Bring it! Samsung’s Boxee buy is a preemptive strike on Apple and other rivals

Samsung TV Boxee

For Samsung, $30 million is probably just a drop in the proverbial bucket, but spending that cash to acquire Boxee and bring in all 45 staff members is an investment — and perhaps an aggressive move to improve what it can offer consumers in the living room by taking on Apple TV and Roku.

Boxee has always been a software company first, with a particularly keen eye for aesthetic user interfaces and user-friendly content delivery. Much of Samsung’s success on the mobile front is based on Android, but the open-source operating system doesn’t carry over to the company’s TVs. Instead, Samsung’s smart TVs are a mix of homegrown UI and a smattering of apps that many consumers probably don’t think about – or use – very much.

The question is whether Samsung will incorporate Boxee’s user interface into its smart TVs, or launch a new set-top box.

That’s where this deal makes the most sense. Samsung’s smart TV interface isn’t all that compelling, but with the purchase of Boxee, it gains one of the best in the biz.

When Boxee was founded in 2007, its staff wanted to create home theater PC software that aggregated content stored locally on the computer along with video pulled from the Web. It was unique for its time, and it established something of a cult following as it progressed.

The Boxee Box was designed to be the pinnacle of that vision, with a D-Link-manufactured box running an improved version of the Boxee software. After an 18-month period of support, firmware updates just stopped coming, leaving the vaunted box in a state of limbo. Since then, Boxee moved to creating the Boxee TV, only to then rebrand it months later as the Boxee Cloud DVR in early 2013. The acquisition effectively kills access to that service on July 10.

Boxee Box

While the Boxee Box treaded towards outward abandonment, competitors carved out their territory, with the Apple TV and Roku becoming the go-to media streaming set top boxes on the market. Small, robust and customizable (though not always legally), the two small boxes have quietly changed the living-room experience, possibly doing more to cut the cord to cable than Boxee ever imagined it could when its marketing language briefly spurred consumers to do just that.

Not enough cable-free pioneers answered the call, and so Boxee was stuck looking for new funding to ostensibly work on improving the Boxee Cloud DVR, or venture into something a little different. We don’t know for sure, but Samsung will likely look to leverage the brand, win over Boxee loyalists and then go after the masses with something other TV and set top box manufacturers can’t deliver.

The question is whether Samsung will incorporate Boxee’s user interface into its smart TVs, or launch a new set-top box that will compete directly with Apple TV and Roku.

Regardless of the direction, Samsung has an industry-wide issue to contend with: Consumers just aren’t getting into smart TVs.

Apple TV is small and user friendly, but needs third-party tools to do what it’s truly capable of. Roku has a vibrant community that looks for ways to improve the box’s features and access to content. In effect, both are fighting for the same spot in the living room, though at $100 each, it’s also conceivable that some consumers might just have both. Samsung may attempt to compete with Apple and Roku by launching a standalone box like this, but whatever interface its newfound Boxee engineers concoct would likely also appear baked into its smart TVs. 

Ironically, the precedent for this two-pronged approach comes not from Apple or Roku, but Samsung’s Korean rival, LG. As manufacturers were trying to sell the idea of connected TVs over the last few years, LG came to market with the Smart TV Upgrader, a small box that connected directly to the TV via HDMI and to the Internet through Ethernet or Wi-Fi. It was basically LG’s smart TV UI in a box, and it was meant to be agnostic, working with any TV that didn’t have any smart TV features or even Internet connectivity. With apps, access to movies and shows, plus limited integration with mobile devices, it was expected to be a great deal at a $130 price point.

It didn’t turn out that way. Mention the LG Smart TV Upgrader to the average consumer and you’re likely to receive a blank stare. The problem with the box wasn’t its size or price, it was that it didn’t offer a great experience or useful integration, something both Samsung and Boxee tried to overcome themselves. LG acquired the fabled webOS platform from HP as a potential foundation for a new smart TV interface, but the fruits of that effort have yet to be seen on store shelves.

Boxee DVR

Where LG failed, Samsung wants to succeed — desperately. The company is already in the process of building its own ecosystem to rival Apple’s, pushing out its own apps and features on smartphones, tablets and smart TVs to get them all talking to each other. The issue is that this nascent walled garden isn’t a good place to be in its current state, particularly when it doesn’t look as good as it should, and the cost for entry is a little steep.

Apple’s AirPlay streaming protocol is popular because it directly connects a Mac or iOS device directly with a TV (via Apple TV) or home theater system that supports it. Incidentally, the Boxee Box was also AirPlay enabled, allowing for audio and video to be streamed to a TV directly through it. Would Samsung want to include such a feature into a new Boxee set top box, or will it pack in Intel WiDi and DLNA instead, to keep with the PC/Android focus of the company’s varying products? You can bet on the latter, if a box is indeed part of the plan.

Swallowing up Boxee may be Samsung’s pre-emptive move to counter what Apple has in store.

Regardless of the direction, Samsung has an industry-wide issue to contend with: Consumers just aren’t getting into smart TVs. Research firm NPD Group has found that smart TVs are hooked up only 30 percent of the time, and that streaming boxes are expected to overtake Blu-ray players next year. If rumors are true, and Amazon and Microsoft enter the streaming box market, things could get very interesting.

In April, Roku announced it had sold 5 million boxes since its first model in 2008. Apple had sold 5 million of its “hobby” Apple TV in its 2012 fiscal year alone. Boxee never released sales numbers for the Boxee Box, so it’s not clear how many were moved in total. The last confirmed number from D-Link one year ago claimed 200,000 units sold, lagging well behind the other top competitors.

