State of the Web: We gotta fight! For our right! … to Instagram our ballots

state of the web ballots election voting 2012

Did you know that you could be arrested, fined, kicked out of your polling place, or have your vote tossed in the trash for sharing a photo of your marked ballot on the Web?

This is the reality for most states in the U.S. Florida, Georgia, Kentucky, Nevada, North Carolina, Texas, and West Virginia all have laws on the books that explicitly forbid photography or video recording in polling places. Some states forbid the use of cellphones – which more often than not double as cameras. A majority of states have laws against the “public display” of a marked ballot – which means that Instagram photo you just posted to the Web may have broken state law. And other states just don’t make the rules clear, meaning you’d have to ask an already over-worked polling place volunteer first before snapping a pic or shooting video – and they might not know the answer.

Despite this, citizens are flooding the Web with photos of their ballots. A quick search for the #vote hashtag on Instagram at the time of this writing brings up nearly 600,000 photos, many of which likely violated the law – though many probably didn’t know they were doing so. On top of that, YouTube is pushing voters to record their voting experience, another potential no-no in the eyes of state laws.

In short, we might have a legal mess on our hands. So, how did we get in this muck? And, more importantly, can we get out?

To get a better sense of the issues at hand, I reached out to Andy Sellars, a First Amendment Fellow at Harvard University’s Berkman Center for Internet & Society and a staff attorney for its Digital Media Law Project, which has become the preeminent authority on laws governing the photographing and recording of ballots.

Protecting the vote

First, it’s important to remember that these laws are in place to protect citizens’ right to vote and the integrity of the voting process at large.

“The reason to have laws like this largely go to issues of voter intimidation and voter fraud,” says Sellars. “The concerns with voter intimidation would be you showing your ballot around the polling place, trying to use your vote as a way of influencing other voters how to vote, which obviously we [Americans] are pretty repugnant toward.”

In terms of voter fraud, Sellars says these laws are often in place to prevent vote-purchasing schemes, which could become more prevalent if voters are able to take a photo of their completed ballot as proof that they voted a particular way. “By preventing the disclosure of ballots, you’re preventing that from being able to happen,” says Sellars. “It reinforces the privacy of the vote … It also helps make sure that people aren’t interrupting other voters, or interfering with other voters, while in the polling place.”

Despite the protection anti-ballot-disclosure laws provide, Sellars notes that much of this legislation was concocted in an age before smartphones and social media.

“It’s important to keep in mind that these laws were probably written before we all walked around with cameras in our pockets,” says Sellars. “So the laws contemplate sort of a traditional era of voting, where you’d mark your ballot, you’d deposit your ballot, then you’d walk out, and there would be no physical record of that ballot traveling [outside the polling place].”

A dangerous culture of disclosure

Another argument for the presence of laws against ballot disclosure is that, by allowing everyone to photograph and share their ballots, it could create a so-called culture of disclosure, wherein people who do not wish to share their ballot with anyone feel pressure to do so. Sellars, however, doesn’t see this becoming too widespread a problem.

“There haven’t been that many elections where we have social media like we have today, so this election could be setting a new standard here,” says Sellars. “But, in general, we haven’t seen all that many people doing this. We see it happen for sure. And Instagram, I’m sure, will have many examples of this today. But I think that this idea of privacy around your vote isn’t escaping the next generation of youth that are voting for the first time today.”

“For the same reasons that you might be careful about photos you post on Facebook from a party this weekend, you might be careful about posting [your ballot],” Sellars adds. “It could jump back to bite you later.”

Ballot photo

Shackled free speech

Of course, it is difficult not to notice the irony in laws that are meant to protect the most sacred form of free speech – your vote – which in turn prevent people from engaging in speech. Sellars says that “these sorts of disclosure laws face some serious Constitutional issues under the First Amendment,” but that the issues are most pertinent “in circumstances where [states are] prohibiting the disclosure of a ballot after the election has concluded.”

Furthermore, these laws do not prevent all forms of disclosure. As Jeff Hermes, director of the Digital Media Law Project, writes in a blog post on the First Amendment issues, “ballot disclosure laws are not complete bars to disclosure of a voter’s choice; voters are free to discuss their votes, albeit without proof in photographic form.”

Limited usefulness

Hermes goes on to argue that taking a picture of your marked ballot, or recording video at a polling location, only adds further protection against voter fraud and errors which seem to have become increasingly commonplace given the prevalence of e-voting machines.

“Voting is the fundamental method by which American citizens exercise their rights of self-governance, and it is essential to combat corruption of the process,” writes Hermes. “However, the extraordinary importance of voting also requires that we be free as citizens to discuss our experiences at the polls, including the people for whom we voted if we so wish. Otherwise, we begin to lose the protection against corruption and error that the First Amendment itself provides.”

The ability to record in your ballot has already proven its usefulness in this election, with a Reddit user capturing an e-voting machine switching his vote from Obama to Romney.

