Skip to main content

The latest installment of American Horror Story has more stars than a ’70s game show

american horror story hotel full cast evan peters tumblr featured
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Ryan Murphy, co-creator of American Horror Story, has been releasing bits and pieces of information about the fifth season of the popular FX anthology series over the past few months, including news of new and returning cast members. And now, it’s all coming together as we find out not only the exhaustive cast list for season five, entitled American Horror Story: Hotel, but also what roles each actor will play.

New cast members include Lady Gaga, Matt Bomer, and Cheyenne Jackson. As reported by International Business Times, Gaga will utilizing her musical talents to play a lounge singer named Elisa Starr, who’s constantly competing with returning cast member Angela Basset’s character, a jazz singer named Lolita Jones. Meanwhile, both Bomer and Jackson will play bellboys: the former as Terry Castro, who’s often on the lookout to spot trouble, and the latter as the suspicious, gossip-hungry Thimas Seabras.

Recommended Videos

Related: Stay in and scream with 15 horror movies you can stream

Please enable Javascript to view this content

It was recently confirmed that Evan Peters would be returning, and now we know that he will play The Prowler, a creepy young man who hangs around the hotel and dark alleys. Nothing good can come of that. Sara Paulson will also return, playing the role of a character by the name of Janis Joplin. No word on whether she will play the Janis Joplin, but we know she’s a rock star (so there’s a pretty good indicator) who checks in to the hotel and encounters some “terrifying events.” Kathy Bates will also return this season, this time as Claudia DeVeau, Joplin’s agent and pseudo publicist, aiming to keep the rock star’s name out of the bad books.

Other roles will be filled by a pretty impressive mix of returning and new cast, with some fairly big names in Hollywood among them.

Michelle Pfeiffer, for instance, will play Martina McBride – not the country singer, but the previous owner of the Hotel. Lily Rabe is Annabelle Evergreen, the current owner of the hotel who is literally being driven crazy by the supernatural events she’s encountering there, and Alexander Skarsgard will portray Joshua Evergreen, her husband. Donald Sutherland is Father Abner Gates, a priest who visits the hotel to try to cleanse it of the evil spirits. Spoiler alert: it doesn’t go well. Chloe Sevigny is Lois Deon, a happy homemaker with a secretly dark past; and Michael Chiklis will play Dr. Nelson Brackett, an out-of-work scientist. Whew! Quite a star-studded list, and we’re not even finished.

Other hotel workers include: Denis O’Hare as Leo Maxwelll, a hotel bartender and friend of Lolita’s; Tammy Blanchard as Theresa Faulkner, the bitter head maid of the hotel and unofficial peeping Tom on guests; and Grace Gummer as Emma Lam, a hotel maid with an affinity for strange behaviors. Frequent hotel visitors include Frances Conroy as Maude Madelyn, a Marilyn Monroe imitator who loves her men young and, oh yeah, murder; Steven Weber as Ray Ottoman, a hotel inspector who’s visits are never welcomed; and Christine Estabrook as Abigail White, realtor of the hotel who likely has a pretty difficult job that has helped her perfect the art of the “spin” pitch.

Additionally, this season will see Finn Wittrock as a perhaps unlucky engaged man named Newton who decides to spend the night at the hotel for some unknown reason (bet he’s wishing for a refund); and Wes Bentley as Father Dominic Deon, the leader of a religious group.

Notably missing from the cast list is Jessica Lange, who has previously confirmed her departure from the series. She had appeared in all four previous seasons of the show.

American Horror Story: Hotel is set to debut on FX this October – likely just in time for Halloween.

Christine Persaud
Christine has decades of experience in trade and consumer journalism. While she started her career writing exclusively about…
The Odyssey first look shows Matt Damon as Odysseus in Christopher Nolan’s epic
Matt Damon stares with a helmet on.

Christopher Nolan has his Odysseus.

Universal has revealed the first look of Christopher Nolan's The Odyssey. The X post features Matt Damon as Odysseus in a soldier's uniform.

Read more
If you have to watch one Peacock movie this February 2025, stream this one
Dreama Walker in Compliance

Like almost every other streaming service, Peacock has a rotating lineup of titles that seem to move onto and off of the streaming service without any real warning. Universal movies often wind up there, but not always. Even when they do, they might not be there forever.
When you're looking for something to watch, you might not be sure whether it's available on Peacock. Thankfully, that's where we come in. If you're looking for something to watch on Peacock this month, Compliance is the perfect watch. Here are three reasons you should check it out:
Need more recommendations? Then check out the best new movies to stream this week, as well as the best shows on Netflix, best shows on Hulu, best shows on Amazon Prime Video, and best shows on Disney+.
It's based on a startling true story
Compliance Trailer (Official HD Trailer from Magnolia Pictures)
Compliance tells the story of employees at a fast food restaurant coerced into performing a series of illicit and increasingly uncomfortable acts by a man who calls the restaurant claiming to be a police officer.
Although the drama plays out on a relatively small scale, it's remarkably tense throughout, in part because the restaurant's manager finds herself so willing to comply with whatever this man says she should do. One of the movie's central characters only exists over the phone, and nevertheless, those inside the restaurant feel compelled to do whatever he says.

It features a riveting central performance

Read more
Dune: Messiah rumored to start filming this summer
Paul walks in the desert in Dune: Part Two.

Dune: Messiah appears to be starting sooner rather than later.

Per Deadline, Denis Villeneuve's third Dune film is expected to begin filming in June. Legendary Pictures has not confirmed Dune 3's official start date.

Read more