Skip to main content

Cloud gaming is not your enemy

Historically, gaming fans are resistant to change — and sometimes for good reason. Through its long history, the video game industry has experimented with ideas that tend to pit the best interests of players against those of corporations. Everything from invasive microtransactions, to the Xbox One’s failed always-online plan, to the current NFT craze have prompted a vocal pushback from skeptical players.

With gamers currently on high alert due to a new wave of buzzy industry concepts, cloud gaming is seemingly under more scrutiny than ever. The more companies experiment with the tech, the more it’s treated as an existential threat to the industry. When Kingdom Hearts came to Nintendo Switch via cloud ports, fans dragged it through the mud. Sony’s recent revelation that PS Plus will feature cloud versions of PS3 games triggered similar blowback from fans who demanded native ports.

The skepticism is understandable as cloud proponents have yet to earn players’ trust. Cloud gaming continues to be a tricky technology as it relies on a user having a good internet connection — something that isn’t always possible in most of the U.S. However, outright opposition to the tech can feel misplaced. Unlike other recent tech innovations, cloud gaming could actually solve problems. In fact, we’re already seeing just how positive it can be as an option.

Mounting skepticism

The negative response to cloud gaming’s continued growth is complicated. While players have plenty of legitimate issues with the tech, part of the response stems from its initial implementation. When Google launched its cloud platform Stadia in 2019, there was no real road map for how the cloud should integrate into video games. Google packaged its service into a pricey subscription model that prioritized the tech itself over the actual games that supported it. With a small launch lineup and a lack of features at launch, Stadia immediately struggled to find its footing.

That start to the revolution may have poisoned the well for some. For a time, cloud gaming became synonymous with subscription services. It didn’t help that Amazon jumped on Google’s bandwagon with Luna shortly after, reinforcing that perception. Disgust for the tech seemed inseparable from rational fears that video games were moving into a subscription era.

A gamer plays Destiny 2 on a phone via Google Stadia.
Rich Shibley/Digital Trends

While that might have exacerbated the skepticism, it’s far from the sole reason gamers still turn their nose up at the tech. The always-online nature of cloud gaming presents a bevy of problems for gamers who don’t live in a major city that has access to fast internet. Lag and image quality dips can put a damper on experiences like Destiny 2. With no way to play games offline, there’s no guarantee that players will get a fully stable experience playing over Wi-Fi.

Other issues are more complex. Ownership becomes an especially slippery concept with the cloud, and that’s something players have long been prickly about. If someone buys a game on Google Stadia and Google shutters the service, subscribers simply won’t have access to it anymore. That bleeds over into concerns over game preservation, as some fear that a move to the cloud would eventually make some titles disappear into thin air one day.

These are all valid concerns, but they’re ones born out of a scenario in which cloud gaming outright replaces the way we play now. That’s simply not the reality of the tech.

Best-case scenarios

The cloud’s role in the modern gaming landscape is mostly a supplemental one. It’s part of a wider industry philosophy that aims to make gaming more flexible — the same idea that birthed the Nintendo Switch and Steam Deck. For dedicated console and PC players, it means that it’s now possible to play something like Halo Infinite on vacation without lugging a pricey machine around. The aim is to give us more options, not less.

The tech is a potential problem solver and we’re starting to see its utility unfold in unexpected ways. Its most obvious benefit is financial. For those who don’t want to spend $500 buying a new console or much more on a capable PC, cloud gaming lowers the barrier for entry by putting high-end games on the devices they already own. It widens access and that’s fundamentally a net positive outcome.

Someone playing Fortnite on a phone.
Photo by Joshua Hoehne on Unsplash

But perhaps the best example of the cloud as a force for good came last week when Microsoft made a cloud version of Fortnite free to all players, no Game Pass subscription required. The move had a monumental side effect: It stealthily brought the game back onto iOS devices. Fortnite hasn’t been available on the App Store since 2020, a decision that led to a high-profile legal battle between Apple and Epic Games. At the time, Apple banned the title as punishment for Epic trying to skirt around Apple taking a cut of its in-app sales. It was a show of force that highlighted how much power the company has over developers.

Microsoft’s Fortnite move took that power away from Apple. Now, players can once again enjoy the battle royale on iOS devices, and there’s not much the company can do about it.

