Skip to main content

The bizarre controversy behind Cooking Mama: Cookstar

Controversy has surrounded Cooking Mama: Cookstar, the latest installment in the normally mild-mannered cooking simulator franchise for the Nintendo Switch, after it was abruptly pulled off the Nintendo eShop shortly after its release.

The game launched near the end of March, but it is currently unavailable on the Nintendo eShop across multiple regions. Physical copies in certain regions have also been reportedly held.

Recommended Videos

There was no explanation for the sudden takedown of Cooking Mama: Cookstar. However, a tweet alleged that the game was mining cryptocurrency using players’ Nintendo Switch consoles.

But the official Cooking Mama: Cookstar account on Twitter blasted to the cryptocurrency-mining accusations as “absolutely incorrect.”

https://twitter.com/CookstarMama/status/1246982509528666113

In a statement sent to Nintendo Everything, Cooking Mama: Cookstar developer 1st Playable said there was “no cryptocurrency or data collection or blockchain or anything else shady” in the game’s code.

“The Nintendo Switch is a very safe platform, with none of the data and privacy issues associated with some mobile and PC games,” the developers said. But they didn’t explain why the game had been removed.

Digital Trends reached out to Cooking Mama: Cookstar developer 1st Playable for comment. We will update this story when we hear back.

IGN later confirmed with players who own the game that claims of it causing the Nintendo Switch to overheat were false, but there does appear to be an issue with battery drain. It was also confirmed that Cooking Mama: Cookstar could be played offline, debunking allegation that it always needs an internet connection to enable cryptocurrency mining.

Unfortunately, the controversy didn’t end there, as Twitter user @OtherEhm suggested another possible reason for the game’s removal from the Nintendo eShop: audio files ripped from YouTube.

Finally, an anonymous member of the Cooking Mama: Cookstar development team revealed what they claimed was the real reason why the game is stuck in limbo.

The developer claimed the real reason behind Cooking Mama: Cookstar‘s removal from the Nintendo eShop is a legal battle between Planet Entertainment and the owner of the rights to the Cooking Mama series, Office Create, according to Screen Rant.

Office Create reportedly wanted 1st Playable to keep polishing the game, and possibly even cancel the project, but Planet Entertainment released it anyway. Office Create then contacted Nintendo to take down Cooking Mama: Cookstar from the digital store and to stop production of the physical version, and also blocked advertising on platforms such as YouTube and TikTok, the developer told ScreenRant.

The developer said that Planet Entertainment is launching a lawsuit against Office Create over the money it lost.

“It’s hard to say if it will ever be released properly,” he added.

Aaron Mamiit
Aaron received an NES and a copy of Super Mario Bros. for Christmas when he was four years old, and he has been fascinated…
The Nintendo Switch 2 gets one more last-minute launch game
Two people stand near a bone dragon in Fantasy Life i: The Girl Who Steals Time.

The Nintendo Switch 2 is getting one more launch game on June 5 in the form of Fantasy Life i: The Girl Who Steals Time. Players who currently own it on Nintendo Switch will be able to upgrade to a Switch 2 edition for a fee.

Released last week, Fantasy Life i: The Girl Who Steals Time is a new game by developer Level-5. It's a sequel to Nintendo 3DS cult hit Fantasy Life, a "Slow RPG" in which players take on various jobs from woodcutter to chef. The game was a surprise hit when it released on May 21, surpassing 65,000 concurrent players on Steam at its peak. While it's already available on Nintendo Switch, it will get a Switch 2 Edition in time for the console's launch.

Read more
Nintendo reveals which games aren’t backwards compatible with Switch 2
The Switch 2 next to a TV with Mario Kart.

Ahead of the Switch 2's June 5 launch, Nintendo provided an update on which Switch games aren't fully backwards compatible with the new console. The list includes several games with issues that are currently being investigated, as well as some video streaming apps.

Ever since the Switch 2's announcement, Nintendo has been vague about what Switch games would and wouldn't work on its new console. Many fans previously assumed that backwards compatibility issues would be limited to games that utilized the Joy-con's IR sensors. Nintendo has now clarified exactly what won't work on the new system, as well as what games currently have problems that it plans to address around launch day.

Read more
6 Nintendo Switch games we can’t wait to replay on Switch 2
Nintendo music key art that spotlights several different franchises.

The most exciting thing about unboxing your brand new game console is booting up a new experience that shows off what that upgraded hardware can do. The Nintendo Switch 2 launch lineup isn't thin by any means, but aside from Mario Kart World, most of it is made up of ports like Split Fiction and Cyberpunk 2077. Plus, it can be a big strain on your wallet to buy a new console and more than a couple of games.

That's where backwards compatibility becomes such a valuable feature. We know that a select few major Switch games are getting special Switch 2 editions, but other games will also benefit from the more powerful hardware. After the dust has settled and we're waiting for the next upcoming Switch 2 game, these are the six Switch games we plan on replaying on Switch 2.

Read more