Skip to main content

‘Paper Mario: Color Splash’ is not making a good first impression with fans

Pokemon Sun, Moon, and Go!

The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild!

Ever Oasis!

Nintendo has focused this year’s E3 on a select few games, but the strategy seems to be paying off, with significant attention coming to Link’s next adventure, in particular.

E3 2016: Ever Oasis is the new action-RPG from Final Fantasy director Koichi Ishii

But before we get our hands on Breath of the Wild and the new NX system, we’ll be able to play the latest in the Paper Mario series, Color Splash. Unfortunately, reactions to the game’s E3 trailer are less than stellar.

The setup certainly darker than the exposition most Mario games. Toad screams in pain as a Shy Guy drains the color from his paper body, sending Paper Mario on a question to restore color to Prism Island, often with Koopas standing in his way.

And the Toads … there are so many Toads.

While the battle system’s occasional mix of realistic visuals and classic 2D characters seems like a perfect fit for the series, the watered down RPG mechanics have not been well-received. Fans on the game’s E3 trailer lament the lack of allies — it looks like you really better like fighting as Paper Mario with his Paint Hammer — and the lack of experience points for defeating enemies.

“There has to be incentive to go into battle, not like Sticker Star,” one YouTube user said on a 40-minute demonstration video for the game. “All battles did was just waste your stickers.”

The backlash came before Sticker Star, however. The Wii’s Super Paper Mario was similarly criticized for putting less focus on the RPG systems that made Super Mario RPG and the first two Paper Mario games so successful, though fan reception was still much better than than of Color Splash.

Paper Mario: Color Splash will be available for Wii U on October 7.

Editors' Recommendations

Gabe Gurwin
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Gabe Gurwin has been playing games since 1997, beginning with the N64 and the Super Nintendo. He began his journalism career…
Paper Mario: The Origami King leaks online; spoilers start to spread
Screenshot of Paper Mario: The Origami King

Paper Mario: The Origami King, the sixth installment in Nintendo's Paper Mario franchise, is set to launch on July 17 for the Nintendo Switch, but the game has apparently already leaked online.

The leak was confirmed on Twitter by Nikki, a well-known Nintendo dataminer.

Read more
Paper Mario: The Origami King gameplay video details combat

Get an in-depth look at Paper Mario: The Origami King! (Nintendo Switch)

Just over a month from its release, Paper Mario: The Origami King looks to be shaking up the traditional Paper Mario formula if a new gameplay video is any indication.

Read more
Metroid Fusion sequel, new Paper Mario rumored for Nintendo Switch this year
Samus stares at her hand in Metroid Fusion.

Metroid Prime 4 may not be arriving soon, but according to rumors, another 2D Metroid game will be coming to the Nintendo Switch this year, along with a new Paper Mario RPG.

Nintendo leaker Sabi, who holds a respectable track record, claims that this year's Nintendo Switch line-up will be bolstered by the two unannounced games.

Read more