops, the MacBook Pros have very poor user-repairability ratings, so those faced with sticky or stuck keys have been forced to go down the official Apple repair route. As VentureBeat highlights, those repairs can be expensive, with some users quoted as much as $700 for the fix. That, according to the authors of the petition, is simply not good enough, and they’re demanding that Apple do something about it.

The petition has so far been signed by over 20,000 people and quotes a number of MacBook Pro owners who have run into various keyboard issues, from sticky keys to defective keys to those who have found their MacBook Pro entirely unusable because of keyboard failure. They demand not only a replacement program and recall for all MacBook Pros sold since late 2016, but a fully redesigned keyboard.

If enacted, such a recall would be of an enormous scale and could cost Apple dearly. But it’s not like Apple doesn’t do product recalls when it encounters significant problems with its hardware. It recently announced a recall of the 13-inch MacBook Pro due to potential problems with its battery. That MacBook Pro is limited to the non-touch-bar version and only those produced between October 2016 and October 2017. A recall of all MacBook Pros for keyboard replacement would be on a far grander scale.

Updated on May 13: Included information regarding a lawsuit filed against Apple. 

Jon Martindale
Jon Martindale is a freelance evergreen writer and occasional section coordinator, covering how to guides, best-of lists, and…
The new MacBook Air has got a small, but significant keyboard update
M4 MacBook Air

This week, Apple introduced three new products: a fresh MacBook Air, iPad Air, and iPad. One thing each of these devices has in common is that they basically look the same as the models they are replacing—except for one tiny detail on the new MacBook.

As iCulture’s noted first, the new laptop addresses a design flaw that Apple has had for the past 26 years. Since the launch of the PowerBook G3 ‘Lombard’ in 1999, the mute key on every Apple laptop has featured a speaker icon. However, this design does not clearly indicate that the button can both mute and unmute the computer’s audio. With the introduction of the new MacBook Air, the keyboard now displays a speaker icon with a strike-through, clearly signaling its full function. For those keeping score at home, the button in question is the F10 key.

Read more
Honor MagicBook Pro 14 beats the new MacBook Air in one striking way
The lid of the Honor MagicBook Pro 14 in green

Although its name may suggest otherwise, Mobile World Congress (MWC) is not just a show for mobile devices. The business side touches every facet of the consumer technology industry, and many of the biggest companies unveil new products for the European and wider global markets.

The latest edition — MWC Barcelona 2025 — did oversee a return to form, with more mobile devices launched than in recent years, but one of the non-mobile devices that stood out for me was the Honor MagicBook Pro 14.

Read more
M4 MacBook Air performance almost competes with Pro models
A person holds a MacBook Air at Apple's Worldwide Developer's Conference (WWDC) in 2023.

The M4 MacBook Air is anticipated as Apple’s next light and fast laptop, and a recent benchmark suggests that the device may have mild performance improvements over the lastest MacBook Pro.

Apple is expected to announce the coming laptop in 13-inch and 15-inch models in the March timeframe. A device suspected to be the M4 MacBook Air surfaced on the Geekbench 6 benchmark on February 19, revealing results that experts are comparing to other Apple products, including the M4 MacBook Pro and the 13-inch M4 iPad Pro.

Read more