Will passwords ever go away?

Password (Shutterstock mkabakov)

Passwords: We all have them, and we all hate them. For decades, passwords have been the de facto standard of digital security, protecting our computers, e-mail, documents,social-networking accounts, and mobile devices. They also guard our money by protecting access to accounts with everyone from local utilities to online retailers and banks.

But passwords are also tremendously vulnerable. They’re indiscriminate, granting access to anyone, not just you. Passwords are also tough to manage, so we often keep them simple and re-use them. (Heck, we even forget them.) Advances in computing power mean cracking passwords by brute force gets easier all the time — and security breaches (like Twitter’s) enable attackers to do just that.

With these problems, passwords should be ripe for replacement by better technologies. What might those be, and will passwords ever go away?

Multi-factor identification

Password are a shared secret: you establish your identity by revealing something you know — ideally, something only you know. It’s a form of single-factor authentication, and fails if the shared secret ever gets out (or can be guessed).

One way to improve security is using multiple tests. Multi-factor authentication can mean multiple passwords: attackers and would-be impersonators wouldn’t have to know just one shared secret, but two! (Or three, or four!)

However, multiple passwords suffer the same frailties as traditional passwords — we’re awash in passwords already, adding more won’t help. So multi-factor authentication methods usually rely on something you have or something you are in addition to something you know.

Mythbusters beat fingerprint scanner

Something you have could be a card, a keyfob, a notebook, or a mobile phone. Something you are is almost always biometric information: your fingerprint, your voice, your face, or perhaps your iris. On their own, these are single-factor authentication: someone could steal your phone or card key, or even lift your fingerprints off a cup or door handle. (A few years ago MythBusters defeated a high-end fingerprint scanner with a photocopied thumbprint and some spit.)

However, combining something you have or something you are with a password can be formidable. An attacker in China might brute-force your email password — but can they also get your phone? Someone might steal your notebook, but will they also be able to crack your password? It’s possible, but usually only for determined attackers: everyday cybercriminals and identity thieves probably move on to easier targets.

Multi-factor for the real world

Google two-step verification

Right now, Google’s two-step verification may be the best-known multi-factor authentication, requiring a password (something you know) and your phone (something you have). When a user logs in, Google sends a one-time verification code to the phone registered with the account via SMS. (Google Authenticator app can generate codes if you don’t have SMS service.) Users need both their password and the verification code to access their account.

Of course, this only applies to Google accounts: it’s no help for Facebook, Twitter, iTunes, Amazon, banks, or other places we maintain passwords. The same issue impacts other multi-factor security systems: an RSA SecurID token might let you connect to a corporate VPN, but it doesn’t protect anything else. Today there are over 100 proprietary authentication systems, by some industry estimates, and they don’t work with each other.

FIDO Alliance "How it works"

One way forward might be an open system. Last week, the Fast Identity Online Alliance (FIDO) formally launched after more than two years in development — and it has some big names behind it, including PayPal and Lenovo. FIDO hopes to create a system for either single- and multi-factor authentication that anyone can use supporting fingerprint readers, facial recognition, tokens, or new technologies that come along. Moreover, FIDO-enabled authentication doesn’t exchange passwords (or fingerprints!), but non-reusable tokens.

“Within FIDO, security and privacy are preserved, because the user information never leaves home,” wrote Sebastien Taveau of Validity Sensors, on behalf of FIDO. “The FIDO-enabled authenticator or device verifies the user identity locally then communicates back to the Relying Party, such as PayPal, that the user is presenting one of a family of approved technologies capable of verifying identity.”

FIDO-compliant products are at least a year off: the protocol and compliance specs aren’t finished, and then devices and services need to get on board. However, FIDO believes the open technology will gain momentum and spread to consumer services — including Android, iOS, and Windows.

“As demand increases for FIDO-compliant authenticators, more products will appear,” wrote Lenovo’s Clain Anderson, on behalf of FIDO. “Though we would expect enterprise markets to drive initial demand, their rate of adoption will drive price and availability for consumer markets to buy into FIDO.”

The pain factor

ID Token (shutterstock, dave clark)

Multi-factor systems provide better security than passwords — but can also create hassles. A lost or broken phone set up for Google’s two-step verification can lead to a days-long account recovery process. With FIDO, a lost or damaged device will mean jumping through hoops to get another device authorized.

“I think passwords are always going to be part of things,” said Rich Mogull, CEO and analyst at Securosis. “Once you get to multiple factors things get much more complex for consumers. Are people really going to walk around with a dozen keyfobs or being only able to log in to accounts from one phone?”

Fixing these hassles can create opportunities for foul play. After all, Wired editor Matt Honan’s digital presence wasn’t famously gutted last year because someone cracked his passwords: instead, his attackers exploited loopholes in password reset regimes. Multi-factor authentication methods may limit back doors, but when they can’t be used users will always need ways to regain access — so there will always be mechanisms outside a user’s control that could be exploited.

“These things work fine in isolation, but it’s very hard to scale them to consumers,” said Mogull. “I havent seen anything that can truly get past the technology and human behavior obstacles.”

Multi-factor security can also be abused. I don’t use Google’s two-step verification, but for months I’ve been receiving verification codes for random Google accounts. I don’t know why, and Google has been no help.

