Skip to main content

The Smile Mirror for cancer patients is getting a ton of blowback online

smile mirror
Image used with permission by copyright holder
File this one under, “It seemed like a good idea at the time.”

A new invention by a Brooklyn-based product and experience designer with good intentions is drawing online fury, most fiercely by the very people the invention was meant to help. Berk Ilhan is the creator behind the “Smile Mirror,” a new gadget intended to lift the spirits of cancer patients. As advertised, the mirror will reveal a patient’s reflection, but only if they smile.

Image used with permission by copyright holder
Image used with permission by copyright holder

While attending the School of Visual Arts in New York, Ilhan developed a year-long thesis project called Uplift, which involved conceptualizing a portfolio of products designed to improve the quality of life of cancer patients, emotionally and socially. In addition to the mirror, Ilhan also conceived a newspaper that only delivers the good and happy news.

The electronic mirror is outfitted with a built-in camera and an opaque surface that is triggered by facial recognition software. The patent-pending invention intended to gift patients a smile will soon launch a Kickstarter crowdfunding campaign. Right now, the unit costs between $2,000 and $3,000, but Ilhan would like to see a final price closer to $500.

Ilhan, originally from Turkey, spent time at cancer hospitals in there speaking with patients, doctors and caregivers. The final device was inspired by Ilhan’s encounter with a cancer survivor. His ultimate goal is to donate Smile Mirrors to hospitals.

“She told me in the first days after her diagnosis, it was difficult for her to look in the mirror and acknowledge she had cancer,” he told CNN Tech. “Our facial expressions affect how we feel. If we flex our facial muscles to smile, our brains think that something good happened and as a result, happiness.”

The reaction to the breaking story has not been hospitable, despite Ilhan’s good intentions. At IFLScience, we find the headline, “This mirror for cancer patients only works when you smile, and everyone thinks it’s a terrible idea.” Bustle calls it,”An incredibly misguided idea.” The New Stateman‘s headline reads: “The mirror that forces cancer patients to smile is borderline dystopian.”

At Slate, cancer survivor and technology writer Jacob Brogan gets to the heart of the matter.

“This is, again, not a device designed with the interests of patients in mind,” he writes. “To the contrary, it asks them to ignore — perhaps even to reject — the small sanctuary of what they feel within. Cancer is already alienating, and this is alienation of another sort. Etymologically, the word patient derives from a Latinate root meaning suffering. Those who love us can attempt to ameliorate our pain, but they should never expect us to live without it. If you would like to see us smile, tell us a joke. Surely you know the ones we like. We will laugh if we are ready to, but our smiles are not yours to claim.”

Editors' Recommendations

Clayton Moore
Clayton Moore’s interest in technology is deeply rooted in the work of writers like Warren Ellis, Cory Doctorow and Neal…
Simplehuman’s Sensor Mirror Hi-Fi now responds to Amazon Alexa commands
simplehuman sensor miirror hi fi and assist google assistant ces 2019 mirror compact

Simplehuman is all-in when it comes to smart home stuff. From trash cans to soap dispensers to its flagship product, a series of sensor mirrors, the designer/manufacturer is determined to make your bathroom one of the most inviting rooms in your home. They were everywhere at the Consumer Electronics Show (CES) in Las Vegas earlier this year,and now their smart mirror  -- which has always worked with Google Assistant -- is adding Amazon's Alexa to the mix.

sensor mirror — tru-lux light

Read more
Best portable power station deals: Bluetti, EcoFlow, and more
Bluetti AC300 portable power station

If you like to take a fair chunk of the modern world with you when you hit the road or set off on a camping trip, it can be beneficial to take one of the best portable power stations with you. A portable power station can be beneficial simply to keep around the house as well, as it can come in handy during power outage and backyard gatherings, among other things. Of all the smart home deals you can shop right now, portable power stations offer some of the largest savings by dollar amount. Reading onward you’ll find all of the best portable power station deals available right now, with brands like Bluetti, Jackery, and EcoFlow ready to charge things up after you grab something from the best tablet deals, best laptop deals, or best phone deals. And if you’d like to shop for some further savings around the house, be sure to check out the current lawn mower deals, pressure washer deals, and smart lock deals.

Our favorite portable power station deals

Read more
Best office chair deals: Improve your posture from $78
staples offering best deals on select printers office chairs plus free shipping chair

A long day at the desk deserves a way to make it more comfortable. Adding one of the best ergonomic office chairs to your work life can get a little expensive, which is why we’ve rounded up the best office chair deals worth shopping right now. There are a lot of budget options and premium options available, as well as several to choose from in between. Reading onward you can find all of the details on the best office chair deals to shop right now, and if you’re looking for some savings on a device to plop yourself in front of have a look at the going laptop deals, gaming laptop deals, desktop computer deals, and monitor deals as well.
Flash Furniture Fundamentals swivel task chair — $86, was $149

This offering from Flash Furniture clearly states that it is task chair and not your typical office chair. Not familiar with the lingo? Task chairs are a subset of office chairs that are made to... well, do tasks in. The thinking goes that office chairs are used primarily for sitting and looking at screens, then doing occasional fits of typing and clicking. The Flash Fundamentals Task Chair, and other task chairs like it, are made for more activity than normal. How does Flash Furniture give you this? It emphasizes quick twists in the 360-degree swivel and a smaller horizontal profile so you can move about with ease through multiple task stations or with multiple workers present. And, of course, there's the nice mesh backing to keep you from getting overheated while doing everything. Try it out for yourself via the button below to see if a task chair is for you.

Read more