You may be forgiven for thinking that the Google Pixel 4 XL‘s launch wasn’t long ago, but the Google Pixel 5 has already arrived to oust it from its throne as the queen of Google smartphones. It improves on some of the minor failings of last year’s phone, introducing a bigger battery, a sleeker edge-to-edge display, and a useful ultrawide camera lens. At the same time, it keeps all the features Pixel phones are celebrated for, including a supremely versatile main camera lens, highly usable software, and a sharp display.
However, there are some interesting differences between the two best phones, leaving it debatable as to which one is better. To answer this question, we compare the Pixel 5 and Pixel 4 XL across a series of categories, looking at how they measure up in terms of their specs, displays, designs, performance, cameras, software, and special features. This should settle once and for all which one is worth your time and money and whether you should upgrade if you’re using the Pixel 4 XL.
|Google Pixel 5||Google Pixel 4 XL|
|Size||144.7 x 70.4 x 8mm (5.70 x 2.77 x 0.31 inches)||160.4 × 75.1 × 8.2mm (6.3 × 2.9 × 0.3 inches)|
|Weight||151 grams (5.33 ounces)||193 grams (6.8 ounces)|
|Screen size||6.0-inch OLED capacitive touchscreen||6.3-inch AMOLED|
|Screen resolution||2340 x 1080 pixels (432 pixels per inch)||3040 × 1440 pixels (537 pixels per inch)|
|Operating system||Android 11||Android 11|
|MicroSD card slot||No||No|
|Tap-to-pay services||Google Pay||Google Pay|
|Processor||Qualcomm Snapdragon 765||Qualcomm Snapdragon 855|
|Camera||Dual lens 12-megapixel wide, 16MP ultrawide rear, 8MP front||Dual 12-megapixel and 16MP telephoto rear, 8MP front|
|Video||4k at 60 frames per second, 1080p at 30 fps||4K at 30 frames per second, 1080p at 120 fps, 720p at 240 fps|
|Bluetooth version||Bluetooth 5.0||Bluetooth 5.0|
|Ports||USB-C, 3.1||USB-C, 3.1|
|Fingerprint sensor||Yes, rear-mounted||No, face unlock|
Fast charging (18W)
Reverse wireless charging
Fast charging (18W)
Qi wireless charging
|App marketplace||Google Play Store||Google Play Store|
|Network support||Verizon, Google Fi||T-Mobile, AT&T, Verizon, Sprint|
|Colors||Just Black, Sorta Sage||Just Black, Clearly White, Oh So Orange|
|Review score||4 out of 5 stars||4 out of 5 stars|
There’s no denying it: The Pixel 5 is a better-looking smartphone than the Pixel 4 XL. The 4 XL may have been big and bright, but it was let down by a very large forehead bezel. The Pixel 5 gets rid of that eyesore, replacing it with a pretty edge-to-edge display that looks very smart, even if it isn’t quite as eye-catching as other 2020 flagships. It’s also 32 grams lighter and is about 16cm shorter and 5cm less wide, making it more comfortable to hold for extended periods of time.
On the other hand, there’s no doubt that the Pixel 4 XL has the more impressively vivid screen. At 6.3 inches and 3040 × 1440 pixels, it provides a satisfying 537 pixels per inch (ppi). By contrast, the Pixel 5’s 6-inch screen packs 2340 x 1080 pixels, meaning it offers a less attention-grabbing 432 ppi. This is still good, but with the Pixel 4 XL also having an AMOLED (rather than OLED) display, the overall impression is that last year’s phone gives you more to look at. Both phones do support a 90Hz refresh rate, so even though the 4 XL is noticeably better, you won’t be disappointed by the Pixel 5.
Both smartphones come with the same IP68 rating, which should mean they can cope with submersion in 1.5 meters of water for up to 30 minutes (as well as exposure to dust). This makes things pretty equal between the two phones, and with the Pixel 5 looking better — while the 4 XL has the better screen — we’re calling this round a tie.
Both the Pixel 5 and the 4 XL come with Qualcomm Snapdragon processors. That said, the 4 XL uses the powerful 855 chip, while the Pixel 5 settles for the slightly less capable 765. This means the 4 XL can handle apps and multitasking better than its newer sibling. The Pixel 5 comes with 8GB of RAM, while the 4 XL packs 6GB, so you should see pretty much the same levels of performance in all but the most demanding of apps.
The Pixel 5 is generous enough to contain 128GB of internal storage as standard, doubling the amount (64GB) the Pixel 4 XL provides. This relatively low amount of ROM is quite surprising given the 4 XL was supposed to be a premium-level flagship smartphone, and you’ll have to pay $100 extra if you want 128GB.
