The Witness review

The Witness is one of the most vexing, irresistible puzzle games since Myst

The Witness is one of the best exploration puzzle games since Myst.
The Witness is one of the best exploration puzzle games since Myst.
The Witness is one of the best exploration puzzle games since Myst.

Highs

  • Island setting inspires curiosity
  • Puzzles are simple, but hard to master
  • Beautiful graphics
  • Lack of hand-holding is refreshing

Lows

  • Puzzle difficulty and pacing can overwhelm
  • A few audio quirks

Myst kicked off a new wave of adventure games in 1993, and its influence on modern game design is undeniable. Known for its distinctive otherworldly setting and effective use of pre-rendered video, Myst challenged players to explore every inch of their surroundings and solve esoteric puzzles while piecing together a backing narrative. As the adventure game genre evolved, however, Myst‘s faults overshadowed its achievements. Many criticized its overwrought and nonsensical puzzles, which bogged down its central exploration elements and soured its sense of mystery.

The Witness, the latest game from Braid creator Jonathan Blow, aims to recreate Myst‘s successes while avoiding its missteps. The result is a deeply enthralling game that rewards logic, exploration, and patience, and it’s one of the PlayStation 4’s most fascinating releases to date.

Riddle me this

Like Myst before it, The Witness takes place on an abandoned island that players explore from a first-person perspective. After escaping from an introductory gameplay area, players discover a vast open world filled with snaking, interconnected pathways that are unlocked by solving puzzles.

Puzzles in The Witness consist of a series of electrical panels scattered throughout the abandoned island. Upon activating one of these panels, players must draw an unbroken line through a maze of twisting circuits, tracing a path from entrance to exit while fulfilling unspoken requirements unique to each puzzle.

While the puzzle mechanics themselves are simple, solutions often require experimentation and exploration. The Witness conceals the bulk of its puzzle solutions within its environments, and players must often search for subtle patterns or inconsistencies within their surroundings in order to progress.

The best puzzles in The Witness demand a combination of exploration and logic. Solutions are rarely obvious, and the game’s lack of hints or tutorials makes puzzle-solving a difficult and mentally taxing process. This difficulty actually works to the game’s advantage; by giving the player so little guidance, The Witness effectively turns every puzzle’s solution into an epiphany, making gameplay incredibly satisfying.

The Witness effectively turns every puzzle’s solution into an epiphany, making gameplay incredibly satisfying.

Some puzzle sequences have a better sense of pacing than others, however. One especially tiresome stretch of gameplay involves creating walkways that unfold, tile-by-tile, for every puzzle solved. If you’re unable to solve any of these puzzles, your progress is blocked until you can brute-force a solution. Hitting a sudden roadblock after solving dozens of these puzzles in a row is frustrating, and knowing that several more difficult puzzles await after devising a particularly hard-fought solution is demoralizing.

Fortunately, these moments are rare, and The Witness’ open-ended design encourages players to abandon in-progress puzzles and return to them later. Many of the riddles you’ll encounter require solutions learned by exploring elsewhere, and several areas feature back-to-back puzzles that serve as instructions for solving specific maze layouts seen later in the game. This effectively gates player progress while reinforcing the puzzle-solving skills you’ll learn throughout.

By the end of The Witness, you’ll approach puzzles very differently than how you might have approached them at the game’s outset. Where other games might reward progress with new character abilities or weapons, The Witness instead arms you with new puzzle-solving strategies. As you progress and your puzzle-solving vocabulary grows, the process becomes less experimental and more intuitive, making for a constantly evolving gameplay dynamic.

Depths of design

While the parallels between The Witness and Blow’s previous project Braid are not immediately apparent, they both take a similar approach to mechanical depth. Both games feature a simple core mechanic that grows in complexity as gameplay progresses, challenging players to use the knowledge they’ve absorbed from previous puzzles in order to tackle new challenges.

The Witness

Often, solutions in both games require an extra bit of lateral thought to continue; Braid explored the limits of traditional platforming mechanics, while The Witness takes a similar approach with puzzle design. Ultimately, The Witness explores its mechanics to a greater depth than Braid did, and it’s much more satisfying as a result.

Did you hear that?

The Witness‘ audio matches its excellence in mechanical design, for the most part. Environmental sound effects and mood-setting tones accompany the player throughout, giving the game a meditative feel. It’s easy to underestimate just how great a role audio plays in The Witness, but in reality, a lot of thought was put into something as minor as how the player’s footsteps sound when walking across different types of terrain. You’ll hear appropriate and varied sound effects depending on whether you’re walking across dirt, grass, rocks, or planks, making your wanderings that much more absorbing.

