Skip to main content

New York Giants’ Sterling Shepard is not a fan of his ‘Madden NFL 18’ rating

The Madden NFL video game franchise has been the only way millions of sports fans can play NFL stars for more than a decade. Shelling out $60 for the latest edition from EA Sports is a yearly ritual celebrated by armchair athletes and actual ones alike. New York Giants wide receiver Sterling Shepard is one of those avid Madden fans — and after years of on-field and video game experience, he wants a few things changed about the virtual pigskin franchise.

Madden has dominated the NFL gaming market by sheer monopoly, and a constant criticism of the franchise is its lack of innovation. So before Shepard squared off against teammate Landon Collins at Microsoft’s flagship store in New York City the night before the game’s launch, Shepard spoke with Digital Trends about how he hopes Madden will put more control in gamer’s hands.

It’s all about control

Digital Trends loved Madden NFL 18, partly for how closely the gameplay mimics the NFL games you watch on Sundays. Player animations are more realistic than ever, and features like Target passing give more control over where the ball goes.

Yet Shepard wants even more control. “I would like it if you could make the move yourself. I double tapped B to spin, and he’s not spinning when I want him to, really,” he told Digital Trends.

Madden needs to make sure gamers can’t automatically win by selecting certain players.

Madden NFL 2004 and its cover athlete, former Atlanta Falcons sensation Michael Vick, is an example of the type of gameplay Shepard desires. Vick in Madden NFL 2004 was a cheat code in cleats, able to drop back 30 yards and still throw a 60-yard touchdown with the flick of a few buttons.

“He has such a strong arm in the game and in real life, so you can make pretty crazy throws with him,” Shepard says with an excitement in his eyes. “Throwing back across your body. Stuff that you probably wouldn’t be able to do in real life. Mike Vick was that type of player.”

This is a place where the realities of game design bump up against the realities of, well, reality. A game like Madden needs to make sure gamers can’t automatically win by selecting certain players, or stacking their team. Shepard knows he can’t change that part of the game — but he would like to change the player. One player, in particular.

Reality vs. ratings

Modern athletes measure themselves in wins, championships, money, and video game ratings. Shepard says the Giants locker room is “always talking about ratings,” and at the launch of Madden NFL 18, Shepard’s overall rating was an 80, up from a 74 at the launch of Madden NFL 17.

Improvement or not, that rubbed him the wrong way, until he found out his video game destiny is in his real-life hands. “My rating? It’s alright. It needs some tweaking,” Shepard jokingly remarked. “I was told it can move throughout the season. When I heard that, I was alright with where I’m at.”

Madden NFL 18 gaming fans

Odell Beckham Jr — superstar Giants receiver, record breaker and the youngest Madden cover athlete ever — received a cumulative rating of 93 at launch. That is good enough to place him in a nine-player 7th place tie for all players, and fourth place among wide receivers.

Most players would do backflips to simply enter the 90-point range. Yet, both on the field or off, most players are not Odell Beckham Jr. “The other day Odell [Beckham Jr] was talking about his rating, and how they kind of shafted him on the overall rating,” according to Shepard.

The NFL seasons starts in full on September 10 with the Giants squaring off against division rivals, Dallas Cowboys. Shepard’s on-field play will change his rating in Madden as the season progresses, so if you see him putting his body on the line for a seemingly meaningless five-yard catch, you can thank your copy of Madden NFL 18.

Editors' Recommendations

Keith Nelson Jr.
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Keith Nelson Jr is a music/tech journalist making big pictures by connecting dots. Born and raised in Brooklyn, NY he…
Madden NFL 21 getting community-requested tweaks to Franchise mode
most anticipated video games 2020 madden 21

Madden NFL 21 will receive major tweaks to its franchise mode following criticism from the game’s community. The football game will get three waves of post-launch updates with the first scheduled for mid-November.

EA Sports plans to bring four major changes to the mode based on community feedback. Top among the fan-requested features, commissioners will get the ability to assign X-Factors to any player and edit their superstar abilities. The team will roll out fixes to assure that Superstars and X-Factor players are more balanced throughout a multi-year franchise.

Read more
Electronic Arts will remove Washington Redskins name, logo in Madden NFL 21
madden nfl 21 washington redskins in

Electronic Arts will remove all references to the Washington Redskins in Madden NFL 21, after the football team's announcement that it will be developing a new name.

Earlier this week, the Washington Redskins said that following a review that started July 3, it decided that the Redskins name and logo will be retired, after years of criticism that they perpetuate racist stereotypes against Native Americans. The team's new name and logo have not yet been revealed.

Read more
EA renews Madden exclusivity deal with NFL, NFLPA
Madden NFL 20

Electronic Arts renewed its exclusivity deal with the NFL, locking in Madden as the only NFL-approved football sim for years.

EA Sports, the National Football League, and the NFL Player’s Association announced a multiyear renewal of their long-term partnership on Thursday.

Read more