Skip to main content

Microsoft rolls out its big guns, but Xbox Games Showcase misfires

On paper, Microsoft ticked all the right boxes during its Xbox Series X first-party games presentation Thursday. Halo Infinite? Looked good. Fable announcement? Check. A Forza teaser? Nice and shiny.

But the best-laid plans need strong execution. And if the company was looking to make a strong case for people to buy the Xbox Series X this holiday season, it could have done better.

To its credit, the showcase had a very strong start and a solid finish. The extended look at the next Halo installment was exactly what people wanted. It harked back to the first game in the series, showed real-time gameplay, and ended with a nice tease. It also left some mysteries – like Cortana’s potential role in the game – unanswered. Could the demo have been longer? Absolutely – and we’ll have more on that shortly. But it definitely got the presentation off to a strong start.

Similarly, the wrap-up, with the teaser trailer for Fable and the announcement that the Xbox Series X will support over 100 games this winter, put an exclamation point on the system.

The problem was the middle.

Too much padding

Halo: Infinite
343 Industries

For an event meant to showcase the Xbox Series X’s strengths, there was a lot of padding. Obsidian’s Outer Worlds expansion and Grounded will both be out well before the new system. The shout-out to Destiny 2 made virtually no sense, even if an optimized version is on the way for the Series X. This was a showcase that should have looked forward, not backward — even if it involved a Bungie game.

DoubleFine’s Psychonauts 2 is bound to have lots of fans excited, but does the inclusion of a Jack Black song make them anticipate the game any more? It’s hard to make the case for that.

Ninja Theory showed zero footage of Hellblade 2, which made the company’s appearance in this program somewhat baffling. It was as if Microsoft was simply reminding us that the game was in development.

Rather than telling a story or showcasing how games would look on the system, Microsoft showed a lot of trailers and title screens. Only one title showcased what could make playing on the Xbox Series X a different experience than on the Xbox One – The Medium, which renders two worlds at the same time and has you seemingly switch back and forth between them in real time as you progress in the game.

Too many titles

Psychonauts
Psychonauts Image used with permission by copyright holder

The game plan seemed to be to showcase how many titles the Xbox Series X will have: 10 world premieres, 22 console exclusives, 100 titles at launch. That’s not a bad thing, but it’s better to have a dozen must-have titles than significantly more that players don’t grasp (or, worse, don’t care about).

Microsoft could have benefited from highlighting fewer games and showing more actual gameplay. This is where the length of the Halo Infinite demo becomes notable once again. It looked like pure Halo fun, which is great. But it was hard to tell what was new in this game, other than the introductory cutscene. What will Series X players get, beyond 60 frames per second and 4K images? Is the game open-world? If so, as rumored, there were ways to demonstrate that, but Microsoft chose not to showcase them.

Halo is the decision-maker for a lot of people when it comes to Series X. And it would have been a wise move for Microsoft to jettison some of the presentations it showcased in favor of a longer demo for that title. (It also would have been nice for the company to only show real-time footage, rather than pre-rendered scenes, with all games, as Sony did during its PlayStation event a month ago.)

It was a much better performance by Microsoft than its May 7 event, but once again, the company failed to capture and feed the enthusiasm of anyone beyond its most solid customer base. There are lots of unanswered questions about the system, some of which could be game-changers that quickly shift the momentum as next-generation systems race to market. But Microsoft needs to start answering those if it doesn’t want a repeat of the Xbox One’s performance versus the PlayStation 4.

Editors' Recommendations

Chris Morris
Chris Morris has covered consumer technology and the video game industry since 1996, offering analysis of news and trends and…
Every summer 2023 gaming showcase: full schedule of live streams
Detective Pikachu and a Slowpoke wearing a cowboy hat.

Summer is one of the most exciting times to be a gamer, as it's when most video game developers and publishers tease what's coming next. For years, this was all centered around E3, but since that show went away during the COVID-19 pandemic, publishers have switched things up and held a variety of reveal-focused live-stream events throughout the entire season. This year has been no different, especially with E3 2023 is canceled.

On May 24, Sony kicked things off with a PlayStation Showcase that revealed games like a Metal Gear Solid 3: Snake Eater remake and that Bungie is reviving the Marathon series. In June, though, the number of showcases ramped up. Now, things are winding down with new Tokyo Game Show-related events, as well as a second Nintendo Direct. It can be a lot to keep track of, but we're here to help. This is every important, announcement-filled video game live stream that has taken place throughout summer 2023.
PlayStation Showcase: May 24

Read more
Starfield is a success. What does that mean for the future of Xbox?
A ship lands on a planet in Starfield.

