Skip to main content

Popular Android navigation apps are just Google Maps with ads, researcher says

More than a dozen free navigation apps on the Google Play Store with collective downloads of over 50 million turned out to be nothing more than Google Maps with ads.

The discovery was made by Lukas Stefanko, a malware researcher at ESET, who tweeted the details of what he found.

Recommended Videos

I tested over 15 fake GPS Navigation apps with over 50,000,000 installs from #GooglePlay that violate Google rules.

These apps just open Google Maps or use their API without any additional value for user, except for displaying ads.

Some of them don't even have proper app icon. pic.twitter.com/eeIFQS5IVU

— Lukas Stefanko (@LukasStefanko) January 17, 2019

Stefanko said that the 19 fake navigation apps only created a “useless layer” of ads between Google Maps and the user, and used screenshots grabbed from legitimate navigation apps for their listings.

The purpose of the fake navigation apps is, of course, to make money through the embedded ads. One of the apps that Stefanko tested even asked for a payment so that the ads will be removed, when Google Maps is entirely free and without ads in the first place. Alarmingly, some of the apps asked for access to the Android device’s dialer and other permissions that a navigation app would not need, which may present security risks for users.

Stefanko has reported the apps to Google for violating the Google Maps terms of use, which prohibit developers from redistributing the app. Some of the offending apps have been taken down, but unfortunately, some still remain available on the Google Play Store.

The Google Play Store has measures in place to make sure that fake and potentially dangerous software, such as these rehashed Google Maps apps, will not find their way to the service. For example, Google deployed a new system combining human intelligence and machine learning to detect fake ratings and reviews on the Google Play Store.

However, with more than 2 million apps available on the Google Play Store, it is inevitable that some fake and/or malicious apps will slip through the safety nets. Stefanko also recently found four fake cryptocurrency apps on the service that attempted to phish the user’s login details or impersonate cryptocurrency wallets.

The lesson here is that users should be very skeptical of anything they download onto their smartphone. One of the best practices is to only trust apps made by well-known companies. Only Google, Apple, and a handful of other companies are capable of gathering the data for capable navigation apps, so those with unknown developers should already raise a red flag.

Aaron Mamiit
Aaron received an NES and a copy of Super Mario Bros. for Christmas when he was four years old, and he has been fascinated…
Apple is revisiting the idea of placing ads in Apple Maps
Apple Maps

In 2022, Mark Gurman warned that Apple was considering putting advertisements in Apple Maps (and in other areas of the iPhone), but that ultimately didn't happen. Now it looks like Apple is revisiting the idea, according to Gurman's most recent Power On! newsletter.

Apple already shows ads in the Apple News and Stocks app, and Gurman says "Apple is giving this notion more thought." The company said it's exploring potential monetization avenues, but there are no concrete plans or a timeline yet.

Read more
Tired of downloading terrible apps? This Google Play Store update will help
A person holding an Android phone while on a bike. The display shows the Google Play Store.

The Google Play Store has an estimated 3.3 million apps available, but they most certainly are not all created equal. Some are no longer updated, some don't work the way they're meant to, and others are just plain terrible — but a new update to the Play Store could make finding the diamonds in the rough much easier.

This update is already live for some users, but it's still rolling out to others. When browsing the Play Store, warnings will appear just below the app information and provide a high-level overview of its performance. For example, it might warn that an app is frequently uninstalled, or the app might not get as much engagement compared to others, according to Android Authority.

Read more
Why do health apps fail? Research bursts the hype with clear evidence
Someone holding an iPhone with the Apple Fitness app open, showing the Custom Plans feature.

Earlier today, Apple announced plans for its next health study that aims to connect information collected by wearables with all major types of wellness markers. The idea is to build atop the massive corpus of data provided by users and develop new digital health tools, covering both sensor and software-based solutions.

But are we relying too much on these digital health tools, despite not getting any meaningful benefits? Experts at the Technical University of Munich have just published their findings in a research paper, and it says the positive impact of telemedicine and exercise apps is minimal for at-risk people.

Read more