Skip to main content

Streaming services are the ‘Wild West’ for political ads, report finds

Many political ads that appear on your streaming services aren’t being fact-checked and could help spread misinformation without being taken down, a new report from the Mozilla Foundation has found.

Researchers at Mozilla found that six major streaming servicesYouTube TV, Hulu, Tubi, Sling, Roku, and CBS All Access — are, by and large, incredibly unclear about what political ads they allow and how they may or may not vet them.

In general, Mozilla found that most services are very opaque in terms of their ad archives and they have unclear enforcement of their policies. Sometimes it’s not clarified if any fact-checking is happening, or if any ads are removed.

This has led to a “Wild West” where dangerous content meant to misinform can seep into your ad reels between episodes of your favorite show.

“There’s a lot of evidence that people distrust social media ads, but they trust TV ads,” said Becca Ricks, a researcher at the Mozilla Foundation who led the work on the report. “My assumption is that people aren’t really thinking about the details of what governing body is in charge of [streaming ads]. People will think it’s the same [as that which controls TV ads].”

Streaming services are an ascendant medium (so they say themselves), and are quickly becoming a new platform of choice for political ads. Because there are so few regulations, however, misinformation can quickly spread with little moderation. And as the U.S. presidential campaigns are spending far less money this year on political rallies and physical events, more money is being poured into online advertising.

Mozilla gave each streaming platform a letter grade based on criteria like, ‘Do they fact check political ads?’ and, ‘How well do they target viewers?’

YouTube TV, owned by Google, got a B+, the highest of the grades. Roku and Tubi got Ds, Sling got an F.

Giving credit where credit is due, Ricks said that CBS All Access and YouTube TV seemed much more “mature” in their approaches to streaming ads. CBS in particular has stated that all its ads go through a two-week vetting process involving their legal and editorial departments. “It felt like they had taken the rules for broadcast and translated it to streaming,” Ricks said. YouTube, owned by Google, has probably been thinking this through, she posited.

There’s a difference, Ricks said, between having proactive vetting policies like CBS’s and being reactive. Roku, for instance, says that advertisers have to provide evidence of their claims. A spokesperson for Roku similar responded with links to their ad archive and advertising guidelines , which stipulate that advertisers cannot promote hate speech or contain “false, misleading, fraudulent, or deceptive claims or content.”

“That’s different than fact-checking,” Ricks said. “They also say that they ban advertisers who promote misleading content. But is that ban retroactive, after the ad has already run? They’re not super open about how they enforce this.”

Another big problem is that unlike a massive platform like Google which collects and tracks all of its own user data, a smaller platform like Tubi outsources these services to third-party vendors, Ricks said. Therefore, Tubi might not even know what kind of targeting algorithm they’re using.

A spokesperson for Google speaking on behalf of YouTubeTV directed Digital Trends to the publicly available information about how Google targets ads and what its standards are.

The other four platforms have not yet responded to a request for comment.

Editors' Recommendations

Maya Shwayder
I'm a multimedia journalist currently based in New England. I previously worked for DW News/Deutsche Welle as an anchor and…
MotoGP Italian GP live stream: How to watch the race for free
MotoGP racer leaning into turn.

MotoGP’s Italian Grand Prix is today, and even though it’s a recorded broadcast instead of the live European broadcast, you can watch the race on CNBC. This opens up quite a few places to watch the live stream online, including several of the best live TV streaming services. There are also a few ways to watch the Italian Grand Prix for free. We’ve rounded up all of the information you’ll need, so read onward for more details.
Watch the Moto GP Italian Grand Prix live stream on Sling TV

While Sling TV is generally a pretty simple live TV streaming service, it gets slightly complicated in order to watch the Italian Grand Prix. You’ll need to subscribe to Sling’s Blue base plan and add the News Extra add-on in order to get CNBC. This would bring a monthly subscription to $46 with Sling, but you’ll be getting access to more than 50 channels, including USA, TNT, NFL Network, and Comedy Central. There isn’t a Sling TV free trial to speak of, but new subscribers can generally find a discount on a base subscription plan.

Read more
How to watch the free Manchester City vs Inter Milan live stream
A soccer field.

The Champions League final kicks off on the hour, with Manchester City taking on Inter Milan in a match that’s should have soccer fans all over the world on the edge of their seats, and there’s a totally legal way to watch the big game — no strings attached. That’s right: there’s a free Man City vs Inter Milan live stream for those in the United States and travelling abroad, and it comes courtesy of Paramount Plus, one of the best live TV streaming services.
Watch the Manchester City vs Inter Milan live stream on Paramount Plus

Paramount Plus is one of the premier standalone streaming services, in part because of its high quality original programming like Yellowstone, and in part because of its growing lineup of sports coverage. There’s almost always something new on Paramount Plus to watch, and because Paramount Plus is CBS’ online streaming platform, today that includes the Manchester City vs Inter Milan game. With a Paramount Plus subscription you’ll get access to other soccer games and even the NFL on CBS. A 7-day free trial is available to new subscribers, which will allow you to watch the Manchester City vs Inter Milan live stream for free.

Read more
The Digital Trends guide to FAST streaming services
Amazon Freevee.

When you talk about the best streaming services, you typically talk about video-on-demand (VOD) services like Netflix. Or Disney+. Or Amazon Prime Video. Or Hulu. And for good reason — they have a ton of paying subscribers. Netflix alone is closing in on a quarter-billion. Disney+ is about halfway there.

And while the numbers drop off a good bit from there, another flavor of streaming should constitute a good bit of the discussion. FAST services — that's the industry acronym for free advertising-based streaming television — continue to grow both in numbers and in popularity. Think of FAST like the streaming version of broadcast TV, or your cable box. Shows are on at the same time for everyone, and everyone is watching the same thing, with ads. Only unlike YouTube TV or Hulu With Live TV, you don't have to pay anything upfront. It's all supported by advertising — you just don't get the "good" channels like you will on the paid services.

Read more