Skip to main content

Patent troll on the rebound as Apple court-ordered to pay $302M in damages

Apple received some bad news from its ensuing legal battles with VirtnetX, with the Cupertino, California-based company found guilty of patent infringement in a recent retrial, Bloomberg reports.

The retrial came to be from a judge overruling VirtnetX’s February victory against Apple. VirtnetX, a nonpracticing entity, brought its case against Apple, believing the latter violated several patents related to its virtual private networking technologies.

Recommended Videos

In that February decision, Apple was found guilty of patent infringement and ordered to pay almost $626 million in damages. However, a judge overruled the decision in August and ordered two separate retrials. The problem, according to the reversal, was that the original trial, which itself was a combination of two separate patent trials, blurred some lines and might have caused confusion among the jurors.

As a result, the judge ordered two retrials, one of which was this recent decision against Apple. The verdict, handed down by Judge Robert Shroeder in the East Texas Federal District Court, gives VirtnetX a leg up on Apple as the two companies’ legal battles against each other continue to unfold and awarded the nonpracticing entity $302.4 million in damages.

According to court records, however, there will be another court proceeding as to whether Apple willfully violated VirtnetX’s patents, which means the latter might see more money head its way. Furthermore, keep in mind that there is a second retrial down the road, so things do not look extremely bright for Apple at the moment when it comes to VirtnetX.

That second retrial will concern Apple’s more recent security features, as well as iMessage, with the first retrial mainly concerning Apple’s FaceTime protocol. Digital Trends reached out to both Apple and VirtnetX for a comment on the matter and will update if there are responses.

Williams Pelegrin
Williams is an avid New York Yankees fan, speaks Spanish, resides in Colorado, and has an affinity for Frosted Flakes. Send…
The ultimate entertainment tablet: Like-new Fire Max 11 now $130
The back of the Amazon Fire Max 11.

Prime Day isn't officially here yet, but Prime Day deals are. Or, at least a peak of what the deals are going to look like. One of the most exciting of these deals gives you a refurbished Amazon Fire Max 11 tablet for just $130, which is down $70 from the usual $200 and a full $100 less than the retail price of a completely new one. You can even save 20% more with an applicable trade-in. There's no doubt that this is one of the best tablet deals going on at the moment, so tap the button below to lock it in. Or, keep reading to see why you'll like this tablet, take a peek at what our time with it was like, and what it means for something to be refurbished to the 'Like-New' level at Amazon.

Buy Now

Read more
This watchOS 26 feature has me excited for the Apple Watch again
A person wearing the aluminum Apple Watch Series 10.

Ahead of Apple’s long-awaited WWDC keynote earlier this month, the company was widely reported to be working on a new AI-powered doctor that could potentially help you diagnose common conditions, recognize potential illnesses, and understand your overall health. 

The rumored Apple AI doctor had me excited for WWDC, but as we saw, Apple held off on announcing this feature, presumably for a later date. However, WWDC 2025 did introduce a new feature to WatchOS 26 that isn’t a doctor, but rather a friend in the gym who keeps you motivated. 

Read more
Do web browsers on the Apple Watch make sense?
Ant Browser facilitates web access on the Apple Watch.

“It’s a solution for people to reduce their dependence on their phones.” 

That’s what Australian developer Jonathon Lau told me in an interaction about building web experiences for the Apple Watch. We were discussing the Ant Browser, a freemium browser he made specifically for the Apple Watch. But why? 

Read more