Skip to main content

3 underrated movies on Amazon Prime Video you need to watch in May

The three members of Please Don't Destroy standing in a forest looking scared in a scene from Please Don't Destroy: The Treasure of Foggy Mountain.
Peacock/Universal Pictures

Whether it’s a rainy day in or a quiet night at home, why not relax with a good movie? Deciding what movie to watch, however, can be a challenge. You might have already watched all the latest films you had on your radar and you’re looking for something different you’d never have chosen on your own — a hidden gem.

Recommended Videos

There are three underrated movies on Amazon Prime Video you need to watch in May that you might have overlooked. Don’t count them out. One (or more) of these movies, ranging from a 2010 Ryan Gosling mystery/crime drama to a recent Judd Apatow comedy, might be exactly what you’re looking for. They’re all streaming right now with a base subscription to Amazon Prime Video.

All Good Things (2010)

All Good Things Trailer Official

If you’re one of many riding the Ryan Gosling train with his latest hit movies like Barbie and, most recently, The Fall Guy, take a look back at one of the Academy Award-nominated actor’s earlier movies. All Good Things is a mystery/crime romantic drama inspired by the life of Robert Durst. Gosling, alongside Kirsten Dunst, stars as David Marks, a character based on Durst, the son of wealthy real estate tycoon Sanford Marks (Frank Langella, in a role inspired by Seymour Durst) who becomes a suspect in a series of murders. Meanwhile, David’s wife has also mysteriously disappeared.

The movie is directed by Andrew Jarecki, who went on develop the documentary series The Jinx: The Life and Deaths of Robert Durst. It was reportedly All Good Things that caught Durst’s attention and convinced him to sit down with Jarecki for that docuseries, marking the first time he agreed to participate in a project like that about his life and crimes. Both Gosling and Dunst shine in this movie that played an indirectly important role in encouraging Durst to tell his story.

Stream All Good Things on Amazon Prime Video.

Five Nights at Freddy’s (2023)

Five Nights At Freddy's | Official Trailer

The books and video game series are a massive hit among tweens and teens. The supernatural horror movie was met with mixed reviews, but it was unfairly and paradoxically criticized for being too scary for some, while others claimed it wasn’t scary enough. Going into the movie knowing that not every child who is a fan of the franchise will be OK with the level of fright, however, Five Nights at Freddy’s pays homage to the games (and books) in an entertaining way.

With plenty of Easter eggs for die-hard fans, jump scares, and light humor, the movie is a delight for the right audience. Perfect for sleepover fun with kids of a certain age, or for any fan of the books and/or video games, Five Nights at Freddy’s is sorely underrated for what, and who, it’s intended to target.

Stream Five Nights at Freddy’s on Amazon Prime Video.

Please Don’t Destroy: The Treasure of Foggy Mountain (2023)

Please Don't Destroy: The Treasure of Foggy Mountain | Official Trailer

If you love the adorable comedy troupe Please Don’t Destroy that has lent their talents to various shorts and segments on Saturday Night Live, you might want to check out their movie Please Don’t Destroy: The Treasure of Foggy Mountain. Produced by Judd Apatow, the comedy stars the trio as fictional versions of themselves looking for a hidden treasure they first learned about when they were kids.

Please Don’t Destroy: The Treasure of Foggy Mountain has enough funny moments to keep you entertained throughout, like a compilation of their hilarious short skits rolled into one thematic story. Far better reviewed by fans than critics, the movie clearly appeals to the demographic for which it’s intended but goes right over the heads of those who don’t understand the humor. If you fit into the former category and love the types of silly movies that have often come from SNL alumni like Adam Sandler, David Spade, Will Ferrell, and Andy Samberg, Please Don’t Destroy: The Treasure of Foggy Mountain is a worthy addition to the list.

Stream Please Don’t Destroy: The Treasure of Foggy Mountain on Amazon Prime Video.

Christine Persaud
Christine has decades of experience in trade and consumer journalism. While she started her career writing exclusively about…
3 underrated movies on Hulu you need to watch in March 2025
A woman and male dance in the rain.

Fresh off her dominance at the 2025 Oscars, Anora finally heads to Hulu on March 17. Sean Baker's romantic dramedy stars Mikey Madison as Ani, a Brooklyn sex worker who marries the son of a Russian oligarch. The first half resembles a fever dream, while the second half becomes a nightmare. Anora is an excellent Best Picture winner and can now find an audience at home.
Anora should attract a lot of eyeballs. However, there is a wide selection of under-the-radar movies ready to be streamed with the click of a button. The underrated movies featured in March include a rom-com from a famous author, an invigorating dance film, and a steamy thriller.
We also have guides to the best new movies to stream, the best movies on Netflix, the best movies on Hulu, the best movies on Amazon Prime Video, the best movies on Max, and the best movies on Disney+.
The Last Song (2010)

The Notebook gets all the credit as the Nicholas Sparks movie, and rightfully so. It's Ryan Gosling and Rachel McAdams — need I say more? The Last Song is middle-tier Sparks, but there's an argument that it's in the top five. Miley Cyrus stars as Ronnie Miller, an unruly 17-year-old who has never recovered from her parents' divorce three years prior.

Read more
Amazon Prime Video’s AI dubbing could placate cinephiles while angering voice actors
The Amazon Prime Video app icon on Roku.

Amazon Prime Video plans to use AI to dub foreign language shows and movies into English and Latin American Spanish. The company has begun a pilot program that uses "AI-aided" dubbing on 12 licensed movies and series, including titles such as El Cid: La Leyenda, Mi Mamá Lora, and Long Lost.

Amazon says the pilot uses a hybrid approach to dubbing "in which localization professionals collaborate with AI to ensure quality control," and made it clear that it will only use its AI-aided process on content that doesn't already have dubbing support.

Read more
What’s new on Amazon Prime Video in April 2025
Kevin Bacon in The Bondsman.

Amazon may have been a little late turning in its homework this month, but we're giving everything new on Amazon Prime Video in April 2025 a high grade. The selection of new movies added to the Prime Video library, including last year's Oscar contender Conclave, is impressive.

Prime Video also has a strong lineup of originals in April, including The Bondsman, a new series that features Kevin Bacon as a bounty hunter who sends demons back to Hell for Satan. Meanwhile, Viola Davis is an action president in G20, and that's not a joke. Not since Harrison Ford in Air Force One has one of our nation's fictional leaders had to step up to such a challenge largely by themselves.

Read more