This Leica changed my mind on instant cameras. Here’s why

Leica Sofort
Instant film cameras are the vestigial organs of the photography world, and yet they have inexplicably soared in popularity over the past few years. They are impractical, wasteful, take low quality photos, and can end up costing a lot of money if you actually use the things, as there’s a price attached to every exposure.

As a photo technology writer, none of this appeals to me — or at least, it didn’t. But after using a Leica Sofort while vacationing with family, I’ve had a change of heart. Instant film photography can be something truly special, but it’s not about the photography so much as the experience. Whether or not that justifies the Sofort’s premium price is up to you — and I have lingering concerns about the disposable nature of instant film — but I will say this: I am officially no longer a cynic, and after reading this, hopefully neither will you be.

Style you can buy

The Sofort (German for “instant”) is classy piece of hardware that looks both fresh and antiquated at the same time. It exhibits a definite ’80s vibe and will feel immediately familiar to anyone who ever carried around a Walkman, right down to the click-clack of putting in a new film cartridge, a process that’s eerily reminiscent of loading a cassette tape.

Leica hasn’t brought any new features to the table — the Sofort is a just rehoused Fujifilm Instax Mini 90, and uses the same Instax Mini film — but it has sprinkled a dash of conservative German styling into the mix which I quite like. I felt much better about wearing the Sofort around my neck than the other, rather childish-looking Instax cameras available (actually, the Mini 90 doesn’t look too bad).

The Sofort is classy piece of hardware that looks both fresh and antiquated at the same time.

Like other Leicas, the Sofort stands out by not standing out, especially the new — and more expensive — black model. The white finish of my review unit was also quite handsome, although if you prefer a casual Friday look, Leica also offers mint (looks like chewing gum) and orange (looks like a Chiclet; so, also chewing gum).

Of course, you’ll pay for that extra style. With a price of $279 (or $300 for the black version), the Sofort has a big head start in the race to drain your bank account, easily lapping the $120 Mini 90. And with instant photography, the costs don’t stop with the purchase of the camera. Depending on how and where you buy Instax film, you may pay as much as 90 cents per shot, although buying in bulk can cut the price significantly. I paid $43 for three boxes of film, 60 exposures in total, for a cost of about 72 cents per exposure. That’s still not great — especially considering you incur that cost regardless of whether the picture is a masterpiece or a misfire. New cameras do come with a box of film, so that’s at least something.

Unlike an actual Leica, the Sofort is a fully automatic machine and very much a point-and-shoot. It does, however, give you some creative control: You can force the flash on or off, use the macro mode for close-ups, and frame yourself using the built-in mirror for perfect selfies or set the camera on a tripod and use the timer for group photos. It even has a bulb mode for doing long exposures; just hold the shutter button down as long as you wish to get blurry, abstract streaks of color.

For every 10 photos, I end up with a small pile of trash — or a larger pile if I don’t like any of my photos.

There are also some problematic design choices. The parallax viewfinder sits a good distance away from the lens; for close-ups, this means the actual photo will look much different from what you saw through the viewfinder. It can be easier to simply look at the lens to make sure it’s pointed at your subject, rather than relying on the viewfinder. Also, the tripod socket is positioned at the extreme edge of the bottom of the camera for reasons that remain mysterious. It’s probably not a huge issue given that precision tripod maneuvers are not what this camera is designed for, but it does look a bit weird.

Leica Sofort
Daven Mathies/Digital Trends

Trash to treasure

Beyond the expense, what really got to me was the amount of waste generated by the film. Each 20-exposure box is split into two individually sealed 10-exposure film cartridges. Once exhausted, you end up with a wrapper, cartridge, and dark slide (the protective panel that automatically ejects itself when the film is loaded) under your authority, which is both a major annoyance and a minor environmental catastrophe.

Sure, the film cartridges are recyclable, and some DIY-minded folk have even turned them into picture frames, but I still have trouble wrapping my head around the idea that for every 10 photos I take, I end up with a small pile of trash — or a larger pile if I don’t like any of my photos.

Leica Sofort
On the other hand, I admit I have no idea how much waste is produced by the manufacture of digital imaging sensors and associated electronic components. Maybe it’s far, far worse — maybe you’d have to shoot 10,000 Instax photos to equal the carbon footprint of a single digital camera (which nobody is going to do because that would cost $7,200). I do not know how many pictures it would actually take to cross that threshold (maybe it’s only 10), but that not knowing is what makes it so easy to accept digital photography while rejecting single-use plastics I can see with my own eyes.

Instant film leads to some beautiful accidents.

