Skip to main content

Here’s why Telegram will probably never beat WhatsApp

Like other Facebook services, WhatsApp has been under a lot of scrutiny this year. The service botched the rollout of a new privacy policy, and competitors pounced, offering new ways for WhatsApp users to switch their messages over. It worked! These apps, mostly Signal and Telegram, recorded user growth during that tumultuous period. This week, an extended WhatsApp (and Facebook in general) outage took WhatsApp out for hours on end, with rival platform Telegram gaining 70 million users.

“The daily growth rate of Telegram exceeded the norm by an order of magnitude, and we welcomed over 70 million refugees from other platforms in one day. I am proud of how our team handled the unprecedented growth because Telegram continued to work flawlessly for the vast majority of our users,” CEO Pavel Durov said.

Durov went on to plead that the new members stick around and see what Telegram has to offer. That might be a more telling statement than intended.

The difference in scale is almost too large

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Telegram may have logged an additional 70 million users and recorded 500 million active users, but WhatsApp has a recorded 2 billion million active users and is the most used mobile messaging service on a global scale. How many of those are an overlap with WhatsApp? A considerable number, if I had to speculate based on my experience. It points to the fact that while people might be jumping over to Telegram, it isn’t their primary messaging app either.

“WhatsApp has a recorded 2 billion million active users and is the most used mobile messaging service on a global scale.”

While Telegram and Signal may have these small spikes ever so often, the users don’t stick around long term for it to matter, nor do their growth spikes remain consistent. While a person may have Telegram and open it once a week, most people in countries with high WhatsApp usage use it pretty consistently.

It goes beyond the network effect

WhatsApp chat transfer with Lightning to USB-C cable.

Even if one were willing to bear the pain of switching away from your friends and using Telegram for trusted friends, you’d still need WhatsApp in select cases. For a lot of countries, WhatsApp is more than a messaging platform. You can make payments on WhatsApp, you can shop in there, your plumber is in there, the government, even the mail company, etc. During the pandemic, it was not Telegram that governments turned to spread messages to their citizens, but WhatsApp (and Facebook Messenger) to some degree.

“For a lot of countries, WhatsApp is more than a messaging platform.”

During the Facebook outage, the economic effect of WhatsApp was keenly felt in India, as Slate reported. “People panicked throughout India,” said Anil Tiwari, an internet expert based out of Lucknow. Even figuring out what was going on was difficult; he pointed out that “only 2.7% [of the] population of India are on Twitter.” People in small towns were able to turn to SMS messages instead, reducing the harm to small businesses, “but in metro cities where businesses majorly run on apps, it created an impact.”

An excellent Gizmodo report further explained that WhatsApp was far more entrenched into the economic systems of several countries on more than a commercial level, with bundles and telecoms plans all built around WhatsApp’s continued existence.

Telegram is a lot like WhatsApp

Telegram App.
Michael Archambault/Digital Trends

It’s quite easy to switch out Telegram for WhatsApp when both apps are quite similar in concept and execution. You could even think of Telegram as a WhatsApp+, with nifty customization features that WhatsApp doesn’t have and a more built-out set of group features. It’s an app that works for a lot of what you’d need a messaging app for, but it doesn’t do much that most people can’t accomplish in WhatsApp.

To get people to switch en masse, you’d need to be able to answer the “Why would I switch over to Telegram” in a concrete, tangible way that justifies the pain of swimming against the network effect. It’s a lot like the iMessage problem writ large.

Still, WhatsApp won’t be here forever

WhatsApp and Telegram app icons.
Rafael Henrique/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images

There was once a time where people could message each other without necessarily using the client apps. Hell, Microsoft and BlackBerry both built experiences around Facebook Messenger. That time is long gone. And so is any chance of shaking WhatsApp from its position, at least in the near term.

If WhatsApp is to be usurped (barring egregious strategic blunders), this won’t come from another app that’s just like it. Instead, it’ll be a lot more like how WhatsApp took over from Blackberry Messenger and SMS, an app that offers the core of WhatsApp’s appeal while bringing something completely different to the table. I can’t say what an app like that would look like, but it’ll be apparent when it arrives.

Editors' Recommendations

Michael Allison
A UK-based tech journalist for Digital Trends, helping keep track and make sense of the fast-paced world of tech with a…
Why we think the Tesla Phone is probably never going to happen
An iPhone 14 Pro with a Tesla logo Photoshopped on the back of it.

After purchasing Twitter and appointing himself CEO, Elon Musk made some (what can generously be called) controversial changes to the site and its rules. He's aiming to make Twitter a place where his ideas of free speech can be allowed, which has ultimately resulted in providing “amnesty” to previously banned accounts from white supremacists, conspiracy theorists, and other people who were in violation of Twitter’s old terms of service.

Musk claimed in a tweet that Apple has “threatened to withhold Twitter from its App Store” but didn’t tell him why. The Twitter CEO also claimed that Apple has “mostly stopped advertising” on the social media site, but also can’t seem to figure out why. Apparently, the world’s richest man is unable to understand why a company like Apple would want to take some cautionary steps away from the gasoline he’s pouring on Twitter.

Read more
You’ll soon be able to use WhatsApp on more than one phone
Two phones on a table next to each other. One is showing the WhatsApp logo, and the other is running the WhatsApp application.

WhatsApp, one of the most used messaging services in Europe and parts of Asia, is about to close a major flaw. As spotted by the sleuths over on WABetainfo, the company is planning an update that will allow the use of a secondary device -- including another phone or tablet. Currently, WhatsApp only allows phone users to link their account via its web or desktop clients.

The new feature is dubbed companion mode. Once it rolls out, you'll have a workflow that's quite similar to setting up WhatsApp Web or WhatsApp on the desktop. Rather than entering a number, you'll be able to scan a QR code with your main phone to log in to your existing WhatsApp account.

Read more
WhatsApp is copying two of Zoom’s best video-calling features
Call Links by WhatsApp

WhatsApp is taking a couple of pages out of Zoom's playbook. The Meta-owned company is rolling out the Call Links feature, making it easier for people to join audio and video calls with just one tap on the phone screen.

Mark Zuckerberg announced the new feature in a Facebook post on Monday morning. Starting this week, WhatsApp users will be able to tap the Call Links option within the Calls tab and create a link for audio or video calls to send to their friends and family, who will then tap on the link and join the call from there.

Read more