Would an Android laptop be worth buying? Probably not

Android Laptop Lid

Rumors about the potential of an Android laptop have been circling since Android’s former head honcho, Andy Rubin, stepped aside in early 2013. His replacement? Sundar Pichai, overseer of the Chrome browser and operating system. Though this shuffling of corporate chairs could merely be an internal matter, some have speculated it heralds the merge of Android and Chrome OS into a single uber-OS for all devices.

We could go on about the reasons why this may or may not occur, but there’s a more interesting question beneath the rumors: Would an Android laptop even be exciting, or would it create an unholy hybrid unsuitable for any task?

New hardware, same as the old hardware

Motorola Atrix 4G

In a way, this question has already been asked and answered by third-party companies. Motorola produced a keyboard dock for its first Atrix phone, but it gained little traction. ASUS has had better luck with its Transformer tablets, though the percentage of customers that actually buy the keyboard dock is unclear. Other companies, like Lenovo, have shown prototypes but haven’t brought them to market in North America.

Because Google doesn’t do its own manufacturing, the products we’ve seen in the past are an indicator of what we’d be likely to see if Google produced its own Android laptop. The same would be true, of course, if Google did not release its own branded laptop and instead only created a version of Android directed at laptops and desktops.

This means that any theoretical Android laptop would, from a hardware perspective, probably be boring. Expect a 10- to 12-inch display, basic processor, and solid-state drive. The company might aim such a device at the high end and thus equip it with a 1440p+ display like that found on the Pixel, but, even then, the core of the device would likely be no different from what’s already sold.

Interface revisions necessary


We’ve tested Android mini-PCs as an alternative to traditional desktops. Though the experience was usable, any operating system designed for a desktop is better. Those devices were made tolerable only by their low price.

A hypothetical Android laptop, however, would not sell for less than $60. It would probably be priced at $300 on the low end, and possibly much more depending on equipment. Whatever its retail might be, there’s a reasonable price at which the laptop might be a good value. If Android was just ported, with minimal tweaks, it would be nearly useless on a laptop.

To provide a viable alternative to Windows and OS X, the entire interface would have to be revised. Multi-tasking would have to work well with a mouse, the homescreen would have to work better in landscape view, and a competent dock or taskbar would have to be introduced. Android doesn’t even have windows, so that too would have be introduced along with snap and resize functionality.

Alternations aimed at making Android viable for a laptop would hurt smartphones, however. To solve this, Google might fork Android into different versions. But that was already tried with Honeycomb, the version of Android created with tablets in mind, and the split caused minor catastrophe. Developers saw no reason to develop for Honeycomb, which was dwarfed in popularity by Android 2.x – leaving early Android tablets with few exclusive apps to run.

Why doesn’t Google just make an operating system that works for all devices? The answer, put simply, is that it’s hard. Spanning Android between smartphones and tablets has already given the company’s engineers plenty to worry about. Adding laptops on top of that seems absurd. Sure, it’s theoretically possible to create a scalable OS that works on anything, but no one has done it before – or even come close. We may as well ask Google to invent a fusion reactor (and make it no larger than a thimble, please).

The appocalypse

Google Nexus 10 review screenshot google play android tablet

Let us imagine that everything we just said wasn’t a problem. An alien civilization, drawn in by YouTube’s endless parade of cute kitten videos, has taken mercy on us and made the Intergalactic Scalable OS available for download. It works perfectly on every device all of the time.

Google would still have a problem. Why? Because a perfect operating system doesn’t guarantee perfect apps. Developers run into the same challenges as Apple, Google, and Microsoft when crafting an interface for their software, and they have fewer resources available to face them. Many devs already have their hands full with smartphones and tablets, which is why some apps are only available for one or the other.

Adding a laptop into the mix would further fracture Android’s ecosystem. Gaining traction with the developer community would be difficult, as most would see no reason to develop an entirely new version of their app for an Android laptop that would almost certainly make up less than 1 percent of new Android activations for the first year of its life. Most apps for the laptop would be built with a minimum of effort, if at all, leaving users with little software to run on their device. 

Okay, we’re exhausted

And, and, and…

Well, you get the point. A hypothetical Android laptop would unite smartphones, tablets, and laptops. It would also be terrible.