Starfield was one of the most vital video game launches ever.
The last couple of years have been full of whiplash for Xbox fans, full of high highs and low lows. After a solid fall 2021 game lineup, 2022 was comparatively barren for first-party Xbox games. Microsoft then started the year on a strong note with Hi-Fi Rush’s surprise launch before crashing and burning with the disastrous release of Redfall, the first heavily marketed AAA game coming out from Bethesda after it was acquired by Microsoft. Starfield, a game that many were uneasy about due to its scope, would inadvertently become a make-or-break moment for Microsoft.
In May, I wrote that Starfield was “the most pivotal game for the future of the Xbox brand since Halo: Combat Evolved” because of what I thought was at stake if it failed. Well, Starfield just launched, and … it’s a hit. It’s not the genre-defining, industry-changing mega-RPG that some fans were lauding it as prerelease. However, it’s still an enjoyable sci-fi adventure that's receiving positive attention despite some drawbacks. And it's already earned over 1 million concurrent players across all platforms. Digital Trends gave it a three-and-a-half star review, writing, “though it can’t nearly deliver on Bethesda’s intergalactic ambitions, Starfield is an impressive space RPG filled with impactful decisions.” On Steam, over 24,000 reviews are averaging a ‘Very Positive” consensus.
While not a total stunner, Starfield hasn't derailed Xbox or caused the public to lose faith in its first-party games; in fact, it has renewed some confidence. Reassessing Xbox’s future post-Starfield, it’s clear that it’s still reliant on something it has struggled with this entire console generation: consistency.
It’s all about consistency
Despite the success of Xbox Game Pass and some excellent first-party games like Pentiment and Hi-Fi Rush, Microsoft has struggled to establish consistency across messaging, game launch cadence, and quality. That has hurt it this console generation, where it has felt like Xbox has promised more than it's delivered despite several game company acquisitions and exciting announcements. It doesn’t help that Sony and Nintendo have been at the top of their game in regard to those things in recent years.

That’s ultimately what put so much pressure on Redfall and Starfield. They needed to pay off an expensive Bethesda acquisition and usher in a steady stream of new Xbox games. Perhaps that’s why the poor quality of Redfall felt like such a slap in the face for Xbox fans. What should’ve cemented a consistent Xbox first-party output instead highlighted all of its problems. This made Xbox’s situation heading into Starfield’s launch feel dire, even more so than it actually was in reality for a branch of a megacorporation like Microsoft.
But now Starfield is here and people like it, even if it has some evident flaws. Starfield was neither the Redfall-level critical flop that would kill Xbox nor the 11/10 game some people expected. It’s just an entertaining RPG that Xbox players can lose themselves in and feel a little bit of console pride over. The vibes across the Xbox community are mostly positive right now, and Microsoft needs to maintain that feeling.
The weak first-party 2022 lineup and the rough state of Redfall left us wondering if the only thing Xbox was consistent at was disappointment, but Starfield and other recent efforts from Microsoft-owned studios indicate that this is not the case. Since Redfall, we’ve got a big Monkey Island-themed update for Sea of Thieves, an excellent remaster of Quake II, a solid Xbox Series X/S port of Age of Empires IV, and Starfield to show that Xbox’s studios are back on track. It’s up to the Xbox team to keep up that momentum after Forza Motorsport launches and the Activision Blizzard acquisition finally concludes this October.

Read more
Rebuild your own nostalgia with this detailed Xbox 360 toy set
xbox 360 mega building set replica

Although Microsoft is shutting down the Xbox 360 Store next year and definitely wants you to pick up its newest console for Starfield, it has still found a new way to appeal to the nostalgia of Xbox 360 players. It's doing so through the new Mega Showcase Microsoft Xbox 360 Collector Building Set, which will be available this October.

This set will be available starting on October 8 and will cost you $150 dollars; that said, you'll only be able to pick one up at Target. Mega makes Lego-like replica models of things for people to build, and this one is intricately designed to look like the launch version of Xbox 360. It's at 3:4 scale and made up of 1342 pieces. With it, players can build a version of the Xbox 360, a controller, and a case and disc for Halo 3. Even the packaging it comes in looks like the boxes Xbox 360 consoles came in at release. 
Once built, this model will actually have working lights and a disc drive, as well as a hard drive and side shell panels that are removable. It obviously won't be able to play actual Xbox 360 games, but it still looks like a faithful recreation of Microsoft's classic game console. This is far from the first time we've seen video games and their consoles branch over into the work of buildable toys, as Nintendo patterned with Lego to create various Mario sets as well as a replica NES.
The Mega Showcase Microsoft Xbox 360 Collector Building Set releases exclusively at Target on October 8.

Read more