Skip to main content

Echo Plus (1st-gen) vs. Echo Plus (2nd-gen)

Over the past few years, Amazon has been coming out with new and different Echo devices to meet the needs of its customers. In late 2017, Amazon released the Echo Plus, which made controlling your smart home easier. The Echo Plus has a built-in Zigbee smart home hub. This means you don’t need a separate device, like the Samsung SmartThings hub, to control your smart home (more on that later).

In October 2018, Amazon released the second-generation Echo Plus. What’s the difference between the two Echo Plus devices? This guide explains the ins and outs of both devices to help you decide whether to upgrade or which to buy — and what may work if neither is available.

Summary

Sound Design Features Price
Echo Plus (1st-gen) 2.5-inch woofer, 0.8-inch tweeter Hard plastic surface, 9.2″ x 3.3″ x 3.3″ No temperature sensor $80-$150
Echo Plus (2nd-gen) 3-inch woofer, 0.8-inch tweeter Fabric surface, 5.8″ x 3.9″ x 3.9″ Has temperature sensor $150

Sound

Amazon received reviews and feedback from customers about poor sound quality on the first-generation Echo Plus. The first-generation Plus has a 2.5-inch subwoofer and a 0.8-inch tweeter. If you compare that to the original Echo, which has a 2.5-inch woofer (with a reflex port to decrease sound distortion) and a 2-inch tweeter, the Plus provides less in terms of sound quality. Many customers say the first-generation Plus doesn’t have clear and crisp treble, and the bass isn’t very powerful.

echo plus 2nd gen speaker cross section
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The second-generation Echo Plus has increased back volume and a larger subwoofer at 3 inches. It still has a 0.8-inch tweeter like its predecessor. This means better sound quality (stronger bass, plus crisper mid- and high-tones).

Both the first- and second-generation Echo Plus devices let you adjust the treble and bass with your voice. They also both have a 3.5 mm audio output jack, which allows you to connect a more powerful speaker to your Plus.

Design

The first-generation Echo Plus looks a lot like the original Echo. It is cylindrical, 9.2- inches tall, and 3.3 inches in diameter. It has the same blue ring encircling the top and also has a volume dial around the top rim. It has two buttons on the top — an action button and a microphone off button. It has a hard plastic surface that comes in black, white, or silver. The first-generation Echo Plus isn’t the sexiest of devices, but it’s not the “hide it in the corner because it’s so horribly ugly” type of device either. It’s probably somewhere in the middle.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

The second-generation Echo Plus is a bit sexier. It’s shorter and wider than its predecessor, at less than 6-inches tall and around 4-inches wide — it looks more like a Sonos One speaker overall. You can’t really tell at first glance that it’s a smart home speaker, given the fabric surface on its exterior. However, it still has the same blue ring, and it has four buttons on top: volume up, volume down, action button, and mic off button. The Plus 2nd gen comes in heather grey, charcoal, or sandstone.

Features

Amazon Echo Plus
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Echo Plus has the same Alexa features as the other newer Echo devices.

The big standout difference between the Echo Plus and other Echo devices is the built-in Zigbee hub. This allows you to set up your smart home easily and efficiently, without having to purchase an extra hub for more control and functionality. Setting up compatible smart home devices is so simple, you just say “Alexa, discover my devices,” and the Echo Plus will automatically find and set up your tech with help from the Alexa app, where you can control settings and add skills.

If you use any stand-alone Echo device (non-Plus), you’ll be able to use Alexa skills to perform some basic functions on your compatible smart devices. You’ll even be able to set routines that can make your smart home products work somewhat in tandem.

But, Echo Plus lets you do more given the addition of the built-in Zigbee Hub — as long as you have compatible devices. Zigbee is a specific wireless standard used for smart home devices, separate from Wi-Fi networks: This open standard was an early option for smart devices that typically required the use of a central hub. It has since been largely replaced by Wi-Fi connections, but older or more unique devices can still support Zigbee. If you know you have a smart device that needs a Zigbee connection, it’s handy that both Plus devices support it, although it’s not as common these days.

Unlike the first-generation Echo Plus, the second-generation Plus has a temperature sensor. This allows for more advanced commands related to the temperature in your home. For instance, you could have the fan turn on when the temperature reaches 75 degrees, for instance.

Pricing and availability (and the Echo 4th gen)

Amazon Echo Dot (4th Gen) on table
John Velasco / Digital Trends

The second-generation Echo Plus retailed for $150, and the first-generation Echo Plus also retailed for $150 originally before the price dropped down to $100 after it was on the market for a while. Unfortunately, it’s now nearly impossible to find a Plus 1st-gen for sale these days with the rapid rate of new and improved Amazon models replacing them. Let’s break down your current choices:

Upgrade from an earlier Echo to a Plus 2nd-Gen refurbished model: You can save some money and hold on to that old Echo model a little longer if you’re willing to invest in an Echo Plus 2nd-gen upgrade. You can still find a refurbished version of the Plus 2 for $90, making it a viable upgrade, especially if you like the idea of an Echo with a temperature sensor. Otherwise, no Plus models are currently available. 

Buy the latest Echo 4th-gen instead: The Echo 4th-gen is Amazon’s broad combination of Echo and Echo Plus technology into a single, more affordable orb. We gave it an excellent review and consider it well worth its $100 price tag, especially since it’s far more advanced than previous models in the same price range. It’s a viable replacement option if you don’t want a refurbished plus model.

Editors' Recommendations

Erika Rawes
Smart Home Evergreen Coordinator
Erika became a professional writer in 2010, and her work is published all over the web on sites ranging from USA Today to…
Ring Battery Doorbell Pro vs. Ring Battery Doorbell Plus: Is the new Pro model worth it?
The Ring Battery Doorbell Plus installed outside a front door.

The Ring Battery Doorbell Pro is the newest member of the Ring family, offering high-end specs without the hassle of wires. However, it's not the only premium battery doorbell up for grabs, as Ring already offers the Battery Doorbell Plus, which is slightly more affordable than the new Pro model, yet comes with many of the same features.

While there are a lot of similarities between the two, there are a few key differences to be aware of before making a purchase. Here's a look at the Ring Battery Doorbell Pro and Ring Battery Doorbell Plus to help you decide which one is best for your home.
Design

Read more
Echo Show 8 vs. Nest Hub: Does Amazon or Google offer the best smart display?
Google Nest Hub 2nd Gen on table.

Anyone in the market for a reasonably priced smart display has probably stumbled across the Echo Show 8 and Nest Hub. Both clock in at under $150 (often less when on sale) yet provide homes with many of the same features found on premium alternatives like the Nest Hub Max and Echo Show 10.

But is the Echo Show 8 better than the Nest Hub? And what exactly is the difference between these two smart displays? Here's a comprehensive look at both to help you decide which one to bring into your smart home.
Pricing and design

Read more
Nest Hub Max vs. Echo Show 10: which is the better smart display?
The Nest Hub Max on a table.

The world of smart displays is dominated by two companies -- Amazon and Google. Amazon is responsible for the Echo Show 10, while Google is behind the Nest Hub Max. Both offer large screens, access to a massive roster of apps, and the ability to connect (and control) the rest of your smart home. There are a lot of similarities between the two popular displays, but there are a few key differences you should be aware of before adding one to your home.

Here's a closer look at the Echo Show 10 and Nest Hub Max to help you decide which is best.
Pricing and design

Read more