The Pixel 4 XL’s battery life was also surprisingly disappointing, even if it came with more juice than the Pixel 4. At 3,700mAh, this isn’t quite enough to see out a heavy day of use with a reassuring amount of battery life to spare. The Pixel 5 makes amends for this misstep from Google, housing a 4,080mAh battery instead. Our review found that it comfortably lasts a full day of busy use, while also going for just over two days under lighter use.
With this in mind, and with a more practical amount of internal memory, this round is a slim but clear victory for the Pixel 5.
Winner: Google Pixel 5
Both phones opt for dual-lens rear cameras. While the Pixel 5 has a 12.2-megapixel wide lens and a 16MP ultrawide lens, the Pixel 4 XL goes for the same wide lens and a 16MP telephoto lens. This would arguably make them hard to compare, seeing as how they seemingly cater to different uses (i.e., wide shots versus zoomed shots). Nonetheless, the main wide lens of both phones contains a feature that makes the ultrawide lens of the Pixel 5 more useful than the telephoto camera on the 4 XL.
This feature is the Super Res Room, which has been a staple on Google phones ever since the Pixel 3. The Super Res Zoom uses artificial intelligence (A.I.) to enhance photos (taken with the normal wide lens) that use digital zoom, giving them a quality that comes seriously close to rivaling the quality of actual telephoto lenses. This makes the telephoto camera on the Pixel 4 XL a little redundant, while also making the ultrawide lens on the Pixel 5 more appreciated.
Otherwise, the Pixel 5 and Pixel 4 XL are two of the best camera phones you can buy right now. A 12.2MP wide lens may not sound like much, but with Google’s algorithms at the helm, you will struggle to take bad photographs. The Pixel 5 also adds a few new software tweaks and features, such as the ability to switch light sources with Portrait Mode, making it slightly but tangibly better than last year’s model.
As for the video, the Pixel 5 can capture 4K video at 60 fps, while the Pixel 4 XL goes only as far as 30 fps. Combined with the more useful ultrawide lens, this round ends up being another win for the Pixel 5.
Winner: Google Pixel 5
To cut a long story short, the Pixel 5 and 4 XL are identical when it comes to software and updates. They both run Android 11, which has improved the already excellent Android UX by adding a native screen recorder, improved media controls (moving them under the quick settings menu), and changes to conversations and notification bubbles.
Regardless of whether you opt for a Pixel 5 or 4 XL, you’ll also be treated to speedy updates, given that Android is a Google-created operating system. This can only mean that this round is a tie given that both phones are identical in terms of software.
Here comes another Pixel 5 advantage: It supports 5G networks, while the Pixel 4 XL goes no further than good-old 4G. This will make a big difference in connection speed when 5G networks become more widespread (in a year or so), while the Pixel 5’s support for mmWave and sub-6Hz bands will also give you the fastest possible speeds (where available).
On the other hand, the Pixel 4 XL comes with Face Unlock, which works like Apple’s Face ID to unlock your phone by looking at it. The Pixel 5 has removed this feature, reverting to the less exciting and slightly less secure fingerprint scanner on the back. This is a shame since Google’s Face Unlock worked very well. It didn’t have much compatibility beyond unlocking the phone, though, so maybe some people won’t miss it that much.
Seeing as how the 4 XL didn’t use its face sensor for much beyond unlocking, we’re going to give this round to the Pixel 5. 5G will prove a much more useful and significant feature in the near future, so it’s arguably more future-proofed than its older stablemate.
Winner: Google Pixel 5
The Pixel 5 is available from Google for $699 and will ship in the U.S. starting on October 29. It will be supported by Verizon, Google Fi, and AT&T, and you’ll also be able to buy it from Amazon.
The Pixel 4 XL has been available since October 2019 and was officially priced at $899. Google no longer appears to be selling it directly from its own website, but it can be bought from Amazon, where the 64GB version now sells for considerably less than its launch price. The 128GB still sells for close to $1,000.
Take a look at some of the best Google Pixel deals we’ve found to save some money.
There isn’t really much doubt: The Pixel 5 looks set to be a more capable and desirable smartphone than the Pixel 4 XL. Its design is much improved, the internal memory is more generous, its camera is more useful and versatile, it supports 5G, and has a longer-lasting battery. The Pixel 4 XL may admittedly have a crisper screen and also Face Unlock, but other than that, there isn’t much to recommend it over the newer model. Regardless of your priorities as a smartphone user, you will almost certainly end up happier with the Pixel 5 than the 4 XL.
- The best Walmart TV deals for August 2021: 4K TVs, QLED TVs, and OLED TVs
- Google has three new Nest Cams, but there’s really only one you should buy
- Mobvoi TicWatch E3 review: The long lasting smartwatch
- Google Nest Cam Battery vs. Wired vs. Floodlight
- The best Bluetooth headsets for 2021