Skip to main content

The best Dreams creations are still subject to copyright law

Media Molecule’s Dreams is a revolutionary game for PlayStation 4 that turns nearly anyone into a game designer, courtesy of robust creation tools that only require a standard controller. The game’s community has used these tools to make original games across genres ranging from adventures to role-playing to first-person shooters. Unfortunately, alongside the wholly unique user-created games is a mountain of homages and copycats.

These range from silly Sonic-style platforms that instead feature Yoshi to complete remakes of existing game demos for P.T. and Ghost of Tsushima. Impressive as they are, they’re subject to the same copyright and trademark laws as other media. Fans shouldn’t get too attached to their favorites.

PS4 Dreams - PT Remake Comparison (P.t vs dreams P.t)

Metal Gear and Super Mario are among the most popular subjects in Dreams thus far. When approached for comment on their respective IPs’ presence in Dreams, Konami and Nintendo declined. However, Ryan Morrison, a founding partner of legal firm Morrison Rothman, says the companies would find it very easy to have the content removed. 

“They wouldn’t even have to bring a lawsuit,” Morrison told Digital Trends. “Usually, they can just file a DMCA [Digital Millennium Copyright Act] takedown, and if that takedown is not complied with, they can then sue both Dreams and the person who uploaded it.”

Nintendo has already started this process. The company sent DMCA takedowns to Media Molecule parent Sony in March to get its franchise’s characters removed from the game. Mario and Yoshi were featured in popular Dreams levels, but Sony complied, and is removing infringing content when it is brought to its attention.

The DMCA was created to protect copyright holders when content infringing on their rights was hosted online. When a DMCA takedown request is filed, the  material in question is removed. It’s typically up to the creator to challenge the takedown and prove their content was not in violation.

No money? Still problems

Dreams PS4 Gameplay - Ghost of Tsushima made in Dreams

Games made in Dreams can’t be monetized, which means their creators aren’t profiting off them. However, they can still commit copyright infringement, as the games don’t fall under the nebulous umbrella of “fair use,” according to Morrison.

In most jurisdictions, fair use is just one of four factors in determining whether content violates copyright law, according to Morrison. Violations are determined in court, meaning users who create Dreams content must go through the legal process to defend against claims, which would be far too expensive.

“Fair use is not a right, it is a defense,” Morrison added. “It’s saying, ‘Yes, I infringed. However, it was OK [that] I infringed because of fair use.'”

Fair use is not a right, it is a defense.

Curiously, it’s Sony itself that could potentially run into legal issues if it were to manually remove any games infringing on its own works, such as the fan-made Ghost of Tsushima demo. DMCA takedowns are available in large part for companies incapable of policing all content manually.

If Sony were to only remove Dreams games that violated its own IP, it could be seen as selective removal, and could be argued the company should then be responsible for policing everything. Media Molecule’s current policy is to remove content when a copyright holder requests it be removed. Should it not do this, it risks incurring a lawsuit, but the very black-and-white nature of this sort of copyright infringement makes immediate removal the obvious choice.

Sony did not respond to Digital Trends’ request for comment on how it plans to deal with potential copyright violations for its own franchises.

A designer’s perspective

I Expect You to Die | Shell Games
Schell Games

Major game publishers could take issue with their characters or worlds appearing in Dreams, but the designers Digital Trends spoke to have a different attitude. Schell Games’ I Expect You to Die is an extremely popular virtual reality game, and CEO Jesse Schell isn’t worried about imitators affecting support for the real version. In fact, it reminds him of how game designers like him first started, programming Dungeons & Dragons campaigns for Atari computers back in the 1980s.

Game designers Digital Trends spoke to have a much different attitude.

“When we look back 10 years from now, there will be a lot of people who built their chops in Dreams,” Schell said.

For newer independent developers, there could be homages that raise awareness of the original, similar to the way “Let’s Play” videos popularize indie games on YouTube. These are generally ignored by game publishers because, despite violating copyright, they do more good for their games than harm.

This is what Kyle Erf, director of technology at Moving Pieces, believes could work for his retro-style platformer Dodo Peak. He even considered making his own “fan” version in Dreams as a promotional tool.

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Young game designers have copied major publishers’ games for decades. However, they didn’t have an outlet to share their creations similar to what Dreams offers. Erf began creating his own Mario levels using paper and a cardboard “Game Boy” as a child, but if Dreams was available then, it would have been his tool of choice. Those levels would have met the same fate as the ones Nintendo is having removed today.

