Skip to main content

The one way the Steam Deck succeeds where the Switch failed

I recently went on a trip, which brought up a question I face every time I spend a few nights away from my gaming PC: How am I going to play games? For nearly five years now, my answer has been to pack my Nintendo Switch. This time, however, packing up my Switch felt like a compromise I didn’t want to make.

Like a lot of folks, I’m eagerly awaiting for Valve to get around to my Steam Deck reservation. With the clock ticking in the back of my head, I realized the major shortcoming of the Nintendo Switch: Cross-save support. Apart from graphics, battery life, or even the comically large size, the Steam Deck succeeds in an area where the Nintendo Switch never capitalized.

Recommended Videos

And I’m confident saying that even before my Steam Deck pre-order has arrived.

Situational gaming

Person holding Nintendo Switch, looking at the home screen.
Nintendo

My Steam Deck hasn’t arrived yet, but I had a short chance to handle and look through the system on my recent trip (thanks, Giovanni). I’ve also seen how it performs across a range of tests, talked with various owners of the system, and done enough research that Google autocompletes “Steam Deck” before I’ve gotten my first few characters out. I know how the system feels, performs, and behaves, despite the fact that mine hasn’t shown up yet.

Handheld gaming is rarely the preferred way to play.

All of that isn’t important, though. The most important thing about the Steam Deck is that I can carry my progress with me. Handhelds have and forever will be platforms of compromise, so while it’s nice to look at benchmarks and talk ergonomics, the fact remains that handheld gaming is rarely the preferred way to play. It’s situational gaming, where you’re willing to compromise just to keep playing.

With my Switch, I find myself running into the same issue time and again. I get ready for a trip, I browse the eShop for deals, and I pick up some long RPG to keep my attention. I never end up making much progress, though, because I’m well aware that when I get back to my PC, I’ll just play on that.

There are problems with the Switch, but none of them bother me. Graphics, frame rate, the Joy-Con’s controls — none of it matters because I’m willing to compromise for portability. What matters is starting from scratch, and that’s something the Steam Deck doesn’t make you do.

Failing cross-saves

The Witcher 3 running on Nintendo Switch.
Reddit User ConnerBartle

The Switch could have ended the Steam Deck before Valve made the first announcement. But Nintendo never capitalized on one of the best features that developers pushed for: Cross-saves. There’s a decent list of Nintendo Switch games that support cross-saves, and they’ve been the backbone of my experience with the handheld.

Outside of Switch exclusives, I mainly play games that allow me to carry my progress back to my PC: Hades, The Witcher 3, Divinity Original Sin 2, and even Civilization VI (as problematic as that port is). There’s also the rogues’ gallery of live service titles with cross-progression on Switch, like Rocket League and Fortnite. 

It’s clear that Nintendo never made the effort the cross-saves.

Nintendo didn’t recognize the rising tide, and it didn’t put any systems in place to make cross-saves between PC and Switch easier. If I could transfer my Dragon Quest XI or Ni No Kuni save like I could with Immortals Fenyx Rising, I probably wouldn’t have pre-order the Steam Deck. Or, at least, I wouldn’t have been as eager to.

I don’t want to downplay the effort required to get universal cross-saves working, but it’s clear that Nintendo never made that effort. And transferring progression is all the more important considering the dumping ground of ports and rereleases the Switch has become in its late years.

Elden Ring running on a Steam Deck.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The Switch isn’t a failure by any metric, but Nintendo could have given the system a lot more legs this far out from release with broader support for cross-saves. The Steam Deck solves that problem for gamers like me who don’t mind compromising on performance if it means picking up where you left off.

Jacob Roach
Former Lead Reporter, PC Hardware
Jacob Roach is the lead reporter for PC hardware at Digital Trends. In addition to covering the latest PC components, from…
The Nintendo Switch 2 is missing one small thing that speaks to a bigger problem
The Nintendo Switch 2 playing Mario Kart

With the Nintendo Switch 2, it looks like Nintendo is finally catching up with its peers like PlayStation and Xbox. That’s not just about 4K visuals and 120fps framerates. For example, Nintendo finally has a unified account system, letting players carry over their original Switch purchases over to the upcoming console. Nintendo’s previous consoles and handhelds all had siloed digital purchases.

The Switch 2 also has its own form of voice chat called GameChat, which lets players speak with their friends and other players online. Unified account systems and internal voice chats are features that Xbox and PlayStation figured out in the 2000s and 2010s, but at least for Nintendo, it’s better late than never.

Read more
I played the Nintendo Switch 2, and one new feature blew me away
A Switch 2 sits on a display next to its controller.

After years of waiting, we finally know a whole lot more about the Nintendo Switch 2. In a Direct presentation on Wednesday morning, Nintendo revealed a host of highly requested features coming to its latest console, from 4K support to significantly expanded storage. Even with all of that clarity and detail, seeing -- and playing -- is believing with a new console. And after actually playing the Nintendo Switch 2, I’d say I’m a believer.

Following the showcase, I went hands on with Nintendo’s new console. I demoed several games, from Mario Kart World to Metroid Prime 4: Beyond, as well as third-party heavy hitters like Split Fiction and Cyberpunk 2077. From that wide range of demos, I was sold on the tech upgrade here, which brings the Switch 2 more in line with the Steam Deck.

Read more
This underrated Switch 2 feature demonstrates why Nintendo handhelds thrive
GameShare on Switch 2.

The Nintendo Switch 2 Direct was filled to the brim with information about all of the new system's unique hardware and software compatibilities. Most of the discussion and allure of Switch 2 comes from features like GameChat, the mouse capability of the Joy-Cons, and the Nintendo Switch camera peripheral. One notable feature of Switch 2 is flying a bit under the radar, though: GameShare. "With GameShare, a new Nintendo Switch 2 feature, players can share and play the same game with others who do not have the game," the official description of the feature reads in a press release.

"If one person has a Nintendo Switch 2 system and a game compatible with GameShare, that person can invite others to temporarily play the same game together via local play with their Nintendo Switch 2 or Nintendo Switch system," it continues. As someone who owns multiple Switch systems and knows other Nintendo fans, I find a feature like GameShare alluring. It also made me look back and think about the importance of connectivity has historically played in Nintendo handhelds, from the Game Boy's Link Cable to the DS' Download Play.

Read more