Microsoft and EA’s payment to YouTubers may be unethical, but not illegal

microsoft eas payment youtubers may unethical illegal xbox one youtube

Microsoft and Electronic Arts have come under fire following the revelation that both companies were paying YouTube content creators to promote their products, then requiring them to not disclose that they were being paid. Although that might not be the most ethical thing, it doesn’t appear to violate Federal Trade Commissions guidelines, according to an FTC employee speaking to Polygon.

“The guides are guidance to help advertisers and endorsers comply with federal advertising law,” Betsy Lordan from the FTC Office of Public Affairs said. “They are not legally enforceable, and there are no monetary penalties or penalties of any kind associated with them.”

The issue first came to light when it was revealed that Microsoft and Machinima were accused of paying YouTube content creators to promote the Xbox One. The YouTuber would receive $3 for every 1,000 pageviews, up to 1.25 million page views, and the requirements were straightforward enough. The video had to feature at least 30 seconds of Xbox One gameplay footage, mention the console by name, and the creator’s couldn’t “say anything negative or disparaging about Machinima,Xbox One, or any of its Games.”

In itself, there is nothing inherently wrong with that. Companies like Microsoft have the right to market their product how they like. The issue, however, came about because those content creators were reportedly made to sign a non-disclosure agreement that prohibited them from telling anyone that they were paid. Not only does that raise several ethical questions, it seemed to be at odds with FTC guidelines, which prohibit an endorser of a product from taking money from the seller of that product without disclosing it.

The actual guidelines state:

“When there exists a connection between the endorser and the seller of the advertised product that might materially affect the weight or credibility of the endorsement (i.e., the connection is not reasonably expected by the audience), such connection must be fully disclosed.”

Although Lordan wouldn’t specifically comment on whether or not the disclosure met with the FTC’s standards, it turns out it doesn’t matter. The FTC guidelines are just that – guidelines. They are not binding laws, but rather just general statements meant to help make sense of the complex legalities surrounding federal advertising laws.

Violating these guidelines wouldn’t in itself lead to any legal repercussions. Instead it would, at worst, lead to a warning from the FTC, which could turn into an investigation. Lordan would not comment on whether or not the FTC was looking into these particular matters, and as a rule the FTC doe not disclose ongoing investigations until they are complete.

“So (for example) if an advertiser is not following these guidelines, there is no penalty,” Lordan explained in general terms. “But the FTC could send a warning letter and if the problem is not eventually resolved, the agency could opt to open an investigation. But the ultimate charge (if the FTC decides to follow through) would be a violation of the FTC Act (violation of federal advertising law) and not a violation of the Guides. (It is not technically possible to violate the Guides because unlike regulations, the Guides are not legally enforceable.)”

In response to the controversy, Microsoft claimed that it paid Machinima to promote its system and games, but the decision to pay YouTube creators was Machinima’s.

“As part of this campaign, Microsoft advertising dollars on Machinima were specifically for banner and pre-roll media placements,” a Microsoft spokesperson told Polygon. “The additional video content creation was provided by Machinima as a value-add program. Microsoft was not aware of the terms and requirements that Machinima has in place with its content providers.

“Our overall media plan spans a diverse set of channels and Machinima is one of many media partners we work with to reach our audience. It is important to Microsoft that all of our partners follow necessary guidelines and any videos as part of paid programs should carry the appropriate disclosures.”

As for EA, the case is a little different. The publisher paid You Tube content creators to film and post very specific instances of gameplay, and it allowed criticism. It too reportedly required participants to non-disclosure agreements, but it later said that the program also required those creators to comply with FTC guidelines.

“Through EA’s Ronku program, some fans are compensated for the YouTube videos they create and share about our games,” EA said in a statement. “The program requires that participants comply with FTC guidelines and identify when content is sponsored. User-generated videos are a valuable and unique aspect of how gamers share their experiences playing the games they love, and one that EA supports.”

Gaming

As deaf gamers speak up, game studios are finally listening to those who can’t

Using social media, personal blogs and Twitch, a small group of deaf and hard-of-hearing players have been working to make their voices heard and improve accessibility in the gaming industry.
Mobile

The Kindle Paperwhite is waterproof, so now you can read it in the tub

Amazon released a new version of the Kindle Paperwhite ebook reader, boasting improved software, more storage, and a feature that customers have been asking for: Waterproofing.
Home Theater

Put your home theater to the test with these spectacular Blu-ray releases

What's the point of having all of that awesome home theater gear if you can't breed a little jealousy in your friends and family? We've put together this list of fantastic Blu-rays that have the goods to drop a few jaws.
Home Theater

Need more contrast in your life? Here’s what you need to know about HDR TVs

So what is HDR TV? In a nutshell, it’s the best thing to happen to TV since the arrival of 4K. Here's everything you need to know about the technology, what it can do, and why it’s a must-have.
Gaming

Grab a comfy saddle — ‘Red Dead Redemption 2’ campaign clocks in at 60 hours

According to Rockstar Games co-founder and head writer Dan Houser, Red Dead Redemption 2 features a 60-hour story. Houser said "superfluous" content was removed from the game. It launches October 26 on PlayStation 4 and Xbox One.
Gaming

Jump into an internet DeLorean and play free Commodore 64 games online

The Internet Archive has added more than 8,800 full Commodore 64 games to its software library. Here's how you can play them completely free in your browser without the need for a joystick.
Gaming

‘Fortnite’ in-game tournaments will give you the chance to beat the pros

Epic Games is introducing in-game tournaments to Fortnite. The initial schedule includes five tournaments, with commemorative pins going to the victors. Down the road, the pins might grant you access into additional rounds.
Gaming

Here's how you can keep up with your favorite streamers at TwitchCon 2018

From sessions with your favorite streamers to epic Esports tournaments, there's plenty to look forward to at this year's TwitchCon 2018. We cover how you can attend, where you can watch if you can't, and which events you don't want to miss.
Gaming

Monsters you get in ‘Pokémon: Let’s Go’ can be transferred to the next main RPG

Pokémon: Let's Go, Pikachu! and Pokémon: Let's Go, Eeevee! monsters will be able to be transferred to the next main Pokémon RPG on Switch, according to game director Junichi Masuda.
Gaming

Turbo-powered Quadcrasher crashes the party in new ‘Fortnite’ update 6.01

Season 6, week 4 marks the arrival of Fortnite update 6.10 patch notes. It brings with it the arrival of the new Quadcrasher vehicle, in-game tournaments, a ton of Save the World additions, and much more.
Gaming

What you should know about 'Red Dead Redemption 2' before it launches

The long-awaited (and long-rumored) sequel to Rockstar Games' Red Dead Redemption is confirmed. Red Dead Redemption 2 will arrive next spring. Here's everything we've heard about the game so far.
Gaming

PS4 ‘Spider-Man’ game gets ‘The Heist’ DLC, new costumes on October 23

The first downloadable content pack for Marvel's Spider-Man, The Heist, is out October 23. The pack adds three new suits for Spider-Man to wear, and its story focuses on Felicia Hardy.
Gaming

Apple Mac users should take a bite out of these awesome games

Contrary to popular belief, there exists a bevy of popular A-list games compatible for Mac computers. Take a look at our picks for the best Mac games available for Apple fans.
Product Review

'Black Ops 4' outshines the games it copies with that Call of Duty polish

Call of Duty: Black Ops 4’s omission of a campaign could have been a deal breaker, but multiplayer, Zombies, and the new Blackout mode make it one of the best shooters of the year.