The game’s audio is very quiet by default, however, making it difficult to hear key details without boosting your TV or stereo system’s volume significantly. One puzzle in particular requires the player to listen for subtle audio cues – something I would not have noticed if I wasn’t wearing headphones while playing. Subtitles also prove inadequate. On-screen dialog does not properly sync up with speeches delivered via audio logs, making them difficult to follow, and closed captioning is not available for important environmental sound effects. In its current state, The Witness may be unwinnable for players who have hearing disabilities.

Conclusion

Quirks aside, The Witness is a remarkable achievement. Its setting is lush and vivid, and its core puzzle-solving gameplay is intuitive without the need for instructions or tutorials. Developing a vocabulary for puzzle-solving in The Witness is very satisfying, and its abstracted approach to puzzles eliminates the directionless ambiguity that made Myst difficult to enjoy.

The Witness is immersive, taxing, enlightening, cathartic, deeply frustrating, ultimately rewarding, and you’ll love every minute of it.

This game was reviewed on PlayStation 4 with a copy provided by the publisher. It’s also available for PC and will set you back $40 upon its release Tuesday, January 26.

Gaming

The Astro A40 TR and Mixamp Pro TR turn the volume up on pro gaming audio

The A40 TR and Mixamp Pro TR are Astro's latest entries to professional grade gaming gear. The two accessories hold their own alone, but together their true potential is fully realized.
Gaming

Need a new Switch game? These will scratch the itch without emptying your wallet

Besides its great AAA games, the Nintendo Switch also has plenty of cheaper options. Here are some great Nintendo Switch games under $20, including some new versions of old classics.
Gaming

Your PlayStation 4 game library isn't complete without these games

Looking for the best PS4 games out there? Out of the massive crop of titles available, we selected the best you should buy. No matter what your genre of choice may be, there's something here for you.
Gaming

These are the must-have games that every Xbox One owner needs

More than four years into its life span, Microsoft's latest console is finally coming into its own. From Cuphead to Halo 5, the best Xbox One games offer something for players of every type.
Gaming

25 awesome indie games you should definitely be playing right now

These days, some of the best video games are made by independent studios. Here are 25 of the best indie games, whether you prefer grueling dungeon crawlers or otherworldly, meditative adventures.
Gaming

Activision reveals game modes, multiplayer maps for Call of Duty: Mobile

Activision revealed the first five modes for Call of Duty: Mobile. The publisher also highlighted five maps from previous entries in the franchise, but said that the game will not only feature multiplayer modes.
Gaming

Treyarch takes over 2020 Call of Duty, will make Black Ops 5

Treyarch is taking over development for the 2020 Call of Duty, which will be Black Ops 5, Kotaku reported. Raven was initially leading the project alongside Sledgehammer, but the two studios frequently got into arguments.
Gaming

These Xbox One exclusives are the definition of quality over quantity

Xbox One has a prestigious collection of handpicked titles that you can't play on other consoles. Here are the latest and greatest Xbox One exclusives, including some that are also available on PC
Gaming

The best Nintendo Switch games, from Breath of the Wild to Rocket League

The Nintendo Switch's lineup started off small, but games have steadily released as the console continues through its second year. Here are the best Nintendo Switch games available now.
Computing

Give your PC a new lease on life by upgrading its core components

Older PCs can still be great tools for work and play, they just need a little upgrade now and then. Here are the best upgrades you can make to your PC to make it feel fresh and fast once again.
Gaming

You're not a true fan without these Nintendo Switch exclusives

Who doesn't love a good Nintendo game? If you're looking for great first-party titles for your Nintendo Switch, take a look at our list of the very best exclusives available right now.
Gaming

World of Warcraft Classic beta testers confusing old-school features for bugs

Blizzard released a "not a bug" list for World of Warcraft Classic, as beta testers apparently kept reporting intended features. The list includes the "Your skill in Protection increased to 15" message that appears upon leveling up.
Gaming

Next Apex Legends patch will fix Gibraltar’s sticky shield and hit registration

Respawn is set to roll out a new patch for Apex Legends early this week. The update will look to fix several issues in the game, including Gibraltar's sticky shield, the Fortified passive ability, and incorrect hit registration.
Gaming

Red Dead Online poker missing in some parts of the world due to gambling laws

The massive update for Red Dead Online as it left beta added poker, among many other things, to the online component of Red Dead Redemption 2. Some players can't access the card game though, due to the gambling laws of their country.