Sellars says that recording the conditions around your polling location may provide “very helpful evidence” as to whether the election is being conducted legally (as the video above proves); however, he says it’s not entirely clear that photographing your ballot is a particularly useful way to make elections more transparent.

“You’d have to have so many people disclosing their ballots in order to show a bad count in their precinct,” says Sellars. “You could come up with a circumstance where, you know, a precinct says, ‘We had 100 percent of respondents say this.’ And then you say, ‘No, here’s me voting the other way.’ But statistically, that’s very unlikely.”

Times a-changin’ – but not yet

In other words, there is a great debate to be had over whether or not disclosure laws are a positive or negative force on our democracy. Still, some states, like Maine, have already begun to update their disclosure laws. And Sellars says others may follow suit. Until then, however, your best bet is to “contact your precinct first,” says Sellars, before you snap an Instagram pic of your ballot. This is especially important due to the fact that many of these laws are so vague.

“Just because a state law doesn’t expressly prohibit [photographing and sharing your ballot], doesn’t necessarily mean it’s OK,” says Sellars. “Virtually every state empowers the secretary of state or the attorney general of the state, as well as local election officials, to take action to prevent activity which would disrupt a polling place”

So snap cautiously, people. Who knows what could happen if you don’t.

Giveaways

Print your heart’s desire: Enter our giveaway to win a free Monoprice 3D printer

We’re giving away a $400 Monoprice MP Voxel 3D Printer. It's easy to use, especially for beginners, with its simple menu system and touchscreen display. It comes fully assembled so you can spend more time printing instead of setting up.
Gaming

These are the best video games you shouldn't leave 2018 without

Developers showed up with a number of amazing games this year. Each capitalized on something unique but there's always one that outdoes them all. Here are our picks for the best video games of 2018 and game of the year.
Computing

Supermicro investigation: no spy chips found on our motherboards

Supermicro announced the results of an investigation into the controversy surrounding its motherboards. The investigation was launched in response to reports that alleged the motherboards were compromised with malicious hardware.
Home Theater

Looking for the best 4K Ultra HD TVs you can buy? Here are five great options

If it's time to upgrade your old 1080p to a new 4K model but you don't know what to look for, fear not, as we're here with a list of the best 4K Ultra HD TVs to help make your buying process as easy as possible.
Social Media

You can now share saved Facebook posts with a Pinterest-like collection tool

Facebook collections can now be shared with friends if you also want to allow them to contribute to the list. Facebook is rolling out an update that allows users to add a contributor to their collections, or lists of saved Facebook posts.
Mobile

Broadway actor tells Kanye West to get off his phone during opening night

Theater actors can get understandably upset when they spot someone in the audience fiddling with their phone instead of watching the show. The other night that audience member was Kanye West, and he got called out for it.
Social Media

This event topped Facebook’s biggest moments of the year — again

As the year comes to a close, Facebook is looking back on what users discussed most over the last year. For two years in a row, International Women's Day topped the list. So what else is on the list?
Social Media

This band owns Twitter, according to list of top accounts and tweets for 2018

What was the biggest buzz on Twitter in 2018? Twitter's 2018 Year in Review highlights the biggest tweets, accounts, and hashtags. The most-tweeted celebrities, movies, TV shows, athletes, politicians and more in Twitter's 2018 trends.
Social Media

What do yodeling and Kylie Jenner have in common? YouTube’s top 2018 videos

In a true nod to the variety found on YouTube, the platform's top 10 list of videos from 2018 range from celebrities to sports, from perfectly tossing a picture frame on the wall to a kid yodeling in aisle 12 at Walmart.
Home Theater

It took Tom Cruise to raise awareness of this troublesome TV setting

Tom Cruise, in an unexpected PSA tweet, asks you to turn off motion interpolation on your TV, but stops short of how to do it. Here's more on the topic, along with links to a guide on how to rid your TV of the dreaded "soap opera effect."
Computing

Make a GIF of your favorite YouTube video with these great tools

Making a GIF from a YouTube video is easier today than ever, but choosing the right tool for the job isn't always so simple. In this guide, we'll teach you how to make a GIF from a YouTube video with our two favorite online tools.
Business

Amazon scouted airport locations for its cashier-free Amazon Go stores

Representatives of Amazon Go checkout-free retail stores connected with officials at Los Angeles and San Jose airports in June to discuss the possibility of cashier-free grab-and-go locations in busy terminals.
Social Media

Snapchat facial recognition could soon power a new portrait mode, code suggests

Digging into Snapchat's code suggests a handful of upcoming camera features, including a portrait mode. The feature appears to use facial recognition A.I. to blur the background. The code also suggests an updated camera interface.
Computing

Google+ continues to sink with a second massive data breach. Abandon ship now

Google+ was scheduled to shut its doors in August 2019, but the second security breach in only a few months has caused the company to move its plan forward a few months. It might be a good idea to delete your account sooner than later.