Risk analysis

Google Verify Your Identity, We Think Something is Fishy

Banks and credit card companies have a lot to lose from compromised accounts, so in addition to a form of two-factor authentication (asking security questions if they don’t recognize your device) they analyze transactions, flagging unusual activity and suspending accounts if they suspect fraud. Online services can use similar approaches — and Google has been moving in this direction.

“Every time you sign in to Google [..] our system performs a complex risk analysis to determine how likely it is that the sign-in really comes from you. In fact, there are more than 120 variables that can factor into how a decision is made,” Google security engineer Mike Hearn wrote in the company blog. “If a sign-in is deemed suspicious or risky for some reason — maybe it’s coming from a country oceans away from your last sign-in — we ask some simple questions about your account.”

These techniques usually require tracking users’ activity — that information has to be stored and may be vulnerable. But risk analysis more commonly locks people out of accounts via false positives: any credit card user who’s account has been suspended when travelling or making an unusual purchase knows the feeling.

The password is dead! Long live the password!

As millions of people embrace online services and cloud platforms, passwords are about the only thing protecting our online lives. They can be augmented by additional security strategies — and systems like FIDO could embrace multiple solutions — but passwords won’t be going away anytime soon.

And, fundamentally, our digital lives are only as secure as the companies to whom we entrust them — and last year a study found one in four Americans was notified that their information had been compromised by a data breach. If high-profile failures at Sony, Facebook, Twitter, Yahoo, LinkedIn, Amazon, Dropbox, Bank of America, and many (many!) others teach us anything, it’s that passwords aren’t the only weak link in the chain.

Images via Shutterstock/Maksim Kabakou & Shutterstock/Dave Clark Digital Photo

Product Review

With the S10e and S10 Plus, do we really need the Samsung Galaxy S10?

The Galaxy S10 is the middle child in this year’s Galaxy S10 range, between the Galaxy S10e, and the Galaxy S10 Plus. There’s no striking reason to buy it, but it’s still an excellent phone you’ll be happy with.
Social Media

A Facebook, Instagram bug exposed millions of passwords to its employees

Facebook, Facebook Lite, and Instagram passwords weren't properly encrypted and could be viewed by employees, the company said Thursday. The network estimates millions of users were affected.
Computing

Don’t be fooled! Study exposes most popular phishing email subject lines

Phishing emails are on the rise and a new study out by the cybersecurity company Barracuda has exposed some of the most common phishing email subject lines used to exploit businesses. 
Computing

How to change your Gmail password in just a few quick steps

Regularly updating your passwords is a good way to stay secure online, but each site and service has their own way of doing it. Here's a quick guide on how to change your Gmail password in a few short steps.
Computing

You don't have to spend a fortune on a PC. These are the best laptops under $300

Buying a laptop needn't mean spending a fortune. If you're just looking to browse the internet, answer emails, and watch Netflix, you can pick up a great laptop at a great price. These are the best laptops under $300.
Computing

Dodge the biggest laptop-buying mistakes with these handy tips

Buying a new laptop is exciting, but you need to watch your footing. There are a number of pitfalls you need to avoid and we're here to help. Check out these top-10 laptop buying mistakes and how to avoid them.
Computing

Amazon sale knocks $200 off the price of 13-inch MacBook Pro with Touch Bar

If you always wanted to buy a MacBook Pro but found it a bit too expensive, now is your chance to save. A base version of the 13-inch MacBook Pro with Touch Bar is currently on sale at Amazon for $1,600.
Computing

Keep your laptop battery in tip-top condition with these handy tips

Learn how to care for your laptop's battery, how it works, and what you can do to make sure yours last for years and retains its charge. Check out our handy guide for valuable tips, no matter what type of laptop you have.
Computing

Is it worth spending more for the Surface Pro, or is the Surface Go good enough?

The Surface Go vs. Surface Pro — which is better? While the higher price tag of one might make you think it's an easy choice, a deeper dive into what each offers makes it a closer race than you might assume.
Computing

Apple’s 4K 21.5-inch iMac is now $200 off if you pre-order it

Apple's new iMacs are now available and if you pre-order one from B&H you can get the midrange version for $200. That's a near 20-percent saving on one of the most competitive configurations.
Emerging Tech

Microsoft’s latest breakthrough could make DNA-based data centers possible

Could tomorrow's data centers possibly store information in the form of synthetic DNA? Researchers from Microsoft have successfully encoded the word "hello" into DNA and then back again.
Computing

Own an Asus computer? Malware might be hiding in your system

If you own an Asus computer, your system might have been infected by malware distributed from the tool you typically use to update the BIOS and install other security patches, according to a new report by cybersecurity firm Kaspersky Lab.
Computing

The new Windows 10 File Explorer could look like this in 2020

Microsoft may update Windows 10's File Explorer to adopt Fluent Design principles in an upcoming 2020 update. A report suggests that we'll get our first glimpse at the new-look explorer in upcoming Windows Insider builds.
Computing

Hands-on with Microsoft Chromium Edge: A first look at the early release

We installed a preview of Edge Chromium, and there's now a lot that makes it feel Chrome, but there are also some similarities to the old Edge. So, is the new Chromium Edge the best browser ever? Here's a hands-on look.