Aspiring game designers would be wise to come up with their own completely original creations for Dreams, so they can build up their creation chops without their projects getting removed. However, what a litigious company like Nintendo doesn’t seem to recognize is how little impact a Mario character in a 5-minute Dreams level has on its franchise.

It is certainly well within the company’s rights to disallow this content, but players aren’t thumbing their noses at purchasing Super Mario Odyssey because of a cobbled-together Dreams clone. It might even make them more likely to go buy the real game.

Editors' Recommendations

Gabe Gurwin
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Gabe Gurwin has been playing games since 1997, beginning with the N64 and the Super Nintendo. He began his journalism career…
These God of War Ragnarok settings made my playthrough much better
Kratos and Atreus sail on water in God of War Ragnarok.

There are a lot of reasons to be excited about God of War Ragnarok, which launches on PS4 and PS5 today. The action-adventure sequel is another high-quality first-party game for PlayStation owners, following up 2018’s hit God of War reboot with a bigger (though relatively equal) experience. Some fans may be eager to see Kratos' story continue, while others just might be itching to swing the ever-so-satisfying Leviathan Ax again.

What was I most excited to see and do when I booted it up? Open the settings menu.

Read more
The best video games of June 2022: TMNT, Fire Emblem, and more
An image of the TMNT in Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Shredder’s Revenge.

