Skip to main content

Digital Trends may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. Why trust us?

Xbox One X vs. PS4 Pro

If you were someone who missed out on the past generation of consoles, or you aren’t ready to make the jump to the PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series X and S quite yet, now is actually the best time to invest in the previous generation’s hardware. Not only are you getting the best versions of each console (the PS4 Pro and Xbox One X) for a cheaper price, but they also are coming with massive libraries of games to choose from. Plus, you can expect plenty of the new-generation games to also run on these machines, meaning you won’t miss out on most of the big titles.

Unlike the jump from the Xbox One to Xbox One S, the X is actually better in several key technical areas. The same goes for the PlayStation 4 Pro when compared to the jump from the PS4 to PS4 Slim.

With that background in mind, let’s compare the two souped-up consoles side by side, considering all major factors. We hope that this guide will help you decide between a PS4 Pro and an Xbox One X.

Note: The Xbox One X and the PS4 Pro were discontinued in the past year, so you can no longer purchase a new one of either console. However, there are plenty available in most resale markets.

See more

Specs

 

Xbox One X

Xbox-One-X-Chip

PlayStation 4 Pro

PlayStation-4-Pro

Dimensions 11.8 x 9.4 x 2.4 inches 12.8 x 11.6 x 2.1 inches
Weight  8.4 pounds 7.2 pounds
Color Black Black
CPU 2.3GHz x 86 AMD Jaguar eight-core (custom) 2.1GHz x 86 AMD Jaguar eight-core
GPU 6 teraflops (TFLOPS), 40 customized compute units @ 1,172MHz 4.2 teraflops (TFLOPS), 36 improved GCN compute units @ 911MHz
Memory 12GB GDDR5 RAM 8GB GDDR5 RAM
Memory bandwidth 326GB/s 218GB/s
Storage 1TB 2.5-inch 1TB 2.5-inch
Optical drive 4K UHD Blu-ray Blu-ray
4K Yes Yes
HDR Yes Yes
Ports HDMI 2.0a in/out, 3x USB 3.0, S/PDIF, IR out HDMI, 3x USB 3.1
Online subscription Xbox Live ($60/yr) PS Plus ($60/yr)
Connectivity Yes Yes
Price Officially discontinued Officially discontinued
Availability Used or from secondary retailers as supplies last Used or from secondary retailers as supplies last
Digital Trends review 4 out of 5 stars 4 out of 5 stars

Hardware and performance

Xbox-One-X-hardware
DigitalFoundry

Under the hood, the most striking differences between the PS4 Pro and Xbox One X are in their memory and GPUs. Xbox One X’s GPU clocks in at an impressive 6 teraflops, with 40 customized compute units at 1,172MHz, greater than the PS4 Pro’s 4.2 teraflops, with 36 improved GCN compute units at 911MHz. In terms of raw power that makes the Xbox One X more comparable to PC GPUs like the Radeon RX 480. Memory is also significantly boosted at 12GB of GDDR5 RAM versus the PS4 Pro’s 8GB of DDR5, pushing the Xbox One X’s memory bandwidth up to 326GBps over 218GBps on the Pro. The difference in CPU power is much narrower, but the customized Jaguar cores in the Xbox One X may squeeze out better performance in testing.

With such a gap between GPU and memory, the Xbox One X consistently outperforms the PlayStation 4 Pro with third-party games — though there are occasional exceptions.

Winner: Xbox One X

Resolution

Anthem-Xbox-One-X
Anthem running on Xbox One X Microsoft E3 2017 Press Conference

One of Xbox One X’s best perks is its ability to run games in 4K resolution at a steady 60 frames per second, which we see showcased in many of Microsoft’s first-party titles such as Forza Motorsport 7. Many Xbox One games, including third-party titles, can run at native 4K. The Pro’s record has been spotty, with developers using techniques like checkerboarding to improve visuals, but not consistently hitting 4K in practice — and these games often take a frame rate penalty.

Xbox One X also provides better support for users without 4K televisions. Microsoft requires that all games that are natively at higher resolutions use super-sampling with 1080p displays. This means regular HD televisions will get richer images than with a standard Xbox One. Support for this feature has been inconsistent with the PS4 Pro, even in first-party titles, such as The Last Guardian.

Winner: Xbox One X

Home theater support

Theater-Popcorn
Image used with permission by copyright holder

The Xbox One X features a 4K UHD Blu-ray optical drive, similar to the Xbox One S. Although the PlayStation 4 Pro is built specifically to support 4K gaming, it still only includes a standard Blu-Ray player, which is incapable of playing UHD Blu-Ray discs. The PS4 Pro can stream 4K video through apps such as Netflix and Hulu. Xbox One X also offers a superior home theater experience for audiophiles, thanks to bitstream audio passthrough and Dolby Atmos support.

