Skip to main content

Meet Sony’s Man Behind The Coming Console/PC Gaming Convergence

john smedley amazon game studios sony entertainment interview
Image used with permission by copyright holder
The debate between console and PC gamers will never end, not until one medium completely disappears, and probably not even then (unless one side finally rises up and murders the other). But even as the Internet battles continue, the actual heart of the argument is becoming increasingly irrelevant.

The PlayStation 4 and Xbox One are both designed with a PC framework in mind. There are still significant difference between a gaming PC and the new consoles, but developers can latch on to the similarities. Not only does that mean more and more studios will be developing for both platforms, it also means that the quality of the next gen games should ramp up quicker than in previous console launches since developers are already familiar with the tools and won’t have to spend years acquainting themselves with the new hardware.

“I think free-to-play on the consoles is just starting to scratch the surface”

We discussed this shift in the gaming landscape with John Smedley, president and CEO of Sony Online Entertainment. Smedley has been working in the gaming industry for three decades now, and has been associated primarily with PC games. From championing the original EverQuest back when it was just an idea for a new online game, to helping shift SOE’s financial model from subscription to free-to-play, Smedley has been a pioneer in the field of PC gaming. With the advent of the PlayStation 4, though, the line between developing for PC and consoles has blurred, and SOE’s strategy has shifted to match.

We spoke with Smedley about developing on the PS4, the possible life of the systems, and the possible future of gaming.

How has this console launch been different for console launches in the past?

I think the single biggest thing with the PS4 is the memory. I think you’re starting to see a lot more skus lead on the PlayStation 4, because it’s frankly super easy to move it to the PC and vice versa.

How is developing for the PS4 different from PC?

It’s different from PC because you are dealing with a hardware base that is static. For us, being able depend on 8 GBs of RAM [in the PS4] is as good as it gets, so I’m stoked about it.

Does that change how you develop?

Well, because we’re able to patch the game, the development itself doesn’t change, the operation of the game changes quite a bit. The operation is difficult because we have to coordinate patches, and there are times when it takes a little longer on the console to patch because there are much more stringent QA requirements. Sometimes it takes a little longer. So to have the discipline and patience to do that right does take work.

Have there been any specific stumbling blocks to bringing PC games to the PS4? Will we see PlanetSide 2 on the PS4 soon?

We haven’t actually announced a date [for PlanetSide 2]. It’ll be early next year, but we aren’t really saying a date yet, mostly because we’re putting the finishing touches on stuff. It has been a super easy move because the architecture is so similar to what we’re working with.

PlanetSide 2
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The next-gen consoles are much more like PCs than previous systems …

Oh yeah.

Is that how the industry is going? Are we going to get to a point where there is no distinction between PCs and consoles?

You know, I think that is exactly what Valve is trying to do. My opinion is I don’t think they are going to be the same thing, and the reason for that is sort of the location. Yes, it’s true, you can put your PC in your living room and hook up to your TV, but most people just don’t do that. So I think what you’re going to see is those two probably remain a little separate.

Since you work on both PC and console, do you see any differences in the habits of gamers on each platform?

The single biggest one is the control mechanism, obviously. The mouse makes it a very different experience. What I really see, though, is more similarities than differences because games nowadays are going to be available on both, and it’s just going to be wherever you feel like playing. And I think that’s a good thing.

With games created for the PC first, what’s the process to convert those controls to a gamepad?

“It’ll be years before we see the real power [of the PS4]”

The process depends on the type of game you are making, but let me use PlanetSide 2 as an example. We have more controls than a normal shooter, but still at its core the basics are there. So what we wanted to do was give the people a familiar shooter environment so that it’s similar, and that you have controls that you can configure. So it can be like Battlefield 3 or 4, or like Call of Duty depending on your preference. So what we do is just start with the obvious and look at other games that have similar features, and popular games, because if somebody plays a lot of one game, that becomes sort of the one standard. Sort of like [using the keyboard keys] “WASD” in FPS. So we spent a lot of time analyzing what people like, what people don’t like, we try it, we give it to our compatibility lab, and if they like it we’ll give it out to the public.

What were the biggest challenges to developing on three consoles (PS3, PS4, and PC) at once?

Probably the fact that coordinating the timing of the launch was difficult because there were so many changes. That means we didn’t just get one console approval, we got two, and we had to get the PC version ready to go. It was logistically challenging, but we pulled it off.

DC Universe Online originally debuted on January 2011 on PC and PS3 (and now on PS4), but you’ve been constantly updating and evolving it since. What lessons have you taken from that, that surprised you?

