Skip to main content

5 underrated movies on Netflix you need to watch in September

There are over 3,600 movies on Netflix. With such a wide selection, it can be overwhelming when it’s time to sit down and make a decision about what to watch. With thousands of possibilities, there are that slip through the cracks due to their location on the homepage. However, many of these films are quite good.

Below, we selected five underrated movies on Netflix that you need to watch in September. The selections include one of the last great studio comedies, a pandemic thriller, a reimagining of a popular film from the 1990s, an underseen crime thriller, and a delightful romantic comedy.

This Is the End (2012)

The cast of This is the End faces the apocalypse.
Sony Pictures

It’s been said ad nauseam, but the studio comedy is a thing of the past. It’s rare for major studios to release comedies in 2023 — and even rarer for them to gross over $100 million. It’s been about a decade since we’ve seen a year with multiple studio comedies that churned a profit, and one of those films was This Is the End.

Written and directed by Seth Rogen and Evan Goldberg, This Is The End poses this question: What would happen if a group of comedians were locked in a house during the biblical apocalypse? The comedians playing fictionalized versions of themselves include Rogen, Jay Baruchel, James Franco, Jonah Hill, Danny McBride, and Craig Robinson. This Is the End goes off the rails in all the best ways, providing multiple laugh-out-loud moments in one of the last truly funny studio comedies.

Stream This is the End on Netflix.

The Guilty (2021)

Jake Gyllenhaal sits at a desk in The Guilty.

The pandemic forced filmmakers to get creative with how they tell stories because of the restrictions implemented on sets, including COVID testing and mask mandates. The Guilty utilized dialogue and voice acting to its advantage in a clever 90-minute thriller. Jake Gyllenhaal stars as Joe Baylor, an LAPD cop working the night shift at a 911 call center who receives a disturbing call from Emily Lighton (Riley Keough).

Emily tells Joe that she’s been abducted in a white van, possibly by her ex-husband, Henry Fisher (Peter Sarsgaard). Filmed entirely in the call center, The Guilty is an emotional and edge-of-your-seat thriller carried by Gyllenhaal, who once again proves that he’s one of the most committed actors in Hollywood.

Stream The Guilty on Netflix.

River Wild (2023)

Three people stand in whitewater rafting gear in River Wild.
Universal Studios

The River Wild is a 1994 film starring Meryl Streep about a white-water rafting trip gone haywire after the arrival of two armed killers. River Wild, one of the best thrillers on Netflix right now, is the 2023 reimagining of that film but it flips the formula. Leighton Meester and Taran Killam star as Joey and Gray, two estranged siblings who embark on a white-water rafting trip.

Gray is an instructor along with his childhood friend, Trevor (Adam Brody), who has a complicated history with Joey. Along with two other tourists, the five of them head downriver, and all is fine until the first night, when an accident turns the trip into a fight for survival. A killer is on the loose, but the rough waters ahead may be the deadlier challenge.

Stream River Wild on Netflix.

The Informer (2019)

Joel Kinnaman stands in front of a police lineup in The Informer.
Warner Bros. Pictures

It’s never a good sign when a movie is delayed multiple times. The constant release delays that plagued The Informer decimated its box office profitability. The Informer is entertaining, however, and thanks to streaming, it will find a second life where it becomes a well-received genre film. Based on the novel Three Seconds, the film stars Sympathy for the Devil‘s Joel Kinnaman as Peter Koslow, an ex-con serving as an undercover informant in the Polish mafia who is tasked with bringing down its leader, the General (Eugene Lipinski).

When a mission ends with the death of another undercover officer, Peter is sent back to prison to run the mafia’s drugs, all while continuing to serve as an informant for Special Agent Wilcox (Rosamund Pike). When the General and the FBI fail to keep their promises, Peter decides to escape from prison to save the lives of his wife and daughter.

Stream The Informer on Netflix.

No Strings Attached (2011)

Ashton Kutcher and Natalie Portman on a bed in No Strings Attached
Paramount Pictures

You’ve heard the term “friends with benefits” before. Can two consenting friends have sexual relations without getting into a relationship? In No Strings Attached, that theory is put to the test by Emma Kurtzman (Natalie Portman) and Adam Franklin (Ashton Kutcher). After Emma and Adam have casual sex twice, they form a “no strings attached” relationship.

The duo agrees to have a physical relationship based on sex, keeping emotions out of the bedroom. They also promise to never fall in love. As the relationship progresses, Emma and Adam develop feelings for each other, jeopardizing their arrangement. Though predictable, No Strings Attached is a charming rom-com with two likable actors. Sometimes, that’s all you need.

Stream No Strings Attached on Netflix.

Editors' Recommendations

Dan Girolamo
Dan is a passionate and multitalented content creator with experience in pop culture, entertainment, and sports. Throughout…
3 sci-fi movies on Tubi you need to watch in September
watch sci fi movies tubi in september 2023 back to the future

As streaming heads into a future of bundling and consolidation, one of the more underrated services to keep an eye on is Tubi. As a FAST service, Tubi is free and offers subscribers thousands of hours of programming. The only drawback is users have to watch ads during their movie or TV show, similar to watching a program on cable television.

Once you get past the ads, Tubi has an expansive library with numerous options in all genres, including sci-fi. For September, we narrowed down the list to three sci-fi movies you should watch, including an all-time classic, a vicious monster fight, and a first-person adventure.
Back to the Future (1985)

Read more
The Eagle is one of Netflix’s most popular movies right now. Here’s why you should watch it
Jamie Bell and Channing Tatum in The Eagle.

Thanks to the constantly updated list of the most popular movies on Netflix, the 2011 historical adventure film, The Eagle, is currently enjoying a resurgence. Judging by the film's lackluster box office at the time of its release, the vast majority of subscribers could really use three reasons why they should watch The Eagle on Netflix. But it's already gotten a head start by landing on Netflix's movie chart.

Director Kevin Macdonald and screenwriter Jeremy Brock adapted the film from Rosemary Sutcliff''s novel, The Eagle of the Ninth. The story takes place in the second century A.D., 20 years after the famous disappearance of the Ninth Legion somewhere in Britain. The leader of the Ninth was the father of Marcus Flavius Aquila (Channing Tatum), and his family has suffered a significant loss of status since then. To reclaim his family's lost honor, Marcus resolves to investigate the Ninth's fate and retrieve the eagle standard that was flown by his father's men.

Read more
The 50 best movies on Netflix right now (September 2023)
Karl Urban in Dredd.

Perhaps we shouldn't use the most popular movies on Netflix as an indicator of quality. For reasons we can't explain, the 2017 Woody Woodpecker live-action/animated hybrid film has spent several days in the No. 1 slot. And we can not recommend that flick in good conscience. It's much easier to say good things about the 2012 sci-fi action film Dredd, as well as Olivia Wilde's 2022 thriller Don't Worry Darling, both of which are also on this week's top 10 movies list.

There's almost always something new on Netflix every week, and sometimes we're truly surprised by the obscure films that somehow rise to the top of the streaming ranks. Regardless, we've got our eyes on everything coming and going to give you the most up-to-date info about the best movies on Netflix right now.

Read more