Slick features, universal compatibility give the Microsoft Band a fighting chance

microsofts band can compete with fitbit jawbone microsoft 009
This time last week, we were discussing the potentially limited shelf-life of fitness bands, which are sliding from high-end devices you preorder on Kickstarter to commodity gadgets you grab in the checkout aisle at Walgreens. Lo and behold, a few days later, Microsoft drops the pithily named Microsoft Band on all of our heads. Forgetting its name for a moment (which, quite frankly, sounds like a group of white-collar Redmond workers who get together to jam out on George Thorogood tunes on weekends), the $200 wearable has been getting pretty positive early reviews.

But I stand by those statements made all of seven days ago — in fact, if anything, Microsoft’s entry plays into them nicely.

The fight for the high end of the market is still wide open.

As budget and mid-priced fitness bands get cheaper, and smartphones offer basic fitness functions like step tracking, standing out in the space will either meaning offering your device for free, or offering the sort of premium features people will actually be willing to pay for. The Microsoft Band, clearly, falls into the latter category.

Being Samsung, for instance, means never having to pick a side. You just make something everyone. That means smartwatches, fitness bands, smart fitness bands — you know, a tailor-made wearable for each of the Earth’s 14 billion wrists. Being Google, on the other hand, means developing the software and letting your numerous hardware partners fight it out amongst themselves.

And then, of course, there’s Apple, which has taken on the Herculean task of getting people interested in the watch market, which it played a large role in decimating. And how will Cupertino accomplish such a feat? By making a really, really pretty watch, naturally.


Analyzing Microsoft’s wearable play involves taking a step back into a bygone era called “2004,” when the company launched Smart Personal Object Technology, or SPOT, which allowed household devices to access MSN Direct over the FM band. SPOT powered a broad array of products, from coffee makers to weather stations, but the biggest play by far were watches. Like tablets before them, the products were ultimately doomed by a combination of bad timing and less-than-ideal technology.

With the Band, Microsoft isn’t making that mistake again. It’s jumping into a proven space where other companies are already succeeding. Unlike smartwatches, fitness trackers are already out there in droves, thanks primarily to the successes of companies like FitBit and Jawbone. Microsoft is ready to capitalize on that success and up the ante with some game-changing features, including heart-rate monitoring built directly into the band, and a UV monitor for keeping track of sun exposure.

Unlike smartwatches, fitness trackers are already out there in droves.

At $200, the Band can’t compete with those $12 fitness trackers that have been making headlines in recent months, but it’s not bad price when compared with other premium offerings — namely the Apple Watch. Cupertino’s high-end wearable starts at $350. Start adding things onto it and the pricing only goes up from there, by big round numbers, one suspects. At $200, the Band is priced pretty comparably to other fitness wearables — it’s cheaper, in fact, than the recently announced FitBit Surge. Microsoft seems to have learned its lesson with the Surface tablet line — with few exceptions, breaking into a new space means offering truly competitive pricing.

What truly makes the Band a populist device, however, is its universal compatibility. While the Apple Watch will only work with Apple phones, the Microsoft Band will work with iOS, Android and Windows Phone.

Following Apple’s “closed-ecosystem” approach would almost certainly have been a death sentence for the Microsoft Band. After all, according to IDC’s numbers, Windows Phone was in a distant third for mobile operating system market share in Q2 2014 at around 2.5 percent — a 0.9-percent drop over the same time last year. Sure, Microsoft continues to have faith in its mobile operating system — just not enough faith to risk the health of other emerging product lines.


Making the Band compatible with three operating systems opens it to around 99 percent of potential smartphone users (sorry BlackBerry). And, it just so happens that those Windows Tiles scale pretty nicely to that 1.4-inch color display. Between the last couple of Windows desktop operating systems and the Xbox One, chances are pretty decent that even the staunchest of Windows Phone haters have had some experience with the UI formerly known as Metro.