Probably the biggest one is that the PlayStation 3 players absolutely are bothered by the fact that PC players get their patches sooner. That was kind of a lesson learned. We treat that with much more care now because we’re able to patch fast on the PC. So the PlayStation players, when they hear that’s out there, this one global community definitely lets us know that we need to be putting the patch out on the same day.

After less than a year, DCUO went from subscription to free-to-play, and since then all SOE games have used that model. How is the switch working out?

It went over pretty well because we’ve been able to get a lot more people into the game now. I think free-to-play on the consoles is just starting to scratch the surface, and it’s such a great, captive audience that I think it will do very well there.

Is free-to-play the way to go, or is it just one option?

It’s definitely going to be one option, but I would venture to guess that it’s going to become the norm instead of the exception. But is it going to be the only one? No.

Some of the stuff coming out on PC, like EverQuest Next, is doing some remarkable stuff with things like AI. Will that translate to consoles?

Absolutely, and we’re very excited about the PS4. It’s got the horsepower to do it.

EverQuest Next Concept
Image used with permission by copyright holder

What about Runewaker’s Dragon’s Prophet?

Dragon’s Prophet we have no plans to bring to a console, only because it is a third-party game, one of the partners we work with. We have no intention of turning that into a console game, at least not right now.

With your strategy going forward, are you going to be looking at developing games for both PS4 and PC, or maybe do an exclusive for one or the other?

We’re always going to be doing games for PC and the latest Sony devices. We’ll definitely be bringing it to both. Not every game will be on both, some games don’t work as well on one system or another. It’s likely we’ll be doing a lot of PS4 stuff.

Since the PS4 architecture is more familiar than previous consoles, do you think we’ll see games hit their stride faster than with previous systems?

I do. In fact, on the PS3 people are just now getting the power output. Because, let’s face it, it’s very powerful but it can be hard to use, so people are just now getting the hang of it. The architecture on the PS4 is totally different and it’s very similar to PC, so they’re used to it.

So is it really easier to develop on the PS4 over the PS3, or is it just more familiar?

It’s by far easier to develop. First and foremost, you’re using tools you’re familiar with. Second, you’re using an architecture that, in my opinion, is one of the best in the world, but most importantly is familiar to them because they are familiar with the x86. And then if you take a look at the actual amount of people kind of going through it, they’ve been able to really pour people through to make sure that it’s a good experience.

The Last of Us is a good example of a game that impressed a lot of people late in the console’s life. Since the PS4 hardware is more similar to what PC devs are using, do you think we’ll hit a peak sooner, or will console devs continue to surprise us years from now?

“It’s likely we’ll be doing a lot of PS4 stuff.”

I think it’s going to be years from now, where people are still surprising us, and here’s why: As PC makers, we tend to build for a more scaleable architecture than most console games. And so, because of that, we’re trying to push the bounds. And the reality is that most PC games don’t require large amounts of memory, but this generation is going to change that, so I think it is going to fundamentally change PC gaming forever. Let me give you a classic example, look at Call of Duty. On the PC they require 64 bits. That’s not a small deal …

… And 40 GBs to install.

Yeah, a year ago that would have been unthinkable, especially for Call of Duty, kind of the flag bearer of mass market. So this environment is changing fast and I think because PC is so ubiquitous and because everybody uses one at work – or most people – I think we’re going to see a real renaissance.

How long will the next-gen hardware be relevant from a technological standpoint?

What I think ends up happening with consoles is that people learn to push the limits of what they can work with there. I think that tends to mean you have to get a lot more innovative than you do on the PC, where you cannot worry as much about memory and other stuff. So now that we’ve got such a powerful computer console underneath the hood there, it’s basically going to let [devs] go crazy. It’ll be years before we see the real power.

Things like improved graphics and sharing capabilities seem like obvious improvements to the next-gen systems in hindsight, but what do you think will come next for gaming, five or 10 years down the road?

I think you’re going to see the virtual reality stuff start to matter, and I think you’re also going to see new forms of controllers. I was very heartened to see Steam’s invention of a new controller. I’m not saying I like it or dislike it – I’m just saying it’s time somebody is innovating. To me those are positive developments.

Steam Controller
Image used with permission by copyright holder

So are you guys looking at integrating new peripherals like Oculus Rift?

Absolutely, we’re very interested in that and other peripherals. Oculus Rift is especially interesting, in no small part because we’re gamers ourselves and it’s just damn cool.

Is that something you can plan for yet though? Do you need to see if the market will accept it first or will you try it because, as gamers, you enjoy it?

