Skip to main content

Pay TV is dying, and cable providers are happily hastening its demise

The number of households in the U.S. that have a traditional, paid television subscription is plummeting, but TV providers don’t seem to mind — in fact, a recent report suggests that they’re partly to blame.

According to market research firm eMarketer, more than 25% of U.S. households will be cord cutters by 2023, with the number of traditional, bundled TV plans declining 4.2% this year and continuing at a steady, negative rate of growth going forward. At that rate, the number of households with traditional pay-TV plans will rapidly approach the number of households that either never had a bundled TV subscription or cancel theirs in the years to come.

This aggressive decline in bundled TV subscribers is reportedly a self-inflicted wound, though, with many cable and satellite providers opting to prioritize per-customer profit over a wider revenue stream.

With the costs of maintaining and licensing large bundles of programming on the rise, TV providers are increasing prices for bundled TV plans to the point of pushing away subscribers — only to have those subscribers pivot to the company’s similarly expensive, but significantly more profitable broadband internet service.

LG 75-inch 4K TV
Image used with permission by copyright holder

This shift has developed in concert with the rapid rise of various direct-to-consumer video services such as Netflix, CBS All Access, and the upcoming Disney+ platform, which allow content creators to reach — and continue to earn revenue from — former bundled-TV subscribers.

As the media landscape grows increasingly more consolidated, however, this has also allowed some media companies that encompass both the creation of content and its distribution channels — such as broadband internet providers — to double-dip into their audiences’ wallets. The greater profit margin from this type of arrangement makes it easy to understand why TV providers are more than happy to see subscribers cut the cord on their cable TV plans in favor of a more expensive internet-only package.

Whether such a strategy is sustainable, though, remains to be seen.

At the current rate, the number of U.S. households subscribing to traditional, bundled programming plans from cable or satellite TV companies will drop below 80 million by 2021. The cost of internet plans and existing streaming video services continues to rise, though, along with the number of new direct-to-consumer video services expected to launch between now and then.

The trends suggest that the streaming wars might not be limited to competing services like Netflix and Disney+, but will also pit audiences against the massive media companies that create and deliver their favorite shows.

Editors' Recommendations

Rick Marshall
A veteran journalist with more than two decades of experience covering local and national news, arts and entertainment, and…
If you don’t see CBS in 4K on YouTube TV, try this
Super Bowl in 4K on CBS on YouTube TV.

A quick heads up if you have the 4K add-on for YouTube TV but aren't seeing the option to watch Super Bowl 2024 in 4K on CBS: It's likely because you're using a custom sort on your live channel listings. (Which is something you might have done if you want to hide YouTube TV channels that you never watch.) That'a bad enough for the game itself, and it also means you won't be able to enjoy the Super Bowl Halftime Show in 4K.

This is a known problem — and has been for years — anytime YouTube TV adds a new channel to the listing. If you're not using the default sort on the live channel listings, a new channel will appear at the bottom of the listings, which is bad enough. But worse is that it's hidden by default until you actively go in and unhide it.

Read more
A Sonos TV without a remote? No thanks
A remote contol pointed at a TV displaying the Sonos logo.

In 2023, rumors regarding a possible Sonos TV device picked up steam when Bloomberg’s Mark Gurman reported that the company had plans to release a dedicated streaming box priced around $150 to $200. The device, code-named “Pinewood,” according to Gurman’s unnamed sources, will handle 4K video, along with Dolby Atmos and Dolby Vision. Now, thanks to a previously unreported Sonos patent application unearthed by Janko Roettgers, we know a bit more about how such a Sonos TV device might work, including one very disconcerting detail: it may lack a physical remote control.

The patent application, which goes into exhaustive detail describing the Sonos ecosystem as a whole, places a special emphasis on the role of smartphones as the way we would interact with an as-yet-unreleased Sonos TV streaming device. And yes, in the application, it’s actually called Sonos TV.

Read more
YouTube TV laps the competition with 8 million subscribers
YouTube TV on Apple TV.

If there ever was any doubt which live streaming service was dominating in the U.S., it ends now. YouTube TV has more than 8 million subscribers, according to a blog post penned by CEO Neal Mohan. That's up from the 5 million subscribers the service announced in July 2022.

By comparison, Hulu With Live TV — the second-biggest service — reported 4.6 million subscribers as of September 30, 2023, which marked the end of parent company Disney's fiscal year. YouTube's parent company, Google/Alphabet, doesn't report subscription numbers with any real sort of fidelity. "More than 8 million" is all we're going to get. The new numbers also mean that YouTube TV has about four times as many subscribers as the third-highest service, which is Sling TV, at just over 2 million.

Read more