Following all of the major summer showcases, there's a general feeling that gaming in 2022 already peaked earlier this year with games like Elden Ring, Horizon Forbidden West, and Kirby and the Forgotten Land. That said, this mindset isn't really that accurate because June contained several of 2022's best games.
From beat 'em ups to simple mobiles games to grand Musou adventures, there were a lot of games to enjoy alongside all of the announcements this month. If you haven't played anything new this month because you thought 2022 gaming couldn't get any better than Elden Ring, we recommend the following six games.
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Shredder’s Revenge
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Shredder’s Revenge - Gameplay overview
Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Shredder’s Revenge isn’t a super complex game; it’s just almost perfectly executed for what it is. This beat ’em up calls back to classics like Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles IV: Turtles in Time while paying respect to the popular franchise with a variety of Easter eggs and beautiful pixel art. Anyone can pick up and enjoy its beat-’em-up combat, and it’s filled with every hero or enemy you’d expect to see in a TMNT game.
We even gave Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Shredder’s Revenge our first five-star review of 2022. “Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Shredder’s Revenge is a must-play for both TMNT and beat-’em-up fans alike,” Digital Trends contributor De’Angelo Epps wrote in his review. “It’s a game that takes what worked in the past, but still finds space to innovate beyond its fan service and nostalgia play.”
Surprisingly, the game features six-player co-op, so all of your friends who are TMNT fans can get in on the fun. It’s a near-perfect beat ’em up that succeeds at precisely what it was out to achieve and shouldn’t be overlooked because of that. Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Shredder’s Revenge is available now for PC, PS4, Xbox One, and Nintendo Switch. It’s even on Xbox Game Pass, so it’s easy to try out if you’re curious.
Fire Emblem Warriors: Three Hopes
Fire Emblem Warriors: Three Hopes - Announcement Trailer - Nintendo Switch
Like Hyrule Warriors: Age of Calamity and Persona 5 Strikers, Fire Emblem Warriors: Three Hopes incorporates enough elements from the game it’s based on and tells a compelling enough story to stand on its own. Fire Emblem mechanics such as permadeath, distinct character classes and abilities, and support conversations combined with the high-octane Musou action players have come to expect from Koei Tecmo’s Musou games to make something special.
“This is a high-effort hack-and-slash that convincingly functions as a full-fledged sequel to Fire Emblem: Three Houses,” gaming editor Giovanni Colantonio wrote in its four-star Digital Trends review. “While its core action gets repetitive due to a lack of overall variety, there are plenty of familiar RPG hooks around it that keep the adventure engaging. For those who want a good reason to revisit the land of Fódlan, Three Hopes is much deeper than a reunion special.”
The game’s narrative, in particular, stands out as Three Houses’ protagonist Byleth is now the villain. Like Three Houses, You can also play Three Hopes multiple times over if you want to see the story from each house’s perspective. Fire Emblem Warriors: Three Hopes is available now for Nintendo Switch. If you want to try it, a free demo with several hours’ worth of content is available on the eShop.
Poinpy | Official Game Trailer | Netflix
Poinpy is much more obscure than the other games on this list because it’s tucked away as a Netflix exclusive for iOS and Android. If you search for it in the Games tab of your Netflix app on mobile, you’ll be able to jump to the App Store and Google Play Store and download it. If you go through the effort to do all that, you’ll find a simple but enthralling mobile game about collecting fruit to keep a monster at bay as you continuously climb to escape it.
It’s from the creator of the challenging but equally satisfying Downwell. Instead of descending into a dark and dreary well, Poinpy is a much more cute and colorful experience where your focus is on launching your character up to collect fruit and escape. A monster is always chasing you, so you’ll have to collect certain combinations of fruit to feed it and keep it at bay. Once you get the hang of swiping to jump and tapping your phone to stomp into the ground, you won’t want to put Poinpy down.
Netflix’s video game initiative hasn’t quite caught on yet, which is why Poinpy is relatively obscure. If Netflix can keep delivering games of this quality, people will start to notice. Poinpy is available now for iOS and Android via Netflix. Simply get a Netflix subscription, and you’ll be able to access the game without any ads or microtransactions.
Neon White
NEON WHITE | Launch Trailer
Neon White presents itself as a first-person shooter with an edgy story and intense platforming, but it really just wants you to have a good time. This game is about a bunch of criminals trying to earn their place in heaven by competing in a contest to kill the most demons. As you do this, you’ll be platforming around heavenly levels and taking out demons with guns that come from cards strewn about the level. It’s an odd mix of genres, but it works.
“Neon White takes some big swings with its card-shooter/platformer premise and fortunately doesn’t miss,” Giovanni Colantonio wrote in his four-star Neon White review. “Its execution-heavy action is wildly fast and fun, pushing players to complete complex demon-slaying gauntlets that pepper in exciting twists through the game’s last moments.”
Neon White will be up your alley if you love games like Mirror’s Edge and Clustertruck that challenge your first-person platforming skills. Visual novel fans will get a kick out of the game, too, thanks to its compelling story about who deserves forgiveness and gift system that lets the player unlock extra conversations and memories with Neon White’s supporting cast. Neon White is available now for PC and Nintendo Switch.
AI: The Somnium Files – nirvanA Initiative
AI: THE SOMNIUM FILES - nirvanA Initiative Gameplay Trailer
A follow-up to a 2019 cult classic mystery adventure game, AI: The Somnium Files – nirvanA Initiative has been a low-key critical darling this month. Sitting at an 85 on Metacritic, fans of the Danganronpa series or other similar anime-inspired games should check AI: The Somnium Files – nirvanA Initiative out. In it, you’re trying to track down a serial killer who is literally tearing people in half.
To find out who did this, you must investigate the crime scene to look for evidence and delve into people’s minds to extract more information that could help with the case. Its intense anime stylings and frequent innuendo-filled jokes aren’t for everyone, but if AI: The Somnium Files – nirvanA Initiative, it could scratch that detective gaming itch and be one of your favorites of the year.
AI: The Somnium Files – nirvanA Initiative is available for PC, PS4, Xbox One, and Nintendo Switch.
Card Shark
Card Shark - Release Date Trailer - Nintendo Switch
Like Neon White, Card Shark puts a spin on the card game formula. Instead of blending shooting and platforming mechanics, Card Shark is all about cheating at traditional card games with different tactics. It’s also a beautiful game, as Card Shark is styled after the paintings from 18th century France, where the game is set.
“Card Shark is one of the most inventive video games I’ve played this year, completely spinning the concept of genre on its head,” Giovanni Colantonio wrote about the game earlier this month. “Despite having cards, I can’t really call it a 'card game.' It’s an unclassifiable title that’s more about finding a compelling way to turn real-world sleight of hand into engaging gameplay. Whenever I could successfully pull off a trick without arousing too much suspicion, I felt like an overconfident mastermind.”
If you enjoy card games (or maybe want to pick up a few cheating tricks of your own), Card Shark is worth checking out on PC or Nintendo Switch. While it’s been somewhat forgotten as it came out early in the month ahead of Summer Game Fest, it helps show that times of the year that are considered quiet by many gamers can contain some of its best games.

Read more
PS Plus Extra finally gives me a reason to keep my PS5 powered on
A PS5 standing on a table, with purple lights around it.

Due to the nature of my job, I own every modern video game console. I have a PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X, Nintendo Switch, PC, and even a Steam Deck. Would you believe me if I told you that out of all of those, the PS5 is the one I use the least?

It’s not that I never use it. Sony still offers the best console exclusives around, with top-notch titles like Horizon Forbidden West and Returnal. For that reason, my PS5 is a sturdy pillar in my gaming rotation that’ll never just sit collecting dust. That said, I rarely boot it up for any reason other than to play those handful of releases. Meanwhile, each of my other gaming devices have some incentive that has me returning to them even when there’s not a tentpole AAA game to dig into.

Read more