Skip to main content

Disney Dreamlight Valley sets itself apart from Animal Crossing in 5 key ways

Animal Crossing is one of gaming’s most popular franchises, giving players a much-needed break from the world of challenging, narrative-driven, and thought-provoking adventures in favor of zen community management. Few other games have managed to match its unique gameplay loop in ways that feel equally rewarding and relaxing, but that’s not stopping Disney from shooting its shot at the genre with Disney Dreamlight Valley.

While the two games are no doubt very similar, Dreamlight Valley has a handful of notable features that will likely sway many players in one direction or the other. Let’s take a look at five of the biggest ways these two life simulation titles differ from one another.

Further reading

It’s structured more like a role-playing game

Donald Duck walks through a town in Disney Dreamlight Valley,

Animal Crossing games usually get right to the point, letting players build a new town without much of a storyline to bog them down. This is a great thing for folks who just want to get down to business, but Dreamlight Valley trades that thin premise for a considerably more detailed story and role-playing design. In this narrative-based approach, you follow a long and winding questline to solve the mystery of The Forgetting — an event that has caused all of the Disney characters to lose their memories.

While there is still plenty of freeform crafting, town-building, and laid-back events to partake in while playing Dreamlight Valley, its sports a variety of biomes to explore and quests to complete along the way to figuring out who’s behind The Forgetting. As you push the story forward, you’ll unlock new mechanics, skills, and more that will aid you in making your town everything you’ve dreamed it would be, all while expanding your friendships with each of the Disney characters who have taken up residence there.

It features tons of familiar faces

A player walks by Wall-E while heading into a cave in Disney Dreamlight Valley.

Animal Crossing has no shortage of adorable animal pals that can join your town, and many of them have become beloved and well-known enough to be recognizable even by a few folks who don’t even play the franchise. But you’d be hard-pressed to find someone who doesn’t recognize most of the massive lineup of Disney characters in Dreamlight Valley, from staples like Mickey Mouse, Goofy, and Scrooge McDuck to adored Pixar favorites like Moana and WALL-E.

As you meet these lovable Disney characters, invite them to live in or around your town, and begin to level up your friendship by completing quests with them, you’re rewarded with a vast array of items and cosmetics based on their individual movies. They even serve functional purposes that range from opening up entirely new features and granting you new tools, to simply hanging out with you to assist with your daily tasks. This increased incentive for cultivating deeper friendships with all of the characters makes Dreamlight Valley feel even more alive than you might initially expect.

It’s generally more convenient and efficient

Animal Crossing has long been the undisputed leader of life sims, and whether Dreamlight Valley will manage to make a mark anywhere near as big is yet to be seen. However, Animal Crossing has one major problem that even most diehard fans will admit: performing many tasks in the game can be immensely time-consuming and inefficient for no real reason at all. For instance, crafting has to be done one item at a time with needlessly long animations and pointless dialogue, while moving homes and other structures can take days of work and cost tons of money. This is before factoring in the frustration of replacing broken tools often.

Even in its early access state, it’s already a considerably more efficient experience. Crafting is an extremely fast and straightforward affair, and you can craft as many items as you want at one time. Meanwhile, every structure (including homes), plant, or piece of furniture can be moved at any time to nearly anywhere without spending money. As for tools — nothing to fear there, as your tools never break, meaning you can dig, mine, and fish all you’d like.

Food and farming serve a real purpose

Animal Crossing‘s food is largely aesthetic, with players only needing to chomp down on an occasional fruit to aid them in removing large trees more efficiently. For better or worse, Dreamlight Valley makes food a much more important component of its moment-to-moment experience, asking players to manage an energy bar by frequently consuming various ingredients or dishes. Despite the abundance of fruits to be harvested all around the town and beyond, keeping your energy up can prove to be a bit tedious — at least until you’ve mastered the art of cooking.

Energy runs out pretty quickly while performing tasks like mining, fishing, and digging, so it’s not unusual to spend a surprising amount of time opening up your inventory to eat some food. However, by cooking and eating high-quality dishes, you can give yourself plenty of bonus energy and reduce the frequency of needing to eat. As such, the game’s farming element becomes invaluable, as you won’t be able to make those top-notch dishes if you don’t have all the required ingredients. So if you enjoy the process of planting, harvesting, and cooking dishes, Dreamlight Valley has you covered.

It’s a free-to-play game

A town landscape appears in Disney Dreamlight Valley.
Image used with permission by copyright holder

Perhaps the biggest and most important difference between Animal Crossing and Dreamlight Valley is that the latter is free-to-play — or at least it will be. Unless you have Xbox Game Pass, Dreamlight Valley‘s current early access period requires you to purchase one of its Founders Packs to play right now. However, when it fully releases in 2023, it will be entirely free to download and play on every platform.

As a free-to-play game, Dreamlight Valley has some monetization, but so far, it doesn’t seem to be particularly invasive. A timed battle pass system known as the Star Path allows you to unlock various Disney-themed items and cosmetics, and an upcoming in-game store will offer similar options. Developer Gameloft has promised there will be no paywalls or pay-to-win items in Dreamlight Valley, so things are looking good for those who want to play for free.

Disney Dreamlight Valley is in early access now on Xbox One, Xbox Series X/S, PS4, PS5, Nintendo Switch, and PC.