Unlike some past launches, Microsoft has made some pretty savvy moves in launching a new device this time out. While I still believe low-end fitness trackers are on their way to ubiquity, the fight for the high end of the market is still wide open. The Microsoft name still carries some cache among many consumers, especially when placed against relative unknowns like Jawbone and FitBit.

And at the end of the day, the company isn’t competing directly against Apple here. The two companies are offering two very different products with different feature sets, different usages and different price points. That’s the best-case scenario for both companies, and the bare-wristed consumer.

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.

Editors' Recommendations


Leaks suggest the Microsoft Band 2 may be less embarrassing to wear than the first one

Microsoft may be working on a sequel to the Microsoft Band fitness wearable, and the new model may be sleeker and more stylish than before, if the first leaked renders are accurate.

Samsung’s S Health is your all-in-one health and fitness app, now available on all Android phones

Samsung rarely gets acclaim for its proprietary apps, but S Health is a solid one. It's a comprehensive health and fitness app, and it's now available on all phones running Android 4.4 and higher.
Social Media

He thought he got an Apple Watch, but he got a baby instead

What could possibly be better than an Apple Watch on your birthday? Maybe the news that you’re going to be a father? Both are pretty great, but one is just about priceless, and one lucky man experienced the Apple Watch fake-out firsthand.

Apple Watch at the ready? Feature-packed WatchOS 2 is out now

Apple has added many improvements and feature updates to the Apple Watch with WatchOS 2, including new watch faces and powerful native apps. The software was released on September 21 following a short delay.

Pebble has something new to announce, and rumors say it may be a round smartwatch

Pebble wants to stay involved in all of the wearable chatter, following Apple Watch and Samsung Gear S2 announcements, and will announce a new product this week. Here's what we know so far.

A Massachusetts teen says that the Apple Watch saved his life

High school football player Paul Houle gives full credit to his Apple Watch for saving his life after using the wearable to test his heart rate. Using the Watch to self-diagnose himself with intense chest and back pains, Houle knew…

Apple has been rickrolling us this whole time

Apple has a subtle sense of humor — so subtle that no one noticed the Cupertino company has been rickrolling the public with its Apple Watch support page. Oh Apple, we're never gonna give you up, either.

Whoop athletic wearable stresses recovery for better performance

Meet Whoop, a next-level device that describes itself as "a system robust enough to prepare a Navy SEAL for battle, but with the form factor and design that the average athlete would be comfortable wearing 24 hours a day."

Alibaba partners with FiiSmart to announce Pay Watch, a payments-focused smartwatch

Alibaba has partnered with FiiSmart, a local fitness wearable provider, to create the Pay Watch. It is the e-commerce giant's first smartwatch, with a focus on mobile payments, tickets, and connectivity.

Minecraft Windows 10 Edition gets Oculus Rift support

Oculus Rift creator Palmer Luckey announced at today's Oculus Connect 2 event in Los Angeles that Mojang's hit sandbox construction title Minecraft will receive VR support in a forthcoming update.

The Vector smartwatch, with full 30-day battery life, is now available to order online

The Vector Watch is the latest challenger to rival the Apple Watch, the Pebble, and the various Android Wear smartwatches on sale. It's now available in the U.K. with a starting price of £219.

What to expect from the Google event: Android M, new Nexus phones, Chromecast 2

Google's Nexus event kicks off on September 29 at 9 a.m. PST. Here's everything we expect to see, including the Huawei Nexus P, the LG Nexus 5X, Android M, Chromecast 2, Android TV, Android Auto, and more.
Emerging Tech

Google brings VR field trips to classrooms around the world

While schools would no doubt love to take all their students to fascinating, faraway destinations, logistics and costs can get in the way. That's why Google has come up with Expeditions, a kit that enables virtual field trips to some…

This Google-powered jacket from Levi’s is more than just a jacket

The Levi’s and Google jacket lets you look good and stay on top of your daily tasks with access to the information you need, when you need it.