Skip to main content

Does Amazon’s new Fire TV Stick put Roku out to pasture? We pit the two against each other to find out

Fire TV stick vs. Roku Streaming stick
Image used with permission by copyright holder
Amazon’s Fire TV Stick was such a hit at launch that it is now backordered into next year. Part of its success can be attributed to its low $40 price ($20 for early bird Amazon Prime members), but the HDMI dongle’s impressive hardware specs are equally appealing, making the Roku Streaming Stick look almost like a toy in comparison.

But, as is often the case, the specs don’t tell the whole story. Does a streaming HDMI dongle really need a dual-core processor or an entire gigabyte of RAM to do its job well? According to our experience, the answer is: not necessarily. Most basic TV-watching functions do just fine on more meager hardware, as evidenced by the Roku Streaming Stick’s solid performance in key areas. Fold gaming into the mix, though, and it’s an entirely different story.

In our video, we illustrate the key differences between the Amazon Fire TV Stick and the Roku Streaming Stick, then pit the two against each other to assess app loading time, content loading times, response to user input, and overall user experience. As you’ll see, there is no clear-cut winner. The question, as it turns out, isn’t which streaming stick is best, it is which streaming stick is best for you.

If you like the idea of playing games with a console-style feel, or you are heavily invested in Amazon’s Prime universe, then the Fire TV stick is the best pick. But if you want access to the most apps, a search feature that polls multiple services for the stuff you want to watch, and a user-friendly interface that’s easy to love, then the Roku Steaming Stick is your best bet. Either way, know this: The streaming HDMI stick offers an experience that approaches that of a fully-fledged set-top box, but at a fraction of the price. And if tech history is anything to go by, it will only get better from here.

Editors' Recommendations

Caleb Denison
Digital Trends Editor at Large Caleb Denison is a sought-after writer, speaker, and television correspondent with unmatched…
Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Max packs even more power at just $55
Amazon fire tv remote sitting on couch.

Amazon has taken care of the larger part of the living room with the new Fire TV Omni Series -- the first-ever Amazon-built televisions -- but it hasn’t forgotten about the smaller side. Enter the new Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Max. As the name implies, it’s basically the Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K — already the best Amazon Fire TV device for most people — just made even better. Mostly.

The Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Max, and Alexa Voice Remote. Amazon / Amazon

Read more
New Fire TV experience, AirPlay 2 hits more devices this week
Amazon Fire TV New 2020 experience profiles screen

Starting this week, Amazon will be rolling out its new Fire TV interface to more media streaming devices and smart TVs. Initially, Amazon launched the new experience on the third-generation Fire TV Stick and Fire TV Stick Lite, but it's now rolling out to the Fire TV Stick (second-gen), Fire TV Stick 4K, Fire TV Cube (first and second generations), Fire TV (third-gen, pendant design), and multiple Fire TVs. The only Fire TV device that has yet to get the update is the 2017 Element 65-inch 4K UHD.

Simultaneously, Amazon has updated two Fire TV Edition models with Apple AirPlay 2 and Apple HomeKit technologies: The Toshiba 4K UHD Smart Fire TV with Dolby Vision (2020 model) and the Insignia 4K UHD Smart Fire TV (2020 model).

Read more
Numbers don’t lie: Roku’s streaming spats have given Amazon the edge
Amazon Fire TV Stick

For a long time, we've thought of Roku as the streaming media king. Not just because its software is so easy to use and its devices so affordable, but also because of its popularity -- the company has traditionally enjoyed a much larger share of the streaming market than its competitors. But it looks like the company's contentious relationships with some of the biggest names in streamed entertainment may be hurting that reputation: Amazon has just announced that its Fire TV platform has hit 50 million monthly active users on its devices globally, a number that comfortably edges out Roku, which reported 46 million monthly active users in November.

It took Roku a number of months to solve its differences with NBCUniversal's Peacock, but a similar dispute with entertainment giant HBO Max continues, with no end in sight. These spats alone don't necessarily account for Roku's slower growth when compared to Amazon's Fire TV, especially given that both Peacock and HBO Max are U.S.-only services right now. Other factors include the aggressive rollout and pricing of Amazon's new Fire TV devices, which in some cases deliver more features for less money than the equivalent Roku devices. Amazon's Alexa is now built into every Fire TV device, as one example.

Read more