Winner: Xbox One X

Virtual reality

Image used with permission by copyright holder

Providing stronger support for the PlayStation VR was one of the main selling points for the Pro. All versions of the PS4 work with VR, but the Pro is capable of sharper and more detailed rendering. Graphical upgrades don’t come automatically, however, so only games built specifically to take advantage of the Pro can do so.

Microsoft’s extant partnership with Oculus has led to rumors that Xbox One X may pair with the Rift down the line, but they have since backed away from the idea of entering the VR space any time soon. Microsoft has said in the past that virtual reality and “mixed reality” work best on PC.

As of now, only the PS4 Pro has a dedicated VR headset, and it’s getting better with age.

Winner: PS4 Pro

Upgraded game support

Both Xbox One X and the PlayStation 4 Pro ostensibly support all of the same titles as their standard counterparts. Developers will need to specifically build in features that take advantage of the more powerful consoles, so all titles are playable on Xbox One X and the Pro, but not all games will benefit. A current list of games known to be upgraded on Xbox One X includes the following and many more:

  • Anthem
  • Ashen
  • Assassin’s Creed Odyssey
  • Code Vein
  • Crackdown 3
  • Darksiders III
  • Devil May Cry 5
  • The Division 2
  • Dragon Ball FighterZ
  • The Elder Scrolls V: Skyrim
  • Fallout 4
  • Far Cry New Dawn
  • Final Fantasy XV
  • Fortnite
  • Forza Horizon 4
  • Forza Motorsport 7
  • Gears of War 4
  • Halo Wars 2
  • Killer Instinct 
  • Metro: Exodus
  • Middle-Earth: Shadow of War
  • Minecraft
  • No Man’s Sky
  • Ori and the Will of the Wisps
  • Rage 2
  • Resident Evil 2
  • Resident Evil 7
  • Rocket League
  • Sea of Thieves
  • Shadow of the Tomb Raider
  • State of Decay 2
  • Super Lucky’s Tale
  • Titanfall 2
  • Ghost Recon: Wildlands
  • The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt
  • Tom Clancy’s The Division 2

You can check out the current list of titles supported by the PlayStation 4 Pro here. Being first out of the gate, you would think Sony has the clear edge here, but Microsoft quickly narrowed the gap with a hefty lineup of supported third-party games, as well as added support for older Xbox One games.

Naturally, what matters is not just the games that have upgrades, but the number of total games. In recent years, Sony has trounced Microsoft in the exclusive games department. Microsoft is attempting to close the gap and recently purchased several major studios, including Playground Games, Ninja Theory, and even the massive publisher Bethesda, but Sony’s library of exclusives takes the cake as of now. Microsoft’s commitment to bringing both new and existing games to 4K, however, greatly narrows Sony’s software advantages. Right now, it’s too close to call.

Winner: Tie

Price

The Xbox One X has been officially discontinued by Microsoft, but costs remain around $400, about $50 more than the PS4 Pro. When you look at a detailed breakdown of the specs, it’s easy to see where the difference comes from. However, with the release of a new generation, these prices are very likely to be discounted permanently. In fact, because the Xbox One X has been officially discontinued, you may end up having to buy secondhand for cheaper.

While we think that the extra $100 for the Xbox One X is reasonable given what’s in the box, we understand that $400 — given the $300 to $350 tag on the Xbox One S and PS4 — may be too much of a leap to play the same games in better fidelity. But if your choice is between the best of the best from either Microsoft or Sony, we think the Xbox One X, when all is said and done, will probably be the better value.

Fortunately, when it comes down to cost, the Xbox One X and PS4 are regularly listed at a discounted price or sell for even less than their typical listings. Overall, that means these devices consistently go for less than what you may see listed on their websites. We’ve spotted the Xbox One X listed at about $350 regularly and the PS4 Pro listed at an even lower cost of $300.

Winner: PS4 Pro

Conclusion

Ultimately, Sony was able to score a win over Microsoft with these products; the PS4 Pro supported 4K gaming on its console for a reasonable price, long before competitors. They enhanced the PlayStation VR and made themselves a standout with this console. That said, as time has rolled on, we have noticed some discrepancies for game support for their consoles.  

Keep in mind— the PS4 Pro is not your only option for premium game playing. The Xbox One X is still a worthy contender. Considering the obvious hardware advantages, if you’re on the hunt for a console capable of 4K video, the Xbox One X could be your best bet. (Unless you want VR support, of course.)

