Skip to main content

Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice review

The brutal nature of Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice make victories that much sweeter

Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice
Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice
MSRP $60.00
“Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice is an uncompromising yet immensely satisfying action game.”
  • Creative enemy design
  • Gorgeous environments
  • Stealth mechanics fit in perfectly with the combat
  • Posture system makes battles engaging and skill-based
  • New traversal options add variety
  • The brutal difficulty can be unfair

I died fighting the first enemy I encountered in Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice. That moment set the tone for how the rest of my playthrough would go. This may not come as a surprise if you’re familiar with FromSoftware, the Japanese developer behind Bloodborne and the Souls series, known by many as some of the most difficult games ever made.

While Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice lightly follows in its predecessor’s footsteps, it’s different in many ways. With an emphasis on stealth, skills, and precise combat with varied enemies, it ditches some of the traditional role-playing elements we’ve seen in those previous games. That said, it is not a casual take on the studio’s formula. Instead, Sekiro is the hardest game FromSoftware has ever made, and that just makes the victories all the more satisfying.

Welcome to the (sort of) real world

Set in Sengoku-era Japan, Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice puts you in the shoes of the One-armed Wolf. Sworn to protect the Divine Heir, a child whose magical abilities could be the key to reversing a horrible plague, the Wolf quickly finds himself outmatched by a skilled swordsman. In the very short battle, he loses his arm and is presumed dead — but a supernatural force resurrects him. He is then guided to find his child master and take revenge on those responsible.

In stark contrast to the ambiguous narrative style that FromSoftware games are known for, Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice brings a tale that you can easily follow. It relies more heavily on traditional storytelling, dialogue, and cinematics so you don’t have to look through every item description in your inventory to keep up. Special Memories found on bosses give you insight into their motivation and past, and it’s this kind of refined presentation and character development that makes each villain much more menacing. While lore can still be found by reading through the inventory, it’s clear that director Hidetaka Miyazaki really wanted players to understand what’s going on this time around.

Combining stealth elements from games like Tenchu and classic FromSoftware action, the combat in  Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice is among the best-realized in any video game. Fights take on many different forms. Villains will taunt you in a manner that is enraging, testing your ability to remain calm as you master their moves and go in for the final kill.

As the one-armed Wolf you’ll have to learn how to quickly deflect a flurry of attacks while carefully slashing once or twice.

Combat with standard enemies typically involves sneaking behind an unsuspecting target and delivering a fatal blow. These stealthy executions can alert nearby enemies, so you’d better be prepared to engage in battle or find a way to escape these newfound friends. Facing against larger groups requires true Shinobi skill, as you can utilize hit-and-run tactics to thin the herd, leading to assassinations and ambushes that will truly make you fill like a ninja.

Sidestepping, rolling, and delivering frantic swipes may have worked well with the Stamina system used in previous FromSoftware games, but in Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice it’s all about breaking down an enemy’s posture and maintaining your own. The strength of your Posture determines how many incoming attacks can be blocked before being left vulnerable to a powerful, final blow. This means that enemies must be worn down before you can deliver the kill.

It makes nearly every battle a sort of dance, as the one-armed Wolf you’ll have to learn how to quickly deflect a flurry of attacks while carefully slashing once or twice before going on the defensive again. Posture recharges for you and enemies so you’ll have to determine when it’s worth being aggressive. A perfectly timed and well-executed dance is the key to success in combat, cutting down on the time it takes to win a fight considerably. Choosing the wrong move gives the enemy an opportunity to land a flurry of their own hits, oftentimes leading to your own death and facing the same enemy again.

And boy are you going to guess incorrectly a lot. Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice is more punishing than any FromSoftware game before it. Its early bosses rival the later ones in the first Dark Souls, capable of decimating your health if you so much as hesitate when blocking a single attack. With enormous health bars and Posture that seems to never break, battles can go on for several minutes and demand your complete attention.

You can pause the game at any time to regain your focus since Sekiro is completely offline, but this comes with a disadvantage: No one can help you if you’re struggling with a tricky fight. For us, that meant battling the same enemy for five hours, and getting stuck on the final boss – a foe we’re still currently grappling with.

This is an issue even with the resurrection system that allows you to revive yourself once after being killed. Getting struck down might cause enemies to relocate, giving you a chance to revive, heal up, and unleash your own strikes before they can respond. It’s a neat twist on the Souls formula that can sometimes turn the tides in battle, but it’s not always gamechanger.

Sekiro Shadows Die Twice review
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Miyazaki’s team may have gone overboard with the difficulty this time around. When the second or third boss in Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice is capable of hindering all progress for countless hours at a time, some adjustment to the difficulty is necessary.

More than just a sword

Alongside the Posture system enters the Shinobi Prosthetic, an attachment similar to Nero’s Devil Breaker in Devil May Cry 5. Ranging from blinding firecrackers to staggering axes, the prosthetic can be equipped with different attachments to add a new dynamic to combat. In my experience, however, the prosthetics can be easy to forget about, but when you find a use for one, it can make seemingly impossible fights a little more manageable.

