Skip to main content

Shades of Big Brother? Study finds smart TVs are keeping tabs on us

In the book 1984 by George Orwell, published almost exactly 70 years ago (and remarkably relevant, we recently noted), a totalitarian government watched its citizens through their television set. While that may seem like a wild, tinfoil hat-wearing kind of dystopia, it turns out that it wasn’t too far off. Our televisions, and other smart devices, may be watching us after all, if not to that extreme level.

TCL

In a study by Princeton University, researchers found that internet-connected TVs have data trackers that record a surprising amount of things using bots.

Recommended Videos

“We used this smart crawler to visit more than 2,000 channels on two popular OTT (over-the-top) platforms, namely Roku and Amazon Fire TV,” researchers stated in their report. “Our results show that tracking is pervasive on both OTT platforms, with traffic to known trackers present on 69 percent of Roku channels and 89 percent of Amazon Fire TV channels.” One of the most common trackers found was Google DoubleClick.

Researchers found that the type of data gathered included the user’s device type, device serial number, city, state, Wi-Fi network, and advertising ID. Once the data is collected, it seems to be shared all over the web. “We also observed that certain OTT channels contact more than 60 tracking domains and the data shared with the trackers include video titles, Wi-Fi SSIDs, MAC addresses, and device serial numbers,” they noted in the study.

Would turning off the targeted advertising option help? Not really. Turning it off just stops the advertising ID from being tracked. It seems, other than disconnecting it from the internet completely, there’s no way to stop all of the tracking and data collection when it comes to televisions.

While worrisome, this type of tracking isn’t uncommon. Netflix tracks physical activity data, Facebook gatherers your data, and even your security devices are spying on you. A study by Northeastern University found that just about any kind of smart device, from televisions to wireless video doorbells, smart speakers, and your digital assistants, are tracking you, collecting data, and sending it out over your internet connection.

“And since they’re in our homes and they can do things like detect motion, they know when we’re home, they listen to our voice commands, they record video, they’re potentially getting access to a lot of sensitive data about us,” said David Choffnes, an associate professor who led the study with others from Northeastern and Imperial College London, on the college’s blog.

Read the full Princeton University study: Watching You Watch: The Tracking Ecosystem of Over-the-Top TV Streaming Devices.

Alina Bradford
Alina Bradford has been a tech, lifestyle and science writer for more than 20 years. Her work is read by millions each month…
Earth Day with Reolink: Protecting nature, one camera at a time
earth day with reolink protecting nature one camera at a time hero crop

This Earth Day, Reolink is celebrating the incredible intersection of technology and conservation. With help from environmentally conscious users and dedicated NGO partners, Reolink is proving that small actions, powered by smart outdoor technology, can lead to a big impact for our planet's wildlife and natural landscapes.
Smarter, Greener Outdoor Monitoring
Reolink's lineup of outdoor cameras, including the Go PT Ultra, Go Ranger PT, and TrackMix LTE, do more than safeguard homes. They empower nature lovers to connect with the wild while treading lightly on the environment.

Each camera is engineered for sustainability and performance. Solar power compatibility keeps them running without contributing to battery waste. Their rugged, waterproof designs ensure they survive the toughest outdoor elements. And with stunning 4K 8MP ultra-clear footage, they capture the beauty of wildlife — from the shimmer of a bird's wings to the subtle prowling of a fox at dusk — without disturbing natural behavior.

Read more
Roku expands smart home lineup with two upcoming security cameras
The Roku Battery Camera on a tree

Roku might be known for its streaming sticks and smart TVs, but the brand also has a strong presence in the smart home market. From video doorbells and smart lights to plugs and motion sensors, Roku’s smart home catalog is surprisingly robust. The catalog is set to expand in the coming months, as Roku has officially revealed two upcoming security cameras -- the Roku Battery Camera and Roku Battery Camera Plus.

The Roku Battery Camera Plus is the most enticing of the two, as it can get up to two years of battery life on a single charge (the Battery Camera gets up to six months). They can also be combined with an optional solar panel to extend their battery life. Beyond that, most specs are shared -- including 1080p resolutions, color night vision, and the option to receive motion alerts when activity is detected around your home.

Read more
Aqara releases new Matter hub, security system, and climate sensor
The Aqara Matter Hub

Aqara has been busy as of late. The company announced Matter support for 50 new device types earlier this month, and now it’s launching three new products -- the Aqara M100 Hub, Climate Sensor W100, and Camera Protect Kit Y100. All three are now available for purchase.

If you’re interested in syncing all your smart devices together, the Aqara Smart Hub M100 is bound to be the most exciting of the bunch. The next-gen smart hub is designed for seamless Matter compatibility, allowing you to set up complex automations between Aqara products and Matter-enabled products from other platforms.

Read more