Skip to main content

The music industry reacts to Google Music

music beta by googleEarlier this week, Google finally unveiled its online music service, for the moment simply named “Music beta by Google”. The company has been in a heated race with Apple and Amazon (prior to its Cloud Player launch) to bring cloud-based music programs to the masses, and while the final product has yet to be seen, it took a major step forward with the Tuesday beta launch.

The only hitch is that it went forward without partnerships from any music labels. As it stands, Google’s music service is currently limited to 20,000 pre-loaded songs – songs the Internet giant assured the Google I/O keynote audience were legally in its possession. After Amazon’s legal woes concerning its own music player’s questionable lack of label support, it’s a legitimate concern, but Google headed it off early, claiming the service is “completely legal” because it allows users to store their own music. “We very much respect copyright, and we designed this service so that you can use your own personal music collection out of respect for those who create the music,” he clarified. When asked how Google would make certain the music being stored on its service was obtained legally, the team said it would deal with any problems brought to their attention.

When it came to dealing with record labels however, Google simply said the industry wanted compromises it wasn’t willing to make. And, according to the Hollywood Reporter, the industry is “pissed,” as one NARM (National Association of Recording Merchandisers) conference attendee says. Not only are record label execs frustrated with the entire attempt at collaborating with Google, they’re less than pleased with the comments Google has made about the situation. Google director of content partnerships, Zahavah Levine, said “we’ve been in negotiations with the industry for a different set of features, with mixed results…a couple of major labels were less focused on innovation and more on demanding unreasonable and unsustainable business terms.”

According to the new report, money was one of the largest issues. Companies would get wind Google was paying another label more, and the prices began rising. Piracy was another issue, and the labels wanted to be assured music files from illegal downloading sites would be prohibited, and furthermore wanted Google to “eliminate links to pirate sites and services from its search results.” Google’s own indecision about its product may have also strained its relationship with labels, as did Apple’s competing project, which certain record companies may be trying to sustain a deal with.

Editors' Recommendations

Molly McHugh
Former Digital Trends Contributor
Before coming to Digital Trends, Molly worked as a freelance writer, occasional photographer, and general technical lackey…
Google Pixel 8 vs. iPhone 15: did Google finally beat Apple?
A rose Google Pixel 8 (left) held in hand with a green iPhone 15.

Google unveiled the Google Pixel 8 lineup at its October Made by Google event in New York. Though there aren’t any drastic upgrades to the Pixel 8, Google made some smaller changes that are sure to be welcome among fans.

But Apple also released the iPhone 15 lineup in September — and it's one of the Pixel 8's biggest competitors. If you’re in the market for a new smartphone, which one should you pick up? The Pixel 8 and iPhone 15 are both the baseline models for Google and Apple, respectively, so let’s take a closer look at these two phones.

Read more
Google Pixel 8 Pro vs. iPhone 15 Pro: which $1,000 phone should you buy?
A Google Pixel 8 Pro in Porcelain (left) with an iPhone 15 Pro in Blue Titanium held in hand.


It’s an exciting season for premium smartphones. Apple has unveiled its iPhone 15 Pro with a sleek new titanium finish and ultra-powerful A17 Pro chip. Now, Google has followed that up with its new flagship Google Pixel 8 Pro, packing in a new Tensor G3  processor, an improved camera system, and a wealth of fun new machine-learning-powered features.

Read more
The Galaxy Watch Ultra may have one of the best smartwatch displays ever
Samsung Galaxy Watch 7 Ultra with a square dial leaked render.

The anticipated launch of the Samsung Galaxy Watch Ultra -- along with the company's rumored Galaxy Ring, Galaxy Buds 3, Z Fold 6, and Z Flip 6 -- is just weeks away, but that hasn’t stopped leaks from continuing to trickle in. The latest comes from kro_roe on X (formerly Twitter) and claims that the Galaxy Watch Ultra is expected to feature an anti-reflective coating on its display.

Read more