Samsung hasn’t released exact sales figures for its smart TVs, but the market as a whole is expected to expand 55 percent to 141 million smart TVs sold worldwide in 2015, according to iSuppli. With Samsung being among the top manufacturers, a solid chunk of those bear the company’s logo and software. Not one TV manufacturer, including Samsung, has been able to emerge as a frontrunner, much less lead the pack in any meaningful way. This is a major reason why rumors have run rampant on Apple coming out with its own flat-panel TV product to address the confusion in the marketplace.

Samsung Smart TV

That hasn’t happened yet, and swallowing up Boxee may be Samsung’s pre-emptive move to counter what Apple has in store. The company has made a dramatic impact in the mobile space with its Galaxy products, but hasn’t quite done the same in the living room, a battleground still very much up for grabs. Boxee also couldn’t make a lasting impact, and it soon struggled with its identity.

At CES in January, Samsung claimed it was “re-inventing” the TV’s home screen by focusing on five core app tiles that were more reminiscent of mobile devices. There would be support for Android tablets, as well as iOS devices, and a renewed focus on apps and social networking to create a more seamless second screen experience.

The irony is that this was Boxee’s vision back in 2010, for the most part, before it switched gears, except it never integrated mobile devices very well, nor included social networks in a serious way. It could play a wide range of file formats before other boxes could, tap into streaming content from a range of sources and present it all in an interface that was nice to look at and easy to navigate — all of which Samsung has struggled mightily with since first introducing smart TVs.

There’s no telling if the Boxee brand will survive past this point, or even if Samsung will remake its interface using the staff’s expertise, but paying $30 million to acquire everything Boxee offers is probably a lot less than the money spent on creating a smart TV platform that few consumers seem to notice.

Home Theater

LG’s 2019 TVs slide Alexa next to Google Assistant, with Siri on the way

LG announced that Alexa will be coming to its 2019 lineup of ThinQ A.I. TVs, joining Google Assistant. Users will be able to control their TVs and smart home devices with their remote, no extra speaker required.
Home Theater

Throw away those EarPods — we dug up the best headphones in every style

Trolling the internet for hours to find headphones is no way to live. Instead, leverage our expertise and experience to find the best headphones for you. Here are our favorites, with all the features you want.
Home Theater

These TVs might cost less than $1,000, but they certainly don’t perform like it

Check out our picks for the best TVs under $1,000 to enjoy top-shelf features like 4K Ultra HD, High Dynamic Range, and gorgeous image processing. Park yourself here to find the absolute best values in TV land.

Dell slashes price on this JBL Harman Kardon Allure smart speaker

Dell has knocked $135 off the Harman Kardon Allure, but there's a catch: There's a limited amount of stock available, so those wanting to scoop up one on the cheap will need to act fast.
Home Theater

What is Android TV? Google’s smart TV software fully explained

Google's Android TV might not be a household name yet, but with growing support from brands like Sony, it will be soon. But what exactly is Android TV, how do you get it, and what are the benefits? We explain it all.
Movies & TV

The best movies on Netflix in March, from Buster Scruggs to Roma

Save yourself from hours wasted scrolling through Netflix's massive library by checking out our picks for the streamer's best movies available right now, whether you're into explosive action, witty humor, or anything else.

The Best 4K TV deals for Memorial Day: Vizio, Samsung, and LG get discounts

Credit cards at the ready — there's a massive sale on 4K TVs to celebrate Memorial Day, and with pricing starting as low as $230 for a 40-inch and $330 for a 55-inch, there's bound to be something for everyone.
Home Theater

Here’s how to watch The Big Bang Theory online — including season 12

We've rounded up all the best places to watch The Big Bang Theory online (and triple-checked to ensure that the entire article is free of spoilers, so there's no need to read with one eye closed).
Movies & TV

The best shows on Netflix right now (May 2019)

Looking for a new show to binge? Lucky for you, we've curated a list of the best shows on Netflix, whether you're a fan of outlandish anime, dramatic period pieces, or shows that leave you questioning what lies beyond.

Take a gander at the best 4K smart TV deals for May 2019

A good 4K smart TV is the only way to enjoy all your favorite shows, movies, and games in glorious Ultra HD. We've got the best 4K TV deals, including a few Memorial Day weekend offers, right here.
Home Theater

With tvOS 12.3, Apple’s TV app begins its platform-conquering journey

Apple's redesigned TV app experience is here, and it's on Apple TV, iOS, and even some smart TVs. But what exactly is this new experience and how is it different than Roku, Amazon, and others? We've got the answers.

Walmart Memorial Day sale: 4K TVs, laptops, and Apple iPads get price cuts

The Walmart Memorial Day sale has begun. With some pretty nice savings on Apple iPads, Samsung and Vizio 4K TVs, laptops, and Google Home devices, now is a great time to snag some electronics for cheap.
Movies & TV

From Ted to John Wick, these are Keanu Reeves’ best roles

From assassins to computer hackers, football players, and metalhead teens, here's a ranking of Keanu Reeves' best film roles throughout his illustrious, decades-long career in Hollywood.

Sony soundbar systems get huge discounts for Memorial Day weekend

Without a decent soundbar to back up your smart TV, you could easily end up with pretty underwhelming television experience. With so many Memorial Day sales going on right now, it's a great time to pick up a Sony soundbar.