But none of that mattered the moment I was able to look through someone else’s eyes. I have a 2-year-old niece and nephew, twins, who were born into a world where print photography is merely the exception to the norm. I’m sure they can navigate an iPad better than I can, but they had never seen an actual, physical photo of themselves. I took a picture of each of them — not very good ones, mind you — and I honestly do not have the words to describe the looks on their faces when I handed them over. I’ll just say, the $43 was worth it; the mini Pacific garbage patch was worth it.

Then I reached for my digital camera to capture that moment.

And I guess that’s the thing; instant film leads to some beautiful accidents, but for pictures I know I care about, I only trust a digital camera. And I’m fine with that — instant photography certainly isn’t out to replace digital, but I now see it has a valuable place alongside it, creating memories and experiences that may not matter to your Instagram followers, but matter deeply to you.

I don’t know that the Leica Sofort was any more effective in facilitating that experience than the cheaper Fujifilm Instax Mini 90 would have been — but I do know I looked better during it, and that has to count for something.

Movies & TV

Why First Man’s Oscar-nominated visual effects are a giant leap for filmmaking

Paul Lambert, the award-winning visual effects supervisor on First Man, reveals the innovative techniques that blended old footage with modern movie magic to make the Apollo 11 mission to the moon resonate with audiences 50 years later and…
Product Review

With the RX100 VI, Sony proves it still makes the best point-and-shoot camera

The sixth generation of Sony's powerful but compact RX100 camera delivers more zoom, incredible speed, robust 4K video, and still fits in the palm of your hand.
Product Review

Samsung's Galaxy S10 phones are its most refined yet. Be prepared to pay up

Samsung has unveiled its lineup for its most popular smartphones, and it includes the Galaxy S10 and S10 Plus. The two flagship phones boast hole-punch cameras, fingerprint sensors embedded in the display, and beefier batteries.

Photography news: Wacom’s slimmer pen, Leica’s cinema special edition

In this week's photography news, Wacom launches a new slimmer pen for pro users. Leica's upcoming M10-P is designed for cinema, inside and out, with built-in cinema modes in the updated software.
Emerging Tech

Awesome Tech You Can’t Buy Yet: Grow veggies indoors and shower more efficiently

Check out our roundup of the best new crowdfunding projects and product announcements that hit the web this week. You may not be able to buy this stuff yet, but it sure is fun to gawk!

Be careful who you bokeh, jokes Apple’s latest iPhone ad

With iPhone sales under pressure, you'd think there wouldn't be much to laugh about at Apple HQ. But the company has seen fit to inject some humor into its latest handset ad, which highlights the camera's Depth Control feature.

Mirrorless cameras were built to be compact, so why have they gotten so heavy?

Mirrorless cameras launched as portable alternatives to bulky and complex DSLRs -- so why are they getting bigger and heavier? Cameras are trending towards heavier models, but that change comes with more advanced features.

What’s the difference between Lightroom CC and Lightroom Classic?

Lightroom CC has evolved into a capable photo editor, but is it enough to supplant Lightroom Classic? We took each program for a test drive to compare the two versions and see which is faster, more powerful, and better organized.

Luminar’s libraries gain speed, drop need for you to manually import images

Luminar 3 just got a performance boost. Skylum Luminar 3.0.2 has improved speed over December's update, which added the long-promised libraries feature giving editors a Lightroom alternative.

When you're ready to shoot seriously, these are the best DSLRs you can buy

For many photographers the DSLR is the go-to camera. With large selection of lenses, great low-light performance, and battery endurance, these DSLRs deliver terrific image quality for stills and videos.

The best place to print photos online in 2019

Have you been looking around for the best place to print out your favorite photos online or in store? Don't fret, we've pored through dozens of options and narrowed it down to the seven best.

The Panasonic FZ1000 gets a much-needed update alongside the smaller ZS80 zoom

Panasonic's 2014 superzoom camera with a larger sensor has finally seen an update. The new Panasonic FZ1000 II has a sensor that's better for low light, more physical controls, and new 4K Photo Mode features.

Watch the construction of a 270-degree fisheye lens, the widest ever

Think you've seen wide fisheye lenses? Think again. A team from Lensrentals recently shared a behind-the-scenes look at a custom prototype 4.5mm fisheye lens, which captures a whopping 270-degree view.

NASA celebrates Earth’s incredible natural beauty with free photo book

NASA has published a fabulous new book featuring stunning imagery captured by its satellites over the years. A hardback version is available for $53, though it can also be downloaded to ebook readers for free, and enjoyed online.