Skip to main content

German court ruling says Nintendo doesn’t have to refund e-shop pre-orders

Image used with permission by copyright holder

When Nintendo Switch players pre-order a game at a physical retail store, they can usually cancel it before the game’s release. However, on the Nintendo eShop, all sales are final.

That controversial policy held up in a German court, though it’s pending appeal, and takes away players’ right to cancel their buy in the lead-up to launch. It also defines a pre-order as a purchase in its own right, despite delivery coming after money is exchanged.

Thomas Iversen  the Norwegian Consumer Council’s senior legal adviser, expressed the agency’s frustration over the ruling to Digital Trends. It had sued Nintendo regarding its policy, alongside the German Consumer Protection Authority.

“It is unfortunate that the district court in Germany has concluded that the delivery of the product is said to start before the product can be of any use to the consumer,” Iversen said. “To us, preloading of content does not mean a game has been delivered. The consumer cannot play the game or use any of its content until launch date.”

The Download - December 2019 - Dauntless, Shovel Knight: King of Cards & More!

In the U.S., players have even fewer protections. Ryan Morrison, who is known as the “video game attorney” and is a founding partner at law firm Morrison Rothman, told Digital Trends that the U.S. does not have mandatory refunds for digital purchases. Decisions made on return policies would come from a business rather than a legal perspective. Morrison noted that Nintendo’s stated policies sufficiently inform customers that pre-order sales are final.

“Whenever you buy a product (pre-order or not) on the Nintendo eShop, you’re not just giving them money,” Morrison added. “You’re giving them your money, and you’re communicating to them that you agree to the Nintendo eShop purchase terms.”

Nintendo’s pre-order policy isn’t identical to all competitors. Microsoft, for instance, will not bill purchasers’ cards until 10 days before launch. They can cancel it with no hassle before this period and can request a refund afterward. PlayStation Network functions similarly, allowing for refund requests provided that players have not started or downloaded the game yet, and Steam allows for returns if they’ve been played for less than two hours.

Nintendo players hoping for a change can follow other gamers and speak with their wallets. Large-scale business model changes came to Star Wars: Battlefront II and its loot box system, among other examples, after fan outcry. So far, Nintendo doesn’t seem to be facing significant pushback from gamers for its pre-order policy.

Editors' Recommendations

Gabe Gurwin
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Gabe Gurwin has been playing games since 1997, beginning with the N64 and the Super Nintendo. He began his journalism career…
The best GTA 5 roleplay servers
A police shootout in GTA 5.

We all love GTA 5 for letting us live out our more chaotic and destructive fantasies, but you aren't just limited to being a criminal in the world Rockstar Games has created. The single-player version is packed with content, but jumping online is where the possibilities really open up. Role-play servers, also called RP servers, modify the game and rules, with players expected to fully commit to whatever character they choose to embody. If you're a cop, you shouldn't be recklessly driving and shooting civilians, for example. You can't expect to randomly jump into an online lobby and have everyone follow the rules, though. You will need to join very specific RP servers to get the true experience. While we wait for GTA 6, here are the best role-play servers out there.

Note that all RP servers are accessed through either the FiveM or Rage MP clients. You will need to download them separately.
NoPixel

Read more
Black Myth: Wukong is a perfect chaser for Stellar Blade fans
A monkey man faces off against a fiery boss in Black Myth: Wukong.

When I sat down to try Black Myth: Wukong at Summer Game Fest, I began asking the person leading the demo questions about the gameplay to get myself situated. What is the resource for leveling up my stats? Would I drop currency when I die? Could I parry attacks? I went in assuming it was your standard Soulslike, just with a more fantastical premise. After getting a few surprising answers, the demo runner noted that the developers didn’t exactly want it to be viewed as a Soulslike -- they prefer to just call it an action RPG.

That made total sense by the end of my demo. While Black Myth: Wukong does include lots of elements you’d expect from a game like Dark Souls, parts of it are much more in line with traditional action games. That makes for a happy medium between subgenres that’ll resonate with players who want more games like this year’s Stellar Blade.
Fast and furious
My demo begins early in Black Myth: Wukong’s first chapter. I’m tossed into a thick jungle that’s mostly linear, but has a few branching paths that lead to secrets. I get the basics of combat down quickly when I find some weak enemies and thwack them with my staff. The first thing that stands out is how quick my attacks are. While I do have a slow heavy attack that can punish me for overcommitting, my light attacks let me pepper foes with lots of little hits in rapid succession.

Read more
A Quiet Place is getting even bigger with a video game out this year
The cover art for A Quiet Place. There's a person at the top in black and white holding a finger to their lips. Below them is a red empty street.

Ahead of the release of A Quiet Place: Day One, the franchise is continuing its media dominance. Saber Interactive announced that it's publishing A Quiet Place: The Road Ahead, a first-person, single-player horror video game due out later in 2024 for PC, PlayStation 5, and the Xbox Series X/S.

The game takes place in the Quiet Place universe, but features a whole new story about a woman trying to survive the alien apocalypse while dealing with "the anguish of interpersonal family conflicts and her own inner fears." The gameplay, similar to the movies, will focus on stealth as you try to get around the creatures without making a sound, and scrounging up items and tools that you can use to improvise your way out of situations.

Read more