When used as a tool, the cloud can solve problems like that. Sony’s decision to make PS3 games available via the cloud may be frustrating, but it’s a clever way to get around the complicated architecture that’s made it historically difficult to port titles like Metal Gear Solid 4 to modern devices. Given the state of the Nintendo Switch and its aging tech, the cloud gives players a way to experience modern titles like Control that simply wouldn’t run on the console otherwise.

Team Sonic Racing being played on a variety of devices that support Amazon Luna.

In all of these scenarios, the alternative would be that these games simply wouldn’t exist on these platforms. Fortnite would continue to be unplayable on iOS due to corporate politics, PS3 games would remain lost to time, and Switch owners would have less options. While none of those may be optimal experiences for players with poor internet currently, their existence is purely additive.

As the tech currently stands, there’s not much sense in rooting against cloud gaming in the same way that players push back on microtransactions or NFTs. As long as it continues to supplement traditional gaming experiences, it’s a powerful tool that stands to help more than hurt. You don’t have to buy in, but it’s not our enemy.

Editors' Recommendations

Topics
Giovanni Colantonio
Giovanni is a writer and video producer focusing on happenings in the video game industry. He has contributed stories to…
This sci-fi game predicted our current AI landscape four years ago
Evelyn sits on a bench in Eliza.

Like many others, I’m currently fascinated -- and a little terrified -- by rapid advancements in AI. While the tech seems like it could be used for good, several applications of it leave me worried. Websites have replaced human writers with error-prone robots, Hollywood refuses to protect its creative talent from the tech, and AI-generated games like Sumner have raised red flags about bot plagiarism. Though what’s concerned me most in the last few months is the existence of AI therapy.

There are currently a handful of services available that automate therapy in some way. Woebot is an “automated conversational agent” that’s being positioned as a personal mental health tool. Users can check in with it every day to have brief conversations with a chatbot who will send over wellness tips and videos. Wysa, on the other hand, pairs users with an AI coach, but Premium users can add in 1:1 human support. Considering how much traditional therapy relies on connection with a real person, the idea of automating it seems like a recipe for disaster.

Read more
Nintendo Switch’s weirdest launch game is getting a surprise sequel
Key art for Everybody 1-2-Switch!

Nintendo has quietly announced Everybody 1-2-Switch!, a sequel to one of the oddest launch titles for Nintendo Switch.
1-2-Switch! was a Nintendo Switch launch title that served as a tech demo of sorts for the Joy-Con controllers, with players completing minigames based on direction from actors in live-action clips. It's a very quirky and critically divisive Nintendo Switch game, so it's a bit surprising to see a follow-up. According to the eShop listing for Everybody 1-2-Switch!, this game lets players use their Joy-Cons or smartphones to complete a variety of team-based minigames. And that's about all we've seen or know about this $30 game ahead of its June 30 launch alongside some new pastel Joy-Cons.

Everybody 1-2-Switch!'s announcement was quite unorthodox for Nintendo. It simply tweeted about the game's existence and opened up preorders on the eShop. This all happened with no reveal trailer less than a month before the game's launch. It's unknown why Nintendo's taking this approach instead of including the game in a Nintendo Direct or other major showcase, but a 2022 report from Fanbyte may reveal the answer. According to that report, Everybody 1-2-Switch! tested horribly, and Nintendo worried that the game could "damage the company’s reputation as a great software developer." 
Almost a year after that report, it seems that the game has improved enough to release, or maybe Nintendo is just willing to take the hit after the impressive launch and critical reception of The Legend of Zelda: Tears of the Kingdom. Either way, this is a weird sequel to a weird Nintendo Switch launch game that's being mutedly marketed so it doesn't elicit much hype. We'll just have to wait and play it for ourselves if we want to know whether Everybody 1-2-Switch! is an enjoyable game or not.
Everybody 1-2-Switch! will be released physically and digitally for Nintendo Switch on June 30.

Read more
Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse features an incredible video game Easter egg
Miles Morales falls through a multiverse portal in Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse.

Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse is out now and it contains a wealth of Easter eggs for video fans to obsess over. It's full of references to Spidey's history, from his comic books to cartoons and beyond. The animated sequel even includes some nods to the franchise's video game history, leading to one of its best (and most obscure) references: Spider-Man for the Atari 2600.

(A quick heads up if you're afraid of spoilers: This article contains some very light story details for Spider-Man: Across the Spider-Verse.)

Read more