The grappling hook is the most useful prosthetic of the bunch, giving you traversal options not found in most other Souls-like games. You can use it to zip away to a nearby rooftop if a battle becomes too overwhelming, giving you time to plan a follow-up attack as enemies lose track of you. It also makes Sekiro’s version of Japan a joy to explore. Its gorgeous environments range from flaming villages to icy, snow-covered mountains and dense forests, all of which are rewarding to traverse.

Hidden items, allies, and characters can be found far aboveground, and well below it. If you head down an unsuspecting passageway, there’s a high probability that you’ll find something useful or bizarre at the end. Thankfully, even if you encounter an enormous monster, a series of interconnected passages and Sculptor’s Idols (similar to the bonfire checkpoints in the Souls series) mean you don’t lose much progress upon death. Your statistics are primarily tied to items you find in the world and on enemies, as well, so you don’t lose mountains of potential upgrades if you happen to stumble against a random soldier.

15 minutes of us trying to beat a boss

Yeah, we died. A lot. This game is hard.

Our Take

We can taste victory, and we’re already confident that Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice is a must-play game for fans of From Software’s other titles. Its difficulty might pose a barrier for newcomers, so it may not be the first Souls-like game you’ll want to start with. It demands a level of determination and skill that far exceeds every other Souls-like game before it, but just as Sekiro can be downright infuriating, it can be just as, if not more, satisfying. It feels like the uncompromising realization of FromSoftware’s vision, and you can’t ask for much more than that. If FromSoftware intends to make a sequel, we’ll have our controllers ready – and the backup controllers for when we break the first ones.

Is there a better alternative?

For newer players, you’ll find Dark Souls III or Bloodborne less daunting, but we’ve never seen melee combat in a game quite like Sekiro.

How long will it last?

Playtime will vary depending on skill level, but we reached the final boss in just under 30 hours.

Should you buy it?

Yes, as long as you’re patient!

Editors' Recommendations

Gabe Gurwin
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Gabe Gurwin has been playing games since 1997, beginning with the N64 and the Super Nintendo. He began his journalism career…
Where to find smithing stones in Elden Ring
Player stands next to the blacksmith in Elden Ring.

Elden Ring players need to upgrade their weapons to survive in the Lands Between. Other than equipping Ashes of War, you can use smithing stones to upgrade your favorite weapon's overall damage. However, there are several schools of thought in play when upgrading weapons. Some weapons require different kinds of smithing stones, whereas others require different tiers of smithing stones. Furthermore, you can only upgrade weapons on your own up to a certain point. Then you'll have to bring them to Roundtable Hold and talk with Smithing Master Hewg.

Smithing stones are the most important piece of the upgrading puzzle. They're scattered all over the Lands Between but can also be found as random pick-ups from dead enemies. So, where do you find more smithing stones in Elden Ring? Specifically, where can players look if they need to find them quickly?

Read more
Elden Ring beginner’s guide: 8 tips and tricks to get started
Elden Ring's hero shines a torch in a fleshy cave.

The Lands Between is an uncharted wonderland of secrets, dangers, and surprises. Mixing the tight combat mechanics, satisfying level design, and tough boss mechanics with an impressive open-world makes Elden Ring the crowning achievement of developer FromSoftware. There are many folks who might be interested in giving this game a shot but are unsure whether or not they will be able to enjoy it, considering the reputation the devs have earned for making difficult games that demand from their players. On the other hand, those who love that challenge may not be prepared for all the new systems this game brings.

There's still no true difficulty setting to pick from when starting Elden Ring, for better or worse, and the game likes to keep many things obscured or hidden. That includes some mechanics and tips that could go undiscovered for your entire time playing. Elden Ring is perhaps the most accommodating to those new to the Souls-like game, as long as you know a few key tips. Whether you've linked the first flame a dozen times or never pulled off a parry, here's a spoiler-free beginner's guide to getting started in Elden Ring.

Read more
Elden Ring closed network test: What is it and how to play
The Land Between in Elden Ring.

Fans of the Dark Souls games, or FromSoftware in general, have been eagerly awaiting the newest game from the studio. Originally planned to be released in January, we learned that Elden Ring would be pushed back to February 25. To make this news a little more palatable, the announcement was coupled with the news that players would be able to sign up for a closed-network test of the game, allowing us a chance to play the game early. As for the reason for the game's delay, FromSoftware says, "The depth and strategic freedom of the game exceeded initial expectations. Thank you for your trust and patience." While a delay is never fun, it does appear that the reason, as well as news of this test, will result in a more polished final product.

You're probably wondering what the details of this closed network test are. Who can participate? When is it being held? How do I register? Thankfully, all those details have been made available right alongside the announcement of the test itself. If you're interested in registering for a chance at getting an early look at the world of Elden Ring, here's everything you need to know about how to play the beta.

Read more