Well, it’s also in our DNA. I mean, we are a company that prides itself on innovation, and we derive a lot of satisfaction when we’re making awesome games and we’re doing so with new tech. A good example is something called SOEmote. It’s something that is pretty basic that just nobody ever thought of doing before in an MMO, which is reusing your camera to read your face and apply it to your avatar. So we love this stuff. A lot of times, we’ll build it and hope then they come. Sometimes they do, sometimes they don’t, but from our perspective, we’re having a blast making it, so the journey is what we like.

Are you looking into new transmedia opportunities for SOE properties? Comics, books, and the like?

For our own IP, we are absolutely interested in doing that, and we’re looking at it pretty closely as a matter of fact. And although we don’t have any announcements to make right now, we’ve got some awesome deals we’ve put together that we can’t wait for the players to see.

Editors' Recommendations

Ryan Fleming
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Ryan Fleming is the Gaming and Cinema Editor for Digital Trends. He joined the DT staff in 2009 after spending time covering…
The best single-player games
The Master Sword in Tears of the Kingdom.

It's never been a better time to be a multiplayer gamer, with fantastic titles such as Fortnite, GTA Online, and Call of Duty: Warzone taking the industry by storm. However, the same can be said about single-player experiences, especially in recent years thanks to the PS5, Xbox Series X|S, and PC.

Dedicated single-player games are some of the richest, most beloved experiences in the medium, and in this list, we'll go through the very best. These are the best single-player games.

Read more
PlayStation Showcase teased Sony’s live service future, but I’m not impressed yet
playstation showcase live service games reveals marathon

Ahead of the May 2023 PlayStation Showcase, I wrote that the presentation needed to “elicit confidence in Sony’s future with live service.” Well, multiplayer-focused live service games did end up being a big part of the show, but I can’t say I’m that confident in them yet.
Between neat looks at single-player exclusives like Marvel’s Spider-Man 2 and Synapse, Sony revealed four live-service games that it's publishing. Those games are Haven Studios’ Fairgame$, Arrowhead Studios’ Helldivers 2, Bungie’s Marathon, and Firewalk Studios’ Concord. The fact that these accounted for almost every major first-party announcements of the show signals that we’re entering a new era for Sony: one where multiplayer rules.
Over the past year or so, PlayStation Studios has made it very clear that it’s trying to break into the games-as-a-service sector now that it’s perfected the single-player adventure with games like Horizon Forbidden West and God of War: Ragnarok. Unfortunately, these early live service announcements raised more concerns than hope, which isn’t a great start when it comes to establishing a new direction for PlayStation.
A live service showcase
Haven’s sci-fi PvPvE heist game Fairgame$ was the PlayStation Showcase’s opening, and honestly, it wasn’t a memorable first showing. The trailer was purely cinematic, but its shots were composed like they were live gameplay. That still feels misleading 18 years after Sony did it with Killzone 2, even if it clarified it at the start of the trailer. It also means I don’t have a good idea of how this game will be structured and when I’ll have a chance to play it. All I know is that this is an anti-capitalist game that will probably also be a heavily monetized live service experience. It wasn’t a strong show opener; at least, like all of the other titles on this list, it’s also coming to PC.

Fairgame$ was followed up by the long-awaited reveal of Helldivers 2, a sequel to an entertaining 2015 PS Plus sci-fi top-down shooter. To Helldivers 2’s credit, it had the most honest-feeling showing of these games, with a trailer that showed lots of impressive third-person action gameplay and even gave a 2023 release window. Even if its anti-capitalist undertones were a bit similar to Fairgame$, this was the style of reveal I was hoping to see from Sony’s live service announcements. Unfortunately, it was the only live service game reveal to feature any actual gameplay.
After a break from live service announcements, Bungie emerged to reveal that it was reviving Marathon as a sci-fi PvP extraction shooter. While it’s very surprising to see Marathon coming back and that Bungie is making something other than Destiny, it was a purely cinematic trailer that leaned into its techno-futuristic aesthetics -- much like Fairgame$’s reveal trailer. A dev diary released after the reveal also says that we’ll need to wait a while to learn more and see gameplay. But you can buy a $77 shirt based on this game we don’t know much about yet, though.

Read more
PlayStation gets into the streaming handheld game with Project Q
Project Q and PlayStation earbuds

During the May 2023 PlayStation Showcase, PlayStation CEO Jim Ryan revealed Project Q. It's a new handheld streaming device that will allow you to stream any game from your PlayStation 5 console using its remote play function or Wi-Fi.

It doesn't have an official name yet, so it's known internally as Project Q. What we do know is that it has an 8-inch HD screen, plus all of the buttons and features of a DualSense wireless controller.

Read more