Skip to main content

This bootleg Chinese comic based on Star Wars is fascinating and so very, very strange

bootleg chinese comic based star wars fascinating strange
Image used with permission by copyright holder

If you don’t remember the scene in Star Wars when Darth Vader paced back and forth in front of a galactic map depicting the location of the Kennedy Space Center, you’re not alone. However, if your only connection to George Lucas’ 1977 sci-fi epic was through one of the many bootleg comics published in China that disseminated western pop culture throughout the more remote regions of the country, that scene was a very important — if not entirely logical — element in the story of the Jedi Knights’ battle against the Empire.

Maggie Greene, a Chinese historian and assistant professor at Montana State University, recently posted some images from a comic published around 1980 that she picked up at a Shanghai book fair. Created in the style of palm-sized books that were used to spread propaganda and pass along tales from Chinese history, the lianhuanhua comics occasionally served as a pre-internet means of delivering popular media from other cultures — in this particular case, Star Wars.

“I suppose one of the defining features of modern Chinese cultural production (or perceptions of it, at least) is rather rampant IP violations,” wrote Greene on her website. “But at the same time people are amazed by the speed with which Chinese pirates hop on all sorts of (re)production, I think we often forget how quickly culture circulated before the internet.”

The comic — titled Xing Qiu Da Zhan (Chinese for “Star Wars”) — follows the basic narrative of the film relatively well, but offers up some amusing divergences from the source material, including the appearance of the Kennedy Space Center on Vader’s galactic map, as well as a shifting visual depiction of Han Solo’s partner, Chewbacca. The hairy Wookie is alternately seen as something akin to his appearance in the film or as a large, Planet of the Apes-style simian creature.

As Greene points out, there are also some interesting depictions of what the artist must have assumed to be common American practices and settings, including a panel featuring Luke Skywalker and his aunt and uncle sitting down to dinner in a trendy kitchen around a slow-cooker pot while someone cooks a duck in a toaster oven

“It seems pretty obvious from the drawings that the artists weren’t always working from an actual film, or really much at all,” adds Greene.

You can look through the entire comic at Greene’s website, where she also offers up a bit more historical context for lianhuanhua and their role in Chinese culture during the 20th Century. A nice, sequential scan of the pages in a more manageable resolution can also be found here

Rick Marshall
A veteran journalist with more than two decades of experience covering local and national news, arts and entertainment, and…
Star Wars: The Phantom Menace is better and worse than you remember
Qui-Gon and Obi-Wan duel Darth Maul in Star Wars: Episode I - The Phantom Menace.

This month marks the 25th anniversary of Star Wars: Episode I — The Phantom Menace. The film, the opening installment in George Lucas' Prequel Trilogy, was the first Star Wars movie in 16 years when it was released. Shortly after it hit theaters in May 1999, though, it became the target of a lot of vitriol and criticism. Star Wars fans went into it expecting a prequel that felt of a piece with the franchise's Original Trilogy. Instead, what they got was a CGI-heavy, polished, and unexpectedly stiff epic about, among other things, child slavery, trade laws, and senatorial politics. In a lot of ways, the film couldn't have been more different from 1977's swashbuckling, fairy tale-like Star Wars: Episode IV — A New Hope.

Over the past few years, a lot of Star Wars fans have adopted a much kinder tone when discussing The Phantom Menace and its fellow prequels. That's been due, in no small part, to the lackluster quality of Disney's Sequel Trilogy. For many of the viewers who were introduced at a young age to Star Wars through the prequels, the films also hold a special, nostalgic place in their hearts. With that in mind and, in honor of its forthcoming anniversary, it's worth asking: Is The Phantom Menace really as bad as so many fans remember? Or is it as good as some of its younger supporters believe?

Read more
The best Star Wars shows on Disney+
Morgan Elsbeth in Star Wars: Tales of the Empire.

When Disney+ launched in 2019, it was understood that the biggest attractions were the Star Wars and Marvel original series. Nearly five years later, the rollout of shows from those franchises has slowed down to a virtual crawl. However, heading into this year's Star Wars Day, there are actually two new shows on the horizon. But we can't guarantee anything else Star Wars-related will arrive on Disney+ in 2024.

On May 4, Disney+ is premiering the animated anthology series, Star Wars: Tales of the Empire, which follows up on some story threads from Star Wars: The Clone Wars and Ahsoka. Star Wars: The Acolyte will follow on June 4, but we don't have too many details about that series yet. Star Wars: Skeleton Crew was originally slated to arrive in 2024 as well, but since there's been no sign of that series to date, it may slip into 2025.

Read more
5 things we need to see in The Mandalorian & Grogu Star Wars movie
The Mandalorian and Grogu in a poster for the Disney+ series.

It's not hard to see why Lucasfilm gave the green light to the upcoming Mandalorian & Grogu movie. No new characters from the new Disney era are as widely beloved as they are. In a time when so many Star Wars films have been announced and subsequently abandoned, a movie based on The Mandalorian feels like a surefire hit.

And yet, everything else about this film remains a mystery. What's the story? When does it even take place? None of that is known. But I think we can agree that the following five things need to be addressed in the upcoming film.
1. The right epic feel and scope

Read more