Editors' Recommendations

Billy Givens
Billy Givens is a freelance writer with over a decade of experience writing gaming, film, and tech content. His work can be…
If you love game history, you need to try Atari 50: The Anniversary Celebration
The Atari logo appears in gold.

Video game collections are becoming more common these days as companies look back on their past. That’s great for game preservation, but collections like Super Mario 3D All-Stars can ultimately feel underwhelming when the end product is little more than a simple port. Atari’s classic lineup of games is no stranger to this treatment; you can play an Atari 2600 game collection on pretty much any platform you desire. Due to the overwhelming amount of Atari collections out there, Atari 50: The Anniversary Celebration might not seem like a compelling release at first.
That’s why it’s more of a surprise that it sets a new standard for this kind of game collection.
Atari 50: The Anniversary Celebration Trailer
In practice, Atari 50 feels like a museum exhibit-turned-video game. It made me feel like I was walking through the Smithsonian’s The Art of Video Games exhibit for the first time, except everything is about Atari's 50-year history. Not only does Atari 50 contain everything from Pong to some of the weirdest titles the Atari Jaguar had to offer, but it embellishes those games with trivia, scans of game-related material from the time, and video interviews with people connected to them. Anyone who loves gaming history owes it to themselves to check out Atari 50.
Eclipsing other collections
Digital Eclipse has been bringing old games to new platforms for years -- it made Atari game collections for the original PlayStation. Over time, it has slowly put more effort into its approach, moving beyond mere emulation. Earlier this year, Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: The Cowabunga Collection included the Turtle’s Lair, which had boxes, manuals, ads, catalogs, comics, TV show clips, and development document. Atari 50 takes that one step further by transforming similar content into exhibit-like Interactive Timelines.
From its title screen, you can immediately access almost all of Atari 50’s 100-plus game lineup. The real draw, though, is choosing one of five Interactive Timelines recounting Atari’s 50-year history. Arcade Origins focuses on the founding of Atari, its earliest success, weird prototypes, and classic arcade games that were released from 1971 to 1984. “Birth of the Console” is about the creation, hits, and triumphs of the Atari 2600, while “High and Lows” discusses the video game crash of 1983 and how the Atari 5200 and 7800 fared during it.
The context art is created in and the legacy it leaves behind are as important as the art itself ...

Meanwhile, “The Dawn of PCs” recounts Atari’s efforts in the PC space from the Atari 400 and 800 in 1979 until the rare Atari Falcon’s release in 1992. Finally, “The 1990s and Beyond” covers everything else, emphasizing the Atari Lynx handheld and 32-bit Atari Jaguar home console. Games will pop up as players navigate these timelines, and you can play them at the press of a button. As is always the case with Digital Eclipse collections, the emulation is smooth, and players can access various visual filters and even the instruction manuals when pausing.
On top of that, almost every game included has some piece of trivia, scanned development document or ad, preserved commercial, or relevant interview to check out. Notable former Atari developers like Pong creator Al Alcorn and programmer Tod Frye frequently appear in these videos, but other prominent industry figures like Double Fine’s Tim Schafer and former Epic Games dev Cliff Bleszinski show up to offer their thoughts. The context art is created in and the legacy it leaves behind are as important as the art itself, so it’s incredible to see Digital Eclipse’s effort to include all this supplemental information.

Read more
No Man’s Sky 4.0’s difficulty options make the space game feel new again
No Man's Sky warp drive

You’d think space was the final frontier, but 2016’s spacefaring exploration sim No Man’s Sky seems to keep finding new ways to expand and improve its eye-watering collection of features. What began as a quiet trek through a galaxy comprised of over 18 quintillion lonely planets is now a far more comprehensive game with a more sophisticated suite of gameplay options, including frontier towns to run, outlaw space systems to smuggle goods through, multiplayer missions to complete alongside your friends, and a fully-fledged story campaign to follow at your own leisurely pace.

It’s also recently been updated to its fourth major iteration as of October 7. That’s when developer Hello Games unleashed the 4.0 update, also known as the Waypoint update, coinciding with the long-awaited Nintendo Switch release. As a result of the 4.0 update, long-term No Man’s Sky fans were once again treated to an impressive array of improvements, including boosts to visual fidelity, better legibility within menus, and a noteworthy overhaul to inventory management that also left some players momentarily disheartened.

Read more
Hello Neighbor 2 offers impressive open-ended puzzling and one creepy villain
Theodore Masters Peterson in Hello Neighbor 2

Hello Neighbor from 2017 was a thematically creepy game. It followed the story of protagonist Nicky Roth, who, through the player’s input, infiltrated the labyrinthine house of an unhinged man with a few too many dark secrets rolled up his sleeves. Without giving too much away, the original’s three main acts were filled with the same sort of horrors one might expect to find if they were to rummage around in their shady next-door neighbor’s basement in the middle of the night -- only to find the aforementioned neighbor creeping around the corner with a hatchet and a menacing glint in their eye.

But the average neighbor doesn't keep macabre secrets behind traps and puzzles in their basement, which means Hello Neighbor 2 could be the next big thing for anyone who ever fantasized about solving mysteries in the dead of night. Don’t try this at home -- er, your neighbor’s home -- but do try Hello Neighbor 2.

Read more