Chrome OS exists because no one at Google knows how to create an operating system that would span smartphones, tablets, and laptops. That they don’t know is not an insult – no one knows, because the problem is hard. But until the problem is solved, Android will be a poor choice for a traditional laptop or desktop PC, just as Chrome OS wouldn’t work well on a smartphone or tablet.

This does not mean Android will never support laptops or traditional desktops. Eventually, some brilliant engineer will find a way to unify the disparate experiences across smartphones, tablets, and PCs. But current rumors suggest that this merge will happen this year – and Android isn’t ready for the transition. 

The views expressed here are solely those of the author and do not reflect the beliefs of Digital Trends.


Android will finally get a faster sharing menu, but it might take a while

The Android sharing menu has gotten a whole lot better over the years, but it's also gotten slower. Thankfully, however, it seems as though Google is working on a better, faster sharing menu but, unfortunately, it may take a while.

These laptop makers produce the most reliable, quality hardware today

If you want to buy your next laptop based around a specific brand, it helps to know which the best brands of laptops are. This list will give you a good grounding in the most reliable, quality laptop manufacturers today.

Check out 25 of the best Wear OS apps for your smartwatch

Looking for some ways to spruce up that new Android smartwatch of yours? Here are the best Wear OS apps to download and use with any Android smartwatch, including a few specially enhanced for Wear OS 2.0.

Buying a laptop on Black Friday? Don't make one of these rookie mistakes

Shopping for a laptop on Black Friday can win you some excellent deals, but you should also avoid making common mistakes. Check out what to avoid when buying a laptop for Black Friday and what danger signs to be wary of.

These cheap laptops will make you wonder why anyone spends more

Looking for a budget notebook for school, work, or play? The best budget laptops, including our top pick, the Asus ZenBook UX330UA - will get the job done without digging too deep into your pockets.

The 100 best Android apps turn your phone into a jack-of-all-trades

Choosing which apps to download is tricky, especially given how enormous and cluttered the Google Play Store has become. We rounded up 100 of the best Android apps and divided them neatly, with each suited for a different occasion.

Taking shots in the dark with Night Sight, the Pixel’s newest photo feature

The Google Pixel range has always been the home of some of the mobile world's best phone cameras. That performance is now getting even better with the introduction of the low-light Night Sight mode.

Best Google Pixel 3 XL screen protectors

It's tough to find good screen protectors, but the 6.3-inch OLED screen in the Google Pixel 3 XL definitely demands to be protected from scratches and impact damage. We've picked out the best options and included insight into the downsides.

Pocket Casts adds more cross-sync, curation, and Siri Shortcuts

Pocket Casts is a pocket staple for many podcast fanatics. But it's about to get even better with the introduction Pocket Casts 7.0 that adds intelligent curation, Siri Shortcuts support, and a streamlined UI.
Product Review

Mediocre battery and a big notch slight Google's otherwise perfect Pixel phone

Google’s Pixel 3 XL has two big flaws: The gigantic notch on the front, and mediocre battery life. That being said, this is the best Android experience you can find in a smartphone today.

Upcoming Galaxy S10 may support 8K video and have Neural Processing Unit

While we still may be months away from an announcement, there's no doubt about it: Samsung is working hard on its successor to the Galaxy S9. Here's everything we know about the upcoming Samsung Galaxy S10.

Samsung will reportedly announce its folding smartphone at MWC in February

Samsung has been showcasing bendable display tech for a few years and now a folding smartphone might finally arrive. The Galaxy X, or perhaps the Galaxy F, may be the company's first example. Here's everything we know about it.

Text messages are disappearing on Pixel 3s, but a fix is on the way

The Google Pixel 3 and Pixel 3 XL are arguably the best Android phones out there right now -- but they aren't perfect. Users have reported a number of issues and problems related to the Google Pixel 3 and Pixel 3 XL. Here's how to fix them.

Get ready for more V-series phones: LG trademarks names up to the V90

It looks like we should get ready for more LG V-series phones. LG has trademarked names for the LG V50 all the way up to the LG V90. We may have to wait some time before we see these phones; the next LG flagship is expected to be the LG G8.