Skip to main content

Do Developers Prefer Apples or Androids?

android logo botIf you ask developers which is better, the iPhone or the Android, they’ll give you a strong, resounding “It depends.”

Writing applications for two different platforms poses significant challenges but developers say the differences between iPhone and Android can be summed up into three key areas: ease of development, speed of approval for apps and of course how much money you can make selling the apps.

Ease of Development

Coding language plays a big role in how easy it is for a developer to work on both iPhone and Android platforms says Anders Brownworth, who has developed Voice over Internet Protocol-related apps for companies such as bandwidth.com. “If you have a Java background, which most developers do, then Android is best for you. iPhone is coding Objective C – it’s an older language, but you can get up to speed. As a developer you have to remember stuff like in Java the system garbage collects for you while with iPhone you have to do it on your own,” he says.

The iPhone’s major development advantage is hardware uniformity. DoApp, a third-party developer of branded mobile apps on Android and iPhone for newspapers, has worked extensively on iPhone. Its senior excecutives agree with Brownworth’s assessment of the different coding languages, but say having one phone to deal with is a plus. “An advantage on the iPhone side is it’s one device. There are going to be 16 Android phones on the market, that makes for a very fragmented situation,” says Wade Beavers, CEO of DoApp.

Brownworth agrees. “If you’re going to put a couple of buttons on the screen you know it’s 360 pixels high for Android, some are 640 pixels, your interface may include multiple copies of the same button image. ”

Alex Moazed, CEO of Applico, which develops applications for the iPhone, Blackberry, Android and Windows Mobile, says this is a bigger deal than one might think. “I’ve done projects where customers need Android apps upgraded and it requires three different screen sizes etc. Your costs add up in terms of backwards compatibility.”

Developers add that if you’re a new developer you’ll need to absorb the cost of buying a Mac as well as a PC if you want to work on both platforms.

Speed of Approval

Once developed your app must be approved and that’s where Android phones tend to shine. ”I just finished nine months of working on an iPhone app,” Brownworth says. “It’ll be two weeks maybe middle of January because of the holidays to know if it’s approved,” he says.

Beavers says Apple’s convoluted approval process and the sheer app volume delay the process. “One of biggest challenges you hear is you get an app denied and no one tells you why,” he says. “The process Apple has for denial and acceptance is very arbitrary. Unpublished API suddenly becomes non available, I’m telling you if a developer gets a call from somebody at Apple, that number goes into a lockbox to be treasured.”

Android is a different story. “With Android everything is accepted by default but they reserve the right to pull. You may be pulled from the Apple store too, but you have to pass some sort of unknown bar to get in then you may be pulled,” Brownworth says.

“We can’t give our client a specific date for approval,” says Dave Borrillo, CTO of DoApp. “Plus if you have a bug you can’t do a quick fix because of time lag. We have 200 apps, if we do a global change all at the same time, we send in the change and some get in and some we have to wait,” he says.

Developers could write Web apps to bypass the iPhone approval process as Peter-Paul Koch says, but even he agreed it isn’t a cureall.

Getting the Sale

Getting your app sold depends on the platform. Ben Kazez, president of Mobiata, makers of FlightTrack – a travel app available in both the iPhone store and for the Android – says Android’s ability to run apps in the background is big for his Android customers. “Running apps in the background is huge for FlightTrack,” he says. “You can get flight updates without interrupting what you were doing. We’re going to be adding integration features like a calendar that we can’t do on iPhone.”

But the iPhone app store is a gamechanger as far as some developers are concerned. A recent article on Wireless Industry News says, “On average, about 82 percent of those surveyed indicated the design of the Android Marketplace makes it very difficult for mobile apps to be noticed, and about 57 percent of the Android developers are not satisfied with the revenues generated so far.

Moazed says iPhone’s increased sales volume can be a negative for a small developer.

“For underdog developers, [the] iPhone store is also very crowded. It’s hard to get your marketing message out there. You can sometimes spend more on marketing than on development with the iPhone store,” Moazed says.

The Future

Although Moazed praises RIM for recent advances to Blackberry like their partnership with Adobe, developers say that Apple and Google will continue to vie for the number one and two spots in the market. “In 2010 it’s going to be all about two titans and it’s going to be iPhone and Android. I don’t think Palm Pre and Microsoft are even going to be in the market,” Beavers says.

Given that, Brownworth says developers looking to write for both should start with iPhone. “If I were to target both platforms for the same app I would write for the iPhone first, get the UI nailed first because the UI tools are prettier. Once you have an interface singing in iPhone it’s easier to go to Android.”

John Greaves is a writer living in Dallas, Ga. His work has appeared in newspapers, magazines and websites.

Check out Digital Trends Best iPhone Apps

Check out Digital Trends Best Android Apps

Editors' Recommendations

Ian Bell
I work with the best people in the world and get paid to play with gadgets. What's not to like?
Android is getting an AI overhaul. Here’s what it looks like
Android 15 on stage at Google I/O 2024.

At Google I/O 2024, Google has shown off a lot of new improvements coming to Android, thanks to Gemini. With Gemini, Android will be aware of the context on the screen in a variety of scenarios, which will make your life a lot easier. At least, according to Google.

Circle to Search, which was first shown off during Samsung’s Galaxy Unpacked event earlier this year, will be getting some new enhancements. Now, Circle to Search will be a great new study buddy for students. Why? Because it will be able to help with homework, like physics and math. You can simply circle a prompt on the screen, and it will give you step-by-step instructions on how to solve it.

Read more
Best Apple Watch 8 deals: Save on last year’s model
Close-up of a person taking a call on their Apple Watch Series 8.

One of the best smartwatches can add a lot to both your fitness routine and your day-to-day style, and the Apple Watch lineup is one people turn to frequently. The Apple Watch Series 9 is the current most recent release, but the Apple Watch Series 8 is still plenty capable, and it makes for great smartwatch deals because it’s a generation old at this point. Apple deals don't come around often, so shopping older generations is a great way to save. There are some Apple Watch 8 deals currently taking place, and we’ve tallied them below for your saving convenience. So whether you’re starting a new fitness routine or cleaning up your wardrobe, don’t hesitate to shop the best Apple Watch deals while they last.
Apple Watch Series 8 (GPS + Cellular, 45mm) (refurbished) — $255, was $273

This is the Apple Watch Series 8 45mm size, which is the largest you’ll find in an Apple Watch 8. It also has built-in GPS and the ability to connect to your cellular plan for connectivity anywhere you get a signal. This is a refurbished model of the Apple Watch 8. Shopping refurbished is a great way to land some savings, and you can do so knowing this watch is backed by Amazon’s renewal standards. It will still have all of the great features people love about the Apple Watch Series 8, including advanced health features and access to Apple’s software ecosystem.

Read more
Google is making it easier for you to find and download Android apps
Google Play on the Oppo Find N2.

Google announced a wide range of features for Android phones at the I/O 2024 developers conference earlier today. However, the event was not all about user-facing changes. The company also revealed a handful of new tricks for developers to showcase their apps effectively while maintaining a vigilant eye on safety.

Among the most important changes -- one that is also going to make life easier for users - is support for more payment options. The most notable of these is support for installment subscriptions, which has already yielded positive results for developers in the early access phase.

Read more