Skip to main content

$17K Apple Watch is ‘missing integrity and substance,’ asserts maker of $13K phones

“We need to ask ourselves what luxury is. It’s not only about the price tag. But that’s the main thing about the Apple Watch Edition.”

That’s what Max Pogliani, CEO of Vertu, told us when we casually asked him about the gold Apple Watch. Vertu is a British company that has mastered the art of making luxury smartphones. The company is the definition of luxury tech, and in his eyes, the Apple Watch Edition isn’t a player. It’s built around its big price tag, but lacks the luxury credibility to back it up.

Recommended Videos

“For me, [the Apple Watch is] missing integrity and substance.”

But either way, the Apple Watch may help his company out. The Watch Edition has prompted conversations about costly mobile devices, instead of rehashing the tired lines that luxury tech is “about expensive things for stupid people with more money than sense.”

While he admires Apple and its achievements, he believes Vertu is on a whole different level.

“We don’t consider our smartphones competing with an iPhone,” he said. “I don’t think Vertu should compete with Apple in the Watch category either.”

The Watch Edition is missing vital luxury characteristics

Why isn’t the Apple Watch Edition a luxury product to Vertu? The only major difference between a $350 Apple Watch and a $17,000 gold Watch Edition is the material used to make the casing. This is the what increases the price. “While it’s true Apple is entering what we define as the luxury space, the material change is only part of the luxury process,” Pogliani said.

The alteration of material used for production, and the effect that has on the price tag, is the only parallel between what Apple is doing with the Watch Edition, and Vertu’s smartphones. “This is where it ends,” he stated.

So what’s missing? Pogliani was very clear, “For me it’s missing integrity and substance.” He broke down Vertu’s recipe for luxury success into three elements: style, technological parity, and bespoke services. “We mix these three together in the best possible way we can. It’s a richer offering, and what people expect luxury to be.”

“It’s about differences that only people in the know, know.” He used the hand polished titanium side panels of Vertu’s Aster phone as an example. The effect cannot be replicated by a machine, but it’s something only a connoisseur would be aware of, and who would understand the hours of craftsmanship that went into it.

7JZ2H_vertu_aster_lifestyle_22
Vertu Aster Image used with permission by copyright holder

The Apple Watch Edition doesn’t come with additional features over its cheaper sister models, and crucially doesn’t have unique aspects that are only possible when something is made by hand. The Watch Edition may walk the walk, but it doesn’t talk the talk, especially upon close examination.

Does this mean Vertu’s not interested in wearables?

The Apple Watch Edition is not Vertu’s idea of a true luxury product, and a smartwatch also isn’t in the company’s plan. Vertu’s not dismissing wearables though. “Watch this space,” Pogliani intriguingly told me. However, he has no intention of rushing in without having come up with the right product.

“I don’t think the answer for us would be a simple luxury smartwatch. Wearables are different and can be way more than just a watch, which makes it a much more interesting space to look at.” Pogliani agreed that Vertu’s high-end luxury talents fit in with wearables, given that personal touch is so important to both.

Vertu has already dabbled in providing high quality accessories to its customers, such as its V Headphones and V Speaker audio products. If, or when, it has a go at wearables, the resulting product is likely to be equally closely connected with what the brand does best.

Pogliani told me a story about a passionate Vertu owner, someone who took ownership seriously, to the point where they had visited the headquarters to met the person who had hand made their phone. She sees her Vertu smartphone very differently to a normal smartphone. The latter, she said, was about rushing through life, not having time to stop, and always being on the go.

The Vertu, however, is about consideration, thought, and standing back to deliberate what course of action to take. That, Pogliani said, is the real essence of luxury. The iPhone, and consequently the Apple Watch, are unrefined, noisy, attention seekers. A Vertu wearable would be quite the opposite, he implied. General excitement and interest over the Watch Edition isn’t pushing Vertu into doing anything rash.

Fittingly, given Pogliani’s tale, deep consideration is how Vertu appears to be approaching the future, flashy Watch Editions or otherwise.

Other great DT articles to read:

Andy Boxall
Andy is a Senior Writer at Digital Trends, where he concentrates on mobile technology, a subject he has written about for…
Apple missed a cute, fitting opportunity with the iPhone 16e’s name
A group of iPhone 16e phones arranged in a pattern.

The names of our smartphones matter. Too clunky and we forget, too wordy and we don’t remember, or too bizarre and we won’t say it. They don’t have to mean anything at all, but they need to fit. The new iPhone 16e’s name fits, far more so than the expected alternatives, and it was one of Apple’s best decisions with the phone. But there’s another name I would have preferred even more.
You’re family now

Since rumors began more than a year ago, it was assumed the iPhone 16e would be called the iPhone SE 4, or the iPhone SE (2025), which mostly followed the trend of previous devices in the range. The original iPhone SE was followed by the iPhone SE (2020), then the iPhone SE (2022), so either name was a logical path for Apple to take.

Read more
Why the OnePlus Watch 3 is missing a key Apple Watch feature in the US and Canada
A person wearing the OnePlus Watch 3.

The OnePlus Watch 3 has officially launched and has several new features, including an ECG (electrocardiogram) analyzer, which was unavailable in the second-generation model.

However, as OnePlus told 9to5Google, this feature will not be accessible to users in the U.S. and Canada because the watch has not received official certification for its ECG capabilities from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA). Despite this limitation, all users, regardless of location, will have access to the new “60-Second Health Check-In” feature expected to be released in the year’s second quarter.

Read more
Apple may owe you money for your broken Apple Watch
Apple Watch Series 3 on wrist.

If you were an early adopter of the Apple Watch, you might be eligible for cash compensation. Apple has agreed to settle a class-action lawsuit filed five years ago. This lawsuit covers the first-generation Apple Watch, as well as the Series 1, Series 2, and Series 3 models, according to CNET. The lawsuit was initially filed in the U.S. District Court for the Northern District of California and claimed that these early Apple Watches had batteries that swelled over time, which could potentially damage other essential components.
Settlement details for users
Apple Watch Series 3 Digital Trends

Apple will compensate affected customers between $20 and $50 for the settlement. The exact amount will depend on the number of claims submitted. To be eligible, you must have owned an affected Apple Watch and contacted Apple customer service about the issue between April 24, 2015, and February 6, 2024.

Read more