Overall winner: Xbox One X

Editors' Recommendations

Will Fulton
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Will Fulton is a New York-based writer and theater-maker. In 2011 he co-founded mythic theater company AntiMatter Collective…
The most common Xbox Series X problems and how to fix them
Xbox Series X

Like any other consoles, the Xbox Series X and Xbox Series S aren't without issues. Even after several years on the market giving Microsoft time to push out updates and fixes, there are still some issues that can crop up.

In this guide, we're going to cover the most common Xbox Series X problems, as well as how to fix them. You can also keep up with all updates, known issues, and potential fixes directly from Xbox.
Get in touch with Microsoft
Before getting to any fixes, take note of the different contact options for Microsoft and Xbox support. There's a robust support system in place, and for certain issues, you'll need to contact Microsoft for a repair or replacement. If you have a smaller issue that we haven't covered in this guide, you can ping us on Twitter @DigitalTrends so we can add it to this guide, as well as tag @XboxSupport. That seems to be the fastest support route.

Read more
All Xbox home screens are getting a PS5-style makeover starting today
An Xbox home screen shows Starfield.

The Xbox home screen is getting a face-lift. Starting today, Microsoft will begin rolling out a freshly redesigned Xbox home interface across Xbox One, Series S, and Series X consoles.

If you're an Xbox owner, you're probably used to the consoles' current design that features a row of recently used apps at the top of the screen and a list of widgets below. Microsoft says it looked at user data and feedback from the Xbox community to create a redesigned experience that's more focused on discovery.

Read more
The best traits to level first in Remnant 2
Three characters shoot at a boss in Remnant 2.

Much of Remnant 2's leveling process is based around increasing the ranks of traits that you'll discover throughout your journe. This will give you plenty of opportunities to build a character that best matches your playstyle. In the game's opening hours, however, each character will begin with just a few traits that can be leveled, and your equally limited trait points can make deciding which of those you want to invest in somewhat of a challenge. In this guide, we'll give you our opinion on which of these are best to focus on for optimizing the early part of your adventure. Here are the best traits to level first in Remnant 2
Best traits to level first in Remnant 2
When beginning the game with a new character, you'll have only five traits – one archetype trait exclusive to the archetype you've chosen and four core traits that every character begins with. Your archetype trait will level automatically as you play with that archetype, so you don't need to do anything with that trait. Instead, let's take a look at the four other core traits and discuss which ones are best to invest in.
Vigor
Vigor improves your overall health, which means you can take more damage before dying. This is likely the most important trait to pump points into, especially when first setting out into the dangerous world of Remnant 2. Enemies hit hard (especially bosses) and you have limited healing options during these opening hours, so you'll need every bit of extra health you can get. It wouldn't hurt to prioritize this trait until you get it to level 10, actually, as you'll be able to get plenty more points as the game progresses, and being able to take a few more hits against the game's first few bosses is immensely helpful. This is even more true for Challengers in team compositions where they'll be tanking and spending a lot of time in melee range.
Endurance
Endurance improves your overall stamina, which will allow you to run and roll more during combat. This is a great option to level up if you're playing a character that is focused on melee, as it will allow you to run more when you get surrounded or roll out of the way of enemy attacks without worrying as much about your stamina meter. For primarily ranged players, though, it's a bit less useful, so you're probably better putting those points elsewhere early on. As with Vigor, though, Challengers will likely benefit most from the trait due to their tendency to be a group's close-quarters combat specialist.
Spirit
Spirit improves your weapon mod power generation. This helps you to earn the ability to use your weapon mods more often in combat, meaning that its usefulness is entirely dependent on how useful your weapon mods are to your build. At the beginning of the game, your weapon mods will be most helpful during boss battles, and you're likely to end them before generating a second use of your mod anyways. Because of this, Spirit is likely better saved for leveling later on so that you can focus on survivability first. Gunslingers, however, are likely to see this as a good option in group settings because they're designed to be a DPS powerhouse.
Expertise
Expertise improves the cooldown speed of your archetype skills. This will aid you in using these skills more frequently, which can be a help against bosses and packs of deadly foes. However, like with Spirit, the usefulness of this trait in the initial few hours of the game is limited due to the already long cooldowns and the speed at which many bosses are likely to fall anyways. While Vigor should still be a priority for most classes, Expertise can be a particularly worthwhile trait for Medics who are playing with a group, as it's vital to keep their healing capabilities available as much as possible.

Read more