Skip to main content

Furious iPhone 4S owners sue Apple for $5M, alleging iOS 9 crippled their phones

google lawsuit
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Apple looks to leave 2015 on somewhat of a sour note, as the company was recently hit with a class-action lawsuit, with the iPhone 4S and iOS 9 at the heart of it all, reports AppleInsider.

The main issue, according to plaintiff Chaim Lerman and other iPhone 4S customers, is that Apple crippled the smartphone’s performance after upgrading to iOS 9. More specifically, after upgrading to iOS 9, Lerman and the other plaintiffs noticed a sharp decrease in performance in third-party apps and Apple’s own applications, such as the Phone app.

Apple’s website for iOS 9 advertises “faster performance, improved security, convenient updates, and longer battery life.”

In addition, because there isn’t an official path to downgrade to a previous iOS version, Lerman feels like the only options iPhone 4S users like himself have are to either keep using the slow smartphone or upgrade to a newer iPhone. Finally, Lerman and the other plaintiffs accused Apple of not properly informing iPhone 4S owners that iOS 9 would “significantly interfere” with the phone’s performance.

As evidence for the latter, the lawsuit points to Apple’s website for iOS 9, which advertises “faster performance, improved security, convenient updates, and longer battery life.” Furthering the point is the plaintiffs’ accusation that Apple must have known about the iPhone 4S’ slower performance on iOS 9, yet didn’t warn owners about such a pitfall. According to the plaintiffs, Apple stands to financially benefit from not warning iPhone 4S owners due to customers readily upgrading to a newer iPhone when given a choice.

In short, the plaintiffs accuse Apple of planned obsolescence, a policy where companies knowingly design products that become non-functional over a set period of time.

Lerman and the more than 100 other plaintiffs are asking over $5 million in damages, with an option to treble, which triples the amount being asked for. No hearings have been set, with New York District Judge Sterling Johnson Jr. presiding over the case.

Unfortunately for the suing party, a previous 2011 lawsuit regarding planned obsolescence and the iOS 4 update for the iPhone 3G was thrown out by the judge. In that case, the judge ruled that iOS 4 was not a good or a service, while also dismissing claims of false advertising and deceptive business practices. In other words, while time has certainly passed and the current case does have a different judge presiding over it, history is not on the plaintiffs’ side.

Editors' Recommendations

Williams Pelegrin
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Williams is an avid New York Yankees fan, speaks Spanish, resides in Colorado, and has an affinity for Frosted Flakes. Send…
It’s official — Apple will announce the iPhone 15 on September 12
Invite for Apple's September 2023 event.

It's official. After months upon months of speculation, we now know when Apple will announce its latest batch of iPhones, Apple Watches, and more. On August 29, Apple sent out press invites for its latest event, which is set to take place on Tuesday, September 12, 2023.

The event invite shows the Apple logo at the top, stylized with what looks like grains of sand in gray, blue, and silvery colors. This is almost certainly a nod to the iPhone 15 Pro, which is heavily rumored to come in black, silver, gray, and dark blue colors this year. Below the Apple logo is similarly colored text that reads "Wonderlust."

Read more
What iPhone do I have? How to find out your iPhone model number
Close-up of the iPhone SE 2022 and iPhone 14 Plus camera modules.

Since its landmark introduction in 2007, Apple has released a total of 38 different iPhone models, and with at least four new ones introduced every fall, the company is showing no signs of slowing down.

In all that time, Apple has made relatively few significant design changes. The company tends to stick with established designs for three or four years before changing things up, which can sometimes make it difficult to tell which iPhone model you have —  especially if you're getting a secondhand iPhone (with no box to offer a hint) rather than a new one.

Read more
If Apple releases the iPhone 15 Ultra next month, it needs these 4 things
A Deep Purple iPhone 14 Pro on top of a Haunted Mansion wallpaper placemat.

With Apple’s fall event just weeks away at this point, it’s pretty much full steam ahead for iPhone 15 rumors. One of the latest reports seems to revive an early rumor that has since been put on the back burner.

What’s the rumor? According to Andrew O’Hara from AppleInsider in a report on MacRumors, it seems that Apple might change the name of the iPhone 15 Pro Max to the iPhone 15 “Ultra.” Originally, this rumor popped up in late 2022 and early 2023 from Apple analyst Ming-Chi Kuo, but it slowly faded as other reports suggested this